Remove this Banner Ad

Poo Mega Thread How's Justin Longmanure working out for you Failmantle (Part 2) 2023 Edition

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

So you agree Waterman would be your first choice chf in place of Treacy, glad we sorted that out.

Waterman compares favourably to Treacy at the same age too btw. No wonder your club has a thing for him.
I don't agree at all, ask any fan of any club and I guarantee everyone would pick Treacy over Waterman in their team, that's an objective fact.

And again, you're lying, we've never been into him.
 
I don't agree at all, ask any fan of any club and I guarantee everyone would pick Treacy over Waterman in their team, that's an objective fact.

And again, you're lying, we've never been into him.
Why would anyone pick Treacy when Waterman is proven to be the superior player?

Youre not making much sense here.
 
Why would anyone pick Treacy when Waterman is proven to be the superior player?

Youre not making much sense here.
Because Treacy is a far better long term choice, he's younger, has far more upside and has potential to be a huge player, but even despite all that he, at 21, is still a better and more exciting player than Waterman is at 25, which is supposed to be the start of his prime, and he can't even crack a game in the worst side in the competition.

Waterman wouldn't get picked up a local Saturday league.
 
And again, you're lying, we've never been into him.
Just to clear this up for you, most people understood this to be common knowledge. It really shouldn’t be a surprise considering how poor your forwardline has been in forever.



Waterman on Saturday declined the Eagles’ offer and looked to begin discussions with clubs including Fremantle, Essendon, Hawthorn and Adelaide over his AFL future.



The Dockers had shown interest in Waterman over the past few years, but they would have struggled to get the Claremont product in given their tight playing list.

It is believed Fremantle coach Justin Longmuir and forwards Jaymie Graham are big fans of Waterman from their time as assistant coaches at the Eagles
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Because Treacy is a far better long term choice, he's younger, has far more upside and has potential to be a huge player, but even despite all that he, at 21, is still a better and more exciting player than Waterman is at 25, which is supposed to be the start of his prime, and he can't even crack a game in the worst side in the competition.

Waterman wouldn't get picked up a local Saturday league.
But Treacy’s not a better player at all, he’s clearly sub afl standard when you look at the numbers.

You’re into your 9th year of a rebuild and have promised your fans top 4 finishes and a flag now, but instead you’re widely tipped to be down the bottom somewhere again next season. Having to rely on non performers like Treacy while other clubs like West Coast have better players in their reserves shows you just how far off the pack you guys really are.
 
Waterman is a 3rd tall, Tracey is a Key Forward and they're 4 years apart in age. Waterman's output is being matched by Treacy and he's only had 1 preseason.
They play very similar roles and Waterman’s output is superior to Treacy’s even though our forwards had it tougher than any other club’s this season.
 
They play very similar roles and Waterman’s output is superior to Treacy’s even though our forwards had it tougher than any other club’s this season.
Waterman gets a heap of uncontested possessions which is the main difference between the two. I assume it's because Gaff kicks it sideways to him every time he gets the ball.

Treacy will go past him in 2024 and no one will give a shit.
 
Waterman gets a heap of uncontested possessions which is the main difference between the two. I assume it's because Gaff kicks it sideways to him every time he gets the ball.

Treacy will go past him in 2024 and no one will give a s**t.
Treacy should be lucky to be anywhere near a starting 22 for any club, let alone one which claims to be in their window, lol. And there’s a few more of those types on your list.
 
First Henry, now Shultz has come out and said the reason for his departure is due to Cockburn’s shit fans. Not surprisingly the straw that broke the camel’s back was when the Failmantle ferals decided to send their club’s game record holder off the park for the last time to the cheers for West Coast premiership hero Dom Sheed instead of his flagless teammate.


1699402858101.jpeg


“The supporter base is the best in the AFL and the most passionate fans in the AFL - that was a massive incentive to come across


1699403021396.gif
 
First Henry, now Shultz has come out and said the reason for his departure is due to Cockburn’s s**t fans. Not surprisingly the straw that broke the camel’s back was when the Failmantle ferals decided to send their club’s game record holder off the park for the last time to the cheers for West Coast premiership hero Dom Sheed instead of his flagless teammate.


View attachment 1848471


“The supporter base is the best in the AFL and the most passionate fans in the AFL - that was a massive incentive to come across


View attachment 1848472
Shultz looks really happy wearing the black and white - honestly i cant remember ever seeing him smile at Cockburn
 
Same here. Might have something to do with a multi year contract.


Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com
Would that contract also be the cause of the glowing, healthy skin on show in the picture compared to the familiar pale, almost grey tone he exhibited along with the rest of the playing group while at Failmantle?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Remove this Banner Ad

Poo Mega Thread How's Justin Longmanure working out for you Failmantle (Part 2) 2023 Edition

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top