Good Call.... Bad Call... all things Carlton

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Carlton should look to trade pick 11 for an established hard nut inside midfielder or Key Position Forward. With this draft a bit slim with top talent getting something that we desperately need as apposed to a speculative pick could do wonders for us next year...

Good Call... Bad Call?

 

[Blueboys7]

Carlton should look to trade pick 11 for an established hard nut inside midfielder or Key Position Forward. With this draft a bit slim with top talent getting something that we desperately need as apposed to a speculative pick could do wonders for us next year...

Good Call... Bad Call?

Bad Call. We won't get the player we want for that pick, I'd rather keep our first rounder but look to trade later round picks.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Waite should be kept as a CHB next year with Kruezer up forward.

 

[thylacine60]

Finally, a clever thread concept. Bad call, roll the dice - unless a young, truck-built gun is a chance.

 

[Blue Bawls]

Bad call. Rhys O'Keefe.

 

[echelon]

Bad Call. We won't get the player we want for that pick, I'd rather keep our first rounder but look to trade later round picks.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Waite should be kept as a CHB next year with Kruezer up forward.

Good call.

----

Robbie Warnock will be our #1 ruckman next year

 

[Banga19]

Robbie Warnock will be our #1 ruckman next year

Good Call, given a full pre-season and continuing to add bulk will see him probably share number 1 ruck duties with Matty K.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Kade Simpson has the potential to take the next step and become a premier midfielder next year, ala Leigh Montagna this year.

Good call, bad call?

 

[Bell Ringer]

Kade Simpson has the potential to take the next step and become a premier midfielder next year, ala Leigh Montagna this year.

Good call, bad call?

Wishful call, but not outside the realm of possibility. Have similar physiques, however I reckon Montagna has better skills and a better inside game. All left-footers at the club should be made to only kick with their right-boot until February - I'm sick of seeing them do u-turns cos they've never been made to learn.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bower, Jamison, Thornton, Waite & Austin. All ~193cm. One must play as a tall forward next year. Good Call/Bad Call

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Wishful call, but not outside the realm of possibility. Have similar physiques, however I reckon Montagna has better skills and a better inside game. All left-footers at the club should be made to only kick with their right-boot until February - I'm sick of seeing them do u-turns cos they've never been made to learn.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bower, Jamison, Thornton, Waite & Austin. All ~193cm. One must play as a tall forward next year. Good Call/Bad Call

Good call... smart call... educated call Bell Ringer...with all those players being able to play on smalls and talls, there is enough flexibility and depth now to have Waite sent forward. We saw it at times this year that Thornton was thrown forward and to good effect.... Good call

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Carlton are a Key Position Forward away from winning a flag...
Good Call/ Bad Call

 

[Blueboys7]

Good call... smart call... educated call Bell Ringer...with all those players being able to play on smalls and talls, there is enough flexibility and depth now to have Waite sent forward. We saw it at times this year that Thornton was thrown forward and to good effect.... Good call

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Carlton are a Key Position Forward away from winning a flag...
Good Call/ Bad Call

Bad call...vague call... We are probably one quality tall and another good inside mid away.

-----

we should look at taking one of the older uncontracted players such as Robbo or Hall to fill a void for a couple of years.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Bad call
David Ellard will be elevated
Small gritty tough ball winner
Yes he is small but when the ball is on the ground big deal
Yes he is not super quick but can win the ball and dig it out by hand or foot to those that are.
Has been BOG all year for the Ants and maybe F&B in VFL

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

And continuing since gunslinger didn't put out a call.....

Russell should be Carlton's new 'quarterback' next year with his new found confident ball handling and penetrating kicking and speed.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Good call, insightful call, stands out like the nose on your face call. The blues forward line has been one dimensional for the past 7 seasons and are crying out for a second key forward to help release the pressure off fev. Flags are won by teams who have a range of different avenues to goal, because if they didn't the better teams would be able to handle that one major threat (in our case it is Fev).
Carlton won 13 games this year and it's fair to say, were unlucky not to win a lot more so just think what another proven forward would do for Carlton... Which is why i was upset when we couldn't seal the O'keefe deal.
GOOD CALL

 

[Jezza U Beauty]

Bad call Jason. Still a little prone to panicking, and doesn't have the best attacking nous.



