Good call, Bad call.

[TradeDraft]

GC BC - Wood will play more Games then Fraser next season and have a Bigger Impact

 

[DThomas]

GC BC - Wood will play more Games then Fraser next season and have a Bigger Impact

Good call. Wood has shown some good signs, I reckon next year is going to be a big year for him. Fraser will probably find it a bit tough to get in the side.

 

[Histrionics]

GC BC - Wood will play more Games then Fraser next season and have a Bigger Impact

Bad call.

Fraser will be 2nd in line to Jolly. Fraser is better around the grounds than Wood and will have a bigger impact.

 

[mattys123]

GC/BC-Pendles will win the Brownlow next year

Bad Call; Cmon, you must know by now that all umpires hate Collingwood, and never give us what we deserve in terms of Brownlow Votes, as shown by Swanny this year.

GC/BC: Heath Shaw will win the Copeland Trophy next year.

 

[TradeDraft]

GC BC - Jolly will play some games at FF with Fraser and Wood in the Ruck

 

[Histrionics]

Bad Call; Cmon, you must know by now that all umpires hate Collingwood, and never give us what we deserve in terms of Brownlow Votes, as shown by Swanny this year.

GC/BC: Heath Shaw will win the Copeland Trophy next year.

Good call.

If Heath can play 22 games I think he will come very close. He polled really well and missed a few games this year.

 

[danielnajdek]

GC BC - Jolly will play some games at FF with Fraser and Wood in the Ruck

Sorry but that's a shocking call he's a ruckman and will play in the ruck and dominate. There's a spot there for Dawes now with Rocca gone now he needs to show he wants that spot and take it and don't look back.

GC/BC- Steele, Dayne and JMac will play majority of the year (bar injuries) and will give us a glimpse of our gun midfield for the next 10 years

 

[DThomas]

Sorry but that's a shocking call he's a ruckman and will play in the ruck and dominate. There's a spot there for Dawes now with Rocca gone now he needs to show he wants that spot and take it and don't look back.

GC/BC- Steele, Dayne and JMac will play majority of the year (bar injuries) and will give us a glimpse of our gun midfield for the next 10 years

Good call. I reckon Beams and Sidebottom will play 18+ games, with McCarthy playing about 12+.

 

[danielnajdek]

GC/BC-Heath Shaw will lead Collingwood in bounces.

 

[danielnajdek]

Good call. I reckon Beams and Sidebottom will play 18+ games, with McCarthy playing about 12+.

I think that would be perfect however I would like JMac to play a minimum of 18 just to get some games in him.Get him ready for when O'Bree retires

 

[Black Flag]

good call bad call:

players found guilty of misdeeds should pay their debts.

 

[smiddaz123]

good call bad call:

players found guilty of misdeeds should pay their debts.

Bad call: The cleaner deserved it!

 

[danielnajdek]

good call bad call:

players found guilty of misdeeds should pay their debts.

You came on here to say that? Piss of back to the Carlton board

 

[Optimax]

good call bad call:

players found guilty of misdeeds should pay their debts.

How about sexual assusalt and rape?

 

[smiddaz123]

How about sexual assusalt and rape?

Swanny is allowed to do them as well if he wants. He shouldn't have to pay a cent.

Although Swanny could never rape anyone. Who could say no to him?

 

[Black Flag]

How about sexual assusalt and rape?

Good call... we paid.

 

[shawthing09]

GC / BC Buckley's coaching career will ultimately define the way he is remembered long term.

 

[Optimax]

GC / BC Buckley's coaching career will ultimately define the way he is remembered long term.

Bad call Watson and Shaw are both rated as great players still even if their coaching careers sucked ass

 

[shawthing09]

Bad call Watson and Shaw are both rated as great players still even if their coaching careers sucked ass

Probably worded my post wrong. I was more wondering whether people thought. Buckley's coaching career (if succesful) would seperate him from the likes of Hird and Voss and put him in the pedestal the current probably only holds Carey and Leigh Matthews.

 

[smiddaz123]

Bad call Watson and Shaw are both rated as great players still even if their coaching careers sucked ass

Tony Shaw captained a Premiership.
Tim Watson played in 3 Premiership winning sides.

Their playing careers are more decorated than Buckley's sadly, even if Buckley was better, so naturally they will stand out in that regard.

I think it's a GC personally, considering the hype of his appointment.

 

[WinOrLoseILoveEm]

Interesting call. Hope he was call. No excuses otherwise call.



Dale Thomas is the next Marty Clarke. Good call - Bad call?

Bad Call! If you referring to their playing style and committment to the club.

Good Call Bad Call?

Max Houghton will contribute as much as is possible in his part time assistant coach position.

 

[WinOrLoseILoveEm]

BC jack is and always will be a forward from now on and maybe a pinch hit in the back half

On dawes i like the kid, hope he suceeds but please get over your man crush on him, he struggles overhead, he struggles in contested situations and his best role is as an endurance running CHF

GC Feel the same way. Dawes doesnt have the presence ATM for senior footy. He doesnt play like the ball is his and the opposition is paying rent to him. A CHF that doesnt play like the ball is his is just a fit bystander.

He's a 2D player that should be adding depth to his game. Call me a gym junkie but he needs to build up those chicken legs and grow some roots and outbody whoever is near him and have more impact. Rugby players have shown you can balance muscle with speed.

We have the technology let's build a mega Dawes that we can be proud of!!!!