Herald Sun's Crows Report Card

Remove this Banner Ad

Aug 14, 2003
1,122
1
"Another day in paradise"
Other Teams
Crows and Westies
Adelaide's 2003 report card
15 September 2003 Herald Sun
By JON ANDERSON

Jon Anderson sums up Adelaide's season.

COACH

Gary Ayres is undemonstrative and seemingly unflappable. He seems to coach to a formula, and while not regarded as an innovator, he will enter his 10th season in the caper in 2004 with his greatest challenge yet. 6/10

DEFENCE

Ken McGregor has done the job asked of him, something Nigel Smart and Ben Hart have been doing for a combined tally of 542 games. Only Port had less points kicked against them. 8/10

MIDFIELD

As good as any in terms of balance. Mark Ricciuto, Andrew McLeod, Brett Burton, Tyson Edwards and Chris Ladhams are also goalkickers; Tyson Stenglein runs with the best; Mark Bickley was hard.8/10

RUCK STRENGTH

Another positive. Rhett Biglands and Matthew Clarke could take more contested marks and kick more goals, but as a hit-out duo they are supreme.7/10

FORWARDS

Their best combination (Ronnie Burns, Burton, Wayne Carey, Graham Johncock, Ian Perrie, Mark Stevens and Scott Welsh) could be electric, but was never available (injury). Carey, who had a dismal final game against the Lions, will play again after showing real signs earlier in the season.6/10

LEADERSHIP

Ricciuto is seen as inspirational and hard. Clearly there is no lack of experience (six players with more than 200 games, Collingwood has one), but where is the next leader coming from?6/10

LIST MANAGEMENT

How many players has Ayres developed in his time at Adelaide? And where are their new stars? Seventeen on the list are 26 or over, meaning some planning for the future is urgently required. The club is in real danger of some bleak seasons, given it tried to steal a flag this year with Dad's Army.5/10

MEDIA

The Crows are not a club that is pro-active in this area. Their coach is perfunctory at best.5/10

MEMBERSHIP

The envy of the competition. How can you go wrong when the 46,620 rises slightly to 46,998? 9/10

FINANCES

The club spent plenty this season on its Crows Tavern at AAMI Stadium, but should still announce a profit. Winning the pre-season cup provided a nice bonus.8/10

TOTAL GRADE: 68/100

FIRST-CLASS HONOURS

TYSON EDWARDS and ANDREW McLEOD

Edwards has played 93 of 94 games in the past four years, whether it be back, forward or midfield, and is invaluable. McLeod is judged by his own sublime standards, which were slightly down on 2002.

QUIET ACHIEVERS

KEN McGREGOR and BRETT BURTON

McGregor has taken all the big names and done OK, as evidenced by Friday night's comeback on Jonathan Brown. Burton was less spectacular than previously, but more effective in a midfield/forward role.

RISING STARS

GRAHAM JOHNCOCK and IAN PERRIE

Johncock from Port Adelaide (SANFL) was an inspired selection at 67 in the 2000 draft and led the Crows' goalkicking. Perrie's form tapered off, but he was excellent early in the year as a key forward.

MISSING IN ACTION

WAYNE CAREY and MICHAEL DOUGHTY

Carey played 16 games for 29 goals and at times looked the part. But when it mattered most on Friday night, he was missing. Doughty, a regular on the wing in 2002, spent most of the year with South Adelaide.

SEE YOU LATER

Mark Bickley is tipped to announce his retirement today.

Possible delistings: Daniel Schell, Ben Marsh, James Gallagher, Ben Nelson.

TRADE TEASER

Matthew Bode to Melbourne for Peter Walsh and pick No.20

ORDER OF DRAFT PICKS: 12, 26, 42, 58, 74 (subject to trades)

The age of the Crows' list makes trading difficult, with most of their players in the twilight of their careers and therefore in the unwanted basket.

But one player sure to create some interest is Matthew Bode, who went backwards this year after a great 2002.

At 24, they may be forced to offload him for a crack at a high draft pick.

The Demons are unlikely to give up picks No. 3 and 5, but pick No. 20 is sure to be on the table for a player of Bode's ability.

They could throw in former West Adelaide player Peter Walsh to get the deal done.

