Heres one from left field.....

[Viva la Mattner]

all the talk about Pavlich, there is one KPP that we could get for CHF
most people dont rate him, but he wouldnt cost too much and under our fitness regime could get back to his form of old, which was quite good.
the player i speak of is Lance Whitnall

id take Pav any day of the week, but just wanted to know everyones thought on this possible trade.

id say:

Doughty + 3rd round

for

Whitnall

 

[rayven]

Quite simply the "carlton" culture is bad news.

 

[Drummond]

You can't be serious? That is without doubt the most ridiculous proposal I have ever seen. If we're looking at Victorian KPP's, we should be targeting Carlton's Brad Fisher. 23 years of age, 192cm and is one of the best contested marks I have seen.

But Whitnall?

 

[swanfan]

No that is better staying in left field......far left field.

 

[bus24]

Slow, too old, not part of the next premiership side

Pass

and then Pass again

And he's a carrot

 

[Viva la Mattner]

You can't be serious? That is without doubt the most ridiculous proposal I have ever seen. If we're looking at Victorian KPP's, we should be targeting Carlton's Brad Fisher. 23 years of age, 192cm and is one of the best contested marks I have seen.

But Whitnall?

like i said, abit fitness behind him he is a decent player

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Slow, too old, not part of the next premiership side

Pass

and then Pass again

And he's a carrot

Carrot?

How can he be a carrot, by the look of him he wouldnt know what a carrot is, he is a mars bar!

 

[bus24]

Carrot?

How can he be a carrot, by the look of him he wouldnt know what a carrot is, he is a mars bar!

Red hair thing.

Definitely a King Size Mars Bar too.

 

[lozstar]

we'd have to get balfours or villi's on as sponsors.....

 

[swanfan]

we'd have to get balfours or villi's on as sponsors.....

We would have to get Donut King.

 

[Truck Rutten]

Too old, too slow, too Carlton, too many family dramas, too fat, too freckly and too ugly.

P.S. This was a joke thread wasn't it?

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Too old, too slow, too Carlton, too many family dramas, too fat, too freckly and too ugly.

P.S. This was a joke thread wasn't it?

Too fire croutch!

 

[Wood_Duck]

all the talk about Pavlich, there is one KPP that we could get for CHF
most people dont rate him, but he wouldnt cost too much and under our fitness regime could get back to his form of old, which was quite good.
the player i speak of is Lance Whitnall

id take Pav any day of the week, but just wanted to know everyones thought on this possible trade.

id say:

Doughty + 3rd round

for

Whitnall

So far out of left field, it started left and is still going left.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

haha well i'll take it as a big fat NO (with the key word being fat)

 

[crowsarethebest]

You can't be serious? That is without doubt the most ridiculous proposal I have ever seen. If we're looking at Victorian KPP's, we should be targeting Carlton's Brad Fisher. 23 years of age, 192cm and is one of the best contested marks I have seen.

But Whitnall?

Fisher is a great mark, I rate him highly but we don't need another forward who can not kick straight!

 

[raikkonen]

We dont want to bring a losing culture here.

 

[WheresGroomgone]

While we're at it I have heard from a reliable source that Randall Bones pretty keen on making CHF his!!!! Ahh the options for 2008 are endless.

 

[KUNG FU]

Our CHF is lacking quality, not quantity.

Therefore, we look at Pavlich, not Whitnall.

Whitnall was a great player, but I doubt he had more than one or two good seasons left.

 

[maccas_no1]

Lance Whitnall.........................................You are kidding yourself

 

[baaaallllll]

The computer says "No"

 

[-VC-]

all the talk about Pavlich, there is one KPP that we could get for CHF
most people dont rate him, but he wouldnt cost too much and under our fitness regime could get back to his form of old, which was quite good.
the player i speak of is Lance Whitnall

id take Pav any day of the week, but just wanted to know everyones thought on this possible trade.

id say:

Doughty + 3rd round

for

Whitnall

I actually don't mind Whitnall, but Carlton would not trade their captain for Doughty and a third rounder.

 

[Redline]

I actually don't mind Whitnall, but Carlton would not trade their captain for Doughty and a third rounder.

Exactly, as scary as it is they would want much more than that.