How many Weeks will Solomon Get

[Magpies696]

LING deserved It the RED head

 

[thewhippersnapper]

LING deserved It the RED head

Club: Collingwood

Oh.. carry on.

 

[royboy2]

It will get points to the tune of 4 weeks, but he has a loading and carry over points which will put it up to 6-7

 

[Kit146]

If your stupid enough to do it your stupid enough to cop the penalty

 

[SaintsPremiers08]

Ling couldn't possibly get any uglier...

 

[bigcatman]

ling they say will be out for 4 weeks so solomon deserves 8...but wont get that much

 

[HolyWars]

6 weeks I think.

 

[Andronicus]

did hall get 6 or 7? i cant remember which, but the fact that he got off so lightly with an act that was so much worse i think should be reflected in the solomon case.

personally i think he deserves about 6, but if the afl is consistent at all, considering the severity of both goodes and hall, 3-4 would be more appropriate.

 

[jman_cool]

LING deserved It the RED head

Typical coming from a Collingwood supporter. I think Solomon should be made to do drive-bys with Didak & Co.

But seriously, he should get double however long Lingy is out for.

 

[Wally07]

Since hall only got 7 and this was not as bad I will say 5.

 

[Big Nasty]

Since hall only got 7 and this was not as bad I will say 5.

Your kidding aren't you?
Ling has had surgery & I think he got a plate inserted. Staker only missed a week.

 

[Andronicus]

Your kidding aren't you?
Ling has had surgery & I think he got a plate inserted. Staker only missed a week.

you cant judge the severity of the indiscretion on the injury that is sustained.

although solomon was foolish and a low act, there is no way it can be considered as bad as hall's hit on staker purely because of the time the victim was sidelined.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Penalty should start after Ling comes back from injury.

 

[jman_cool]

you cant judge the severity of the indiscretion on the injury that is sustained.

although solomon was foolish and a low act, there is no way it can be considered as bad as hall's hit on staker purely because of the time the victim was sidelined.

What rule is that under? So when you have a car accident we will only give you $20 for $2000 worth of damage.... Gee that's far.

 

[Andronicus]

What rule is that under? So when you have a car accident we will only give you $20 for $2000 worth of damage.... Gee that's far.

i dont think you understand the concept

insurance compensation and payouts are to cover damages. penalties given out by the tribunal are to punish indescretions.

they are 2 totally different scenarios.