Matthew Kreuzer to be used more in attack than in the ruck in 2010 - good call/bad call ?

 

[jonoman89]

Good call. Kreuzer is alrady showing signs of tiredness playing ruck 100%. We need to do it for his development.




We need to harden up and play a bit more unsociably. We have too many players who aren't willing to get down and dirty.

 

[Blue since 72]

Good call/Bad call.........

Could Gibbs play a Luke Hodge role off a HBF next season... Did his apprenticeship down back and has sublime kicking skills?

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Bad call.

Gibbs is best used in traffic and as an attacking weapon.

Good call/bad call: Nick Stevens should be stripped off the vice captaincy and given to Kade Simspon instead.

 

[krayfesh]

Good call. Simmo is awesome. And a born leader.
---

Good call/bad call: Do we leave Fevola out of this years NAB cup and fashion a forwardline around someone else as a sort of contingency plan?

 

[goreds]

Good call/Bad call.........

Could Gibbs play a Luke Hodge role off a HBF next season... Did his apprenticeship down back and has sublime kicking skills?

Bad Call...

We need him to become our prime mover as his ability in traffic and disposal is the best in our side...

He is a pure CENTREMAN



I think Mark Austin is our new C.H.B and should be played there from round 1 next year Good Call/Bad Call

 

[Blue since 72]

Bad Call...

We need him to become our prime mover as his ability in traffic and disposal is the best in our side...

He is a pure CENTREMAN



I think Mark Austin is our new C.H.B and should be played there from round 1 next year Good Call/Bad Call

Good call, ready to release Waite up forward with Aussie coming on.

 

[Jeremias]

Good call. Kreuzer is alrady showing signs of tiredness playing ruck 100%. We need to do it for his development.




We need to harden up and play a bit more unsociably. We have too many players who aren't willing to get down and dirty.

Noone answered this one.....

Bad call.

Every time one of our players does something undisciplined half the board has a heart attack and swears for revenge on the player that made a minor mistake.

If we start playing unsociable football this board will go into meltdown.

By all means be rough and tough, but that should be at the ball and not the man.

If we're good enough to win, we'll win, without resorting to cheap shots and over the top violence.

Good call/bad call: We should seriously consider recruiting Barry Hall.

 

[Blue since 72]

Noone answered this one.....

Bad call.

Every time one of our players does something undisciplined half the board has a heart attack and swears for revenge on the player that made a minor mistake.

If we start playing unsociable football this board will go into meltdown.

By all means be rough and tough, but that should be at the ball and not the man.

If we're good enough to win, we'll win, without resorting to cheap shots and over the top violence.

Good call/bad call: We should seriously consider recruiting Barry Hall.

Bad call... Just don't think we need him if Waite and Kruezer play forward.

 

[blue_ball]

Carlton should look to trade pick 11 for an established hard nut inside midfielder or Key Position Forward. With this draft a bit slim with top talent getting something that we desperately need as apposed to a speculative pick could do wonders for us next year...

Good Call... Bad Call?

Good call for a KPF, as i think hadley was doing fine n that roll b4 getting injured

 

[Korn]

Bad call.



Good call/bad call: Nick Stevens should be stripped off the vice captaincy and given to Kade Simspon instead.

Stevens stripped off vice captaincy - good call
Simpson getting it - bad call
I would prefer the vice captaincy goes to Gibbs or Waite

 

[Sin City]

I think Mark Austin is our new C.H.B and should be played there from round 1 next year Good Call/Bad Call

Great call Big fan of this and freeing Bower and Thornton up to run and create a bit more.

My call: Carlton should keep pick 11 and pick the best available player and develop them rather than trading for some player that a club is all too willing to offload.

 

[Banga19]

Great call Big fan of this and freeing Bower and Thornton up to run and create a bit more.

My call: Carlton should keep pick 11 and pick the best available player and develop them rather than trading for some player that a club is all too willing to offload.

Good call....sensible call...important call.

Best available and have some faith in them. Our team needs more good players, not players picked in positions that we need if it means we take a lesser quality player.