RANKINGS

1 Mark Ricciuto 3083

2 Andrew McLeod 2552

3 Tyson Edwards 2428

4 Mark Bickley 2017

5 Graham Johncock 1974

GOALS

1 Graham Johncock 30

2 A. McLeod, W. Carey 29

3 Ian Perrie 26

OTHERS

Kicks Mark Ricciuto 333

Marks Ian Perrie 115

Handballs Mark Ricciuto 232

Clearances Mark Ricciuto 105

Clangers Andrew McLeod 56

Tackles Mark Bickley 73

Goal assists McLeod, Carey 17

Hitouts Matthew Clarke 537

Marking spoils Nathan Bassett 79

Most benchings Rhett Biglands 76

Game time McLeod 2718min

Players used 37

The Good

Ranked second in clearances with 860 during the regular season and won the fourth most hardball gets, led by Mark Ricciuto's 69.

The Bad

Adelaide's 248 marks inside 50 ranked equal 13th, despite having the fifth most forward 50 entries.
 
Re: Re: Herald Sun's Crows Report Card

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
ORDER OF DRAFT PICKS: 12, 26, 42, 58, 74 (subject to trades)
Err, more like 14, 29, 46, 62, 78 :(
Yes, Jon Anderson obviously isn't terribly familiar with the concept of priority draft picks.

But I make it 14, 29, 45, 61, 77
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Re: Re: Herald Sun's Crows Report Card

Originally posted by DaveW
Err, more like 14, 29, 46, 62, 78 :(
Yes, Jon Anderson obviously isn't terribly familiar with the concept of priority draft picks.

But I make it 14, 29, 45, 61, 77
I always sucked at maths :(

I would rather use Bode to trade up in the draft with something/someone else we could possibly get a top 10 pick.

Would Richmond be interested in Bode?????? They do lack a bit of grunt in the midfield.

Otherwise

Bode for Smith and Pick 20 if far better than Walsh and pick 20:(
 
Does anyone else think that report card is a piece of sh*t?

Apparently having a media savvy coach is just as important as having a good midfield. :rolleyes:
 
Originally posted by Scotty's_Girl
DEFENCE

Ken McGregor has done the job asked of him, something Nigel Smart and Ben Hart have been doing for a combined tally of 542 games. Only Port had less points kicked against them. 8/10

MIDFIELD

As good as any in terms of balance. Mark Ricciuto, Andrew McLeod, Brett Burton, Tyson Edwards and Chris Ladhams are also goalkickers; Tyson Stenglein runs with the best; Mark Bickley was hard.8/10

RUCK STRENGTH

Another positive. Rhett Biglands and Matthew Clarke could take more contested marks and kick more goals, but as a hit-out duo they are supreme.7/10

FORWARDS

Their best combination (Ronnie Burns, Burton, Wayne Carey, Graham Johncock, Ian Perrie, Mark Stevens and Scott Welsh) could be electric, but was never available (injury). Carey, who had a dismal final game against the Lions, will play again after showing real signs earlier in the season.6/10


LIST MANAGEMENT

How many players has Ayres developed in his time at Adelaide? And where are their new stars? Seventeen on the list are 26 or over, meaning some planning for the future is urgently required. The club is in real danger of some bleak seasons, given it tried to steal a flag this year with Dad's Army.5/10

Anyonw see Neil Kerleys assessment on all these areas in the sunday mail? They're pretty similar, although Neil Kerley doesn't think the midfield and the rucks were as good.
 
Re: Re: Herald Sun's Crows Report Card

Originally posted by Scotty's_Girl
Anyonw see Neil Kerleys assessment on all these areas in the sunday mail? They're pretty similar, although Neil Kerley doesn't think the midfield and the rucks were as good.
Yeah I reckon Kerls was pretty spot on with his assesment.

Rucks: Definetly need changing. Need someone that will offer a bit more around the ground

Midfield: Started off well but went missing in the last 3rd of the season

Defence: Very solid McGregor had a good year but big problem is a FB. Bassett plays some beauties but is not big enough or Strong enough for Big forwards

Youngsters: He rates Bock as the likely type and reckons Reilly needs to become a regular next year. Likes Schuback and said that Hentschel needs to get bigger.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top