Hird, Buckley or Voss?

[13-CABS]

Just an argument between me and a few others. Dunno how to put a poll on yet, but im just wondering peoples thoughts on who they rate more out of Hird, Buckley and Voss? this is over there whole careers.
Personally i have Buckley ahead of Voss, followed by Hird. Others feel Buckley is more of a receiver and lacks leadership. I cant see how this is proven as hes captained Collingwood to 2 grand finals in years when they werent the most talented. Voss obviously stands out for his leadership, but im not a big fan of Hird as a leader. Feel free to throw others up there, such as Harvey or West. Cheers!

 

[Warwick]

This is something different. For a change, i'll say Voss.

 

[Harvey's Crew]

Why doesn't Robert Harvey get mentioned? 2 brownlow medals, 8 time all australian and many more achievements, just because the media doesn't talk him up, doesn't mean he shouldn't be acknowledged. He's a champion for the game

 

[13-CABS]

I agree about Harvey, was and still is a superstar. Probably the thing with him and West is that they played in teams that weren't as successful. Often a good player is turned in to a champion through performances in the big games, such as finals. Buckleys Norm Smith in a losing side stands out as one such performance. Think Harvey isnt as flashy as the others, just quietly racks up the touches week in week out, whereas Hird and Buckley to an extent can do the freakish things, and Voss is just inspirational with his attack on the ball.

 

[Gilbert_Hodge]

Crawford
But out of those three i would rate Hird. He is the most likeable out of the three and is still in stella form. Has acheived a lot in his career so far and hopefully goes on for another year!

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Buckley by a bit over Hird then Voss.
My bro tells me Lynchy carried Brisbane for his premierships with all the drugs
Sound trolly

Polls are easy tick the box down the bottom type the amount of options post thread and then enter the poll incidentals.

 

[Casey]

Dunno how to put a poll on yet

spose you dont know how to use the search function either... I'm assuming your new here so ill cut you a break..



Hird/Voss > Buckley

Harvey> Hird/Voss > Buckley