Harry is in!

[Lockyer24]

Harry and Chopper in.
Stanley and Rocca outties.

Jacobs has been dropped from the Hawks for Duddy.

 

[bradrowe#32]

Interesting to see if he gets up. We already have a couple of similar defenders - Maxwell, Goldsack and Cox - so I'll be interested to see how that pans out.

Back luck for Stanners. He has showed a bit so hopefully we'll see him back in there soon.

 

[magpies42]

i wouldnt hold my breath about that, 3 weeks to recover from a shoulder dislocation. if he isnt 100% fit i wouldnt play him not worth the risk especially given we are very likely to play finals

 

[mdc]

If there is a more than negligible risk of re-injuring the shoulder I'm sure the medical staff wouldn't have cleared him. Even if he's not 100% he can still be useful, and we need all the help we can get down back. Danny Stanley will be a solid player, but he's certainly not a defender. Let's just hope O'Brien gets through ok.

 

[Sloth]

Harry and Chopper in.
Stanley and Rocca outties.

Jacobs has been dropped from the Hawks for Duddy.

Remind me again, who is Chopper?

 

[Ekulman]

Remind me again, who is Chopper?

Ben Reid

 

[Sloth]

Just answered my own question. Reid. As in Read. Very clever.

S.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

i wouldnt hold my breath about that, 3 weeks to recover from a shoulder dislocation. if he isnt 100% fit i wouldnt play him not worth the risk especially given we are very likely to play finals

I concur. Good on you Harry if he does make a comeback this week though, assuming he doesn't re-injure his shoulder.

 

[Kirk Hinrich #12]

i wouldnt hold my breath about that, 3 weeks to recover from a shoulder dislocation. if he isnt 100% fit i wouldnt play him not worth the risk especially given we are very likely to play finals

3 Weeks is actually plenty of time to heal from ashoulder dislocation dr Magpies42 you must of missed that at class at medical school. Usually a 3-4 week injury as long as no structure damage, may have some pain after a couple of weeks but a jab will fix that up.

 

[Stakerz]

Good on Harry.

Shattered that Stanners is out, Did alright on Saturday night but Harry is the safer option.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

3 Weeks is actually plenty of time to heal from ashoulder dislocation dr Magpies42 you must of missed that at class at medical school. Usually a 3-4 week injury as long as no structure damage, may have some pain after a couple of weeks but a jab will fix that up.

Okay, I'll bite, I'm a physiotherapist.

Care to explain to me how you can dislocate a shoulder without there being structural damage?

 

[Kirk Hinrich #12]

So what bone broke? Damage to the tissue surronding the shoulder hence soreness but 3 weeks is plenty of time for it to recover

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Ah, gotcha, you've got no freakin' idea what you're talking about.

How much detail do you want in your answer?

 

[Kirk Hinrich #12]

Ah, gotcha, you've got no freakin' idea what you're talking about.

How much detail do you want in your answer?

well then you must be right and it must be stuffed cause he is not playinging idiot.

No major damage is done when a shoulder dislocates in some sports players can continue playing so 3 weeks is plenty of time.

Im going to guess your pretty crap at your job like most physio's

 

[The Royal Sampler]

well then you must be right and it must be stuffed cause he is not playinging idiot.

No major damage is done when a shoulder dislocates in some sports players can continue playing so 3 weeks is plenty of time.

Im going to guess your pretty crap at your job like most physio's

And I'm guessing yours doesn't require you to be able to spell.

If what I've highlighted is true, then why are Sean Rusling and Cameron Cloke on long-term injury lists right now?

If anyone is interested in shoulder anatomy, PM me, because this chump is a waste of my time.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Harry and Chopper in.
Stanley and Rocca outties.

Jacobs has been dropped from the Hawks for Duddy.

HARRAY

 

[Kirk Hinrich #12]

And I'm guessing yours doesn't require you to be able to spell.

If what I've highlighted is true, then why are Sean Rusling and Cameron Cloke on long-term injury lists right now?

If anyone is interested in shoulder anatomy, PM me, because this chump is a waste of my time.

Harry IN

Your knowledge of shoulder injuries OUT

 

[The Royal Sampler]

No major damage is done when a shoulder dislocates in some sports players can continue playing so 3 weeks is plenty of time.

You've made a blanket, ignorant statement which is in no way proven by Harry being included in the side. If Harry injures his shoulder again this year, it will prove you wrong, but if he doesn't, it won't prove me wrong.

 

[Jabso]

In my time watching footy I've seen plenty of shoulder dislocations and players can keep on playing or miss up to 12 weeks. It would be fair to say there must be some degrees as to how it actually affects the player.

 

[Dazman]

Harry IN

Your knowledge of shoulder injuries OUT

Geez he must be playing if he's named.

'cause no one pulls out of the game on gameday. I've never seen it in my life.

 

[LuvMyHawks]

I am just relishing the thought of Hodgey giving him a BIG hip and shoulder. Rubbing my hands together at the thought!!!Once you are out there playing you are fair target!!

 

[Stakerz]

I am just relishing the thought of Hodgey giving him a BIG hip and shoulder. Rubbing my hands together at the thought!!!Once you are out there playing you are fair target!!

Stop kidding yourself, Harry O will bounce right off and run away with the ball

 

[Jabso]

Perhaps we can test out Franklins calf. Is chop blocking illegal in the AFL?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

HARRAY

P.S. Nice avatar of Goldsack, Mr Jabso Moderator Man

 

[Dazman]

Bump

A victory to The Royal Sampler.