Herald Sun SuperCoach 2008

[beautime]

any good bench defenders to replace pfeiffer? right now i have hansen and scott thompson, if theres any1 at 94k who can replace hansen it will greatly help me

Matt Sphanger from West Coast

 

[beautime]

nicoski vs. xavier ellis vs. bradshaw vs. matt maguire in the backline?

Bradshaw


look at Barlow as well

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Matt Sphanger from West Coast

I thought that selwood was better?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

palmer only 50/50 to play, should i straight swap him for tuck who is 100% likely going to play and also do u think hansen and thompson are going to play???

 

[eugene_tomas]

chris newman??? thoughts

 

[eugene_tomas]

stick with plamer id rekon

 

[sdsdsdsd]

chris newman??? thoughts

thanks

newman is one of those players whos above mid-ranged and a bit below a gun, so if u have the cash try upgrade but hes a decent pick

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Ok, I haven't had a whine yet but here we go.

Mother ****ing Thursday game with a before 7 lockout.
I finish work at 8 how the **** am I supposed to finalise my rookie spots when I don't know who is in and who is out!

And Bryce Gibbs withdraw from the game tonight so I can rest easy with the bloody painful Gibbs/Griffen selection.

****!

 

[TheMightyPies]

can i get some thoughts on this team too, its my first year in SC to.

1. Birchall (DEF)
2. Selwood (DEF)
3. Cornes (DEF)
4. Ellis (DEF)
5. Mattner (DEF)
6. Pfeiffer (DEF)
7. Johncock (DEF)

8. Gilbee (DEF)
9. Gram (DEF)
10. Nicoski (MID)
11. Mitchell (MID)
12. Ablett (MID)
13. Bird (MID)
14. Dal Santo (MID)
15. Palmer (MID)
16. Stevens (MID)
17. Griffen (MID)

18. Simmonds (RUC)
19. Leuenberger (RUC)
20. Renouf (RUC)
21. Kreuzer (RUC)

22. Le Cras (FWD)
23. Rioli (FWD)
24. Henderson (FWD)
25. Riewoldt (FWD)
26. Deledio (FWD)
27. Tippett (FWD)
28. Didak (FWD)
29. Murphy (FWD)
30. Lucas (FWD)

not sure if my rucks will be strong enough though

cheers

 

[marcmurphy3]

Quick question guys. Chad Cornes and Newman or Gilbee and Sam Fisher?

or I could downgrade Mackie to Symes and just upgrade Gilbee to Cornes?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

one final question

A
gilbee
milburn

B
mattner
synes

pick one from A and one from B

 

[marcmurphy3]

one final question

A
gilbee
milburn

B
mattner
synes

pick one from A and one from B

Mattner and Gilbee.

 

[sens]

Who has a better chance of playing round 1:

S Selwood or L Hansen

 

[sens]

one final question

A
gilbee
milburn

B
mattner
synes

pick one from A and one from B

I'd pick Milburn and Symes

 

[marcmurphy3]

Quick question guys. Chad Cornes and Newman or Gilbee and Sam Fisher?

or I could downgrade Mackie to Symes and just upgrade Gilbee to Cornes?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

1-1 o well thanks for ur thoughts, any reason behind them?

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Who has a better chance of playing round 1:

S Selwood or L Hansen

Honestly.
If you can't work this one out DT isn't for you.

If it is purely who is a better chance of playing it is a no brainer.

 

[sens]

Simmonds or Wood and some cash?

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Quick question guys. Chad Cornes and Newman or Gilbee and Sam Fisher?

or I could downgrade Mackie to Symes and just upgrade Gilbee to Cornes?

cornes is a must do anything u have to to get him

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Just broght Steve Johnson into the side.
Still making the changes!

 

[Dougy85]

arggh. none of my 1st year players are getting a game this week according to the footy show so far :S

 

[Biggie]

Just broght Steve Johnson into the side.
Still making the changes!

SJ is a little overpriced imo.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

SJ is a little overpriced imo.

Got the cash may as well use it.
Upgraded C. Jones...
Don't like anyone else in between their prices.

 

[dmc333]

is anyone else getting a few bugs while on the site?

might be an idea to make sure you're not on there at 5.30 tomorrow and have the thing crap itself.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Got the cash may as well use it.
Upgraded C. Jones...
Don't like anyone else in between their prices.

Deledio?