hypotheticals/what if's thread

[jknothimjustafan]

As the title suggests this is just for hypotheticals/what if's for the sake of discussion. Not for things that are likely to happen/look like happening.

Ill start with 2.

If Mick Malthouse wanted to leave Collingwood (after this season of course) and come back to us as senior assistant coach/director of coaching (whatever Mark Thompson is at Essendon) would the club want him back?

The second one is who has the most trade value on our list? Not who is our best player or who is likely to be traded this year, which one player would opposition clubs fall over themselves to get and offer the most for?

 

[Brave Sir Robin]

1. No.

2. LeCras or NN.

 

[Jootube]

1. I dont think so, as much as I wouldn't want to admit it. I believe Woosha still holds it against MM for how his career ended.

2. LeCras>NN>Shuey/Priddus(For GWS or GC)

 

[Alexwce]

1. Na
2. NicNat, JK, Shuey, Lecca, EMac, Stevens

 

[Goldfish]

1. No

2. Lecca, Shuey, Kennedy, NN, Priddis, Darling

 

[paran]

1. No
2. NicNat. JK. Lecras. Cox.

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

If Mick Malthouse wanted to leave Collingwood (after this season of course) and come back to us as senior assistant coach/director of coaching (whatever Mark Thompson is at Essendon) would the club want him back?

Nope. As mentioned before, I think the club would believe they have moved past him.

The second one is who has the most trade value on our list? Not who is our best player or who is likely to be traded this year, which one player would opposition clubs fall over themselves to get and offer the most for?

Easily NicNat. As good as our other players are, every single club would want NicNat. He's just gonna be a monster (already seeing a signs more and more regularly).

 

[Obeanie1]

No to Malthouse.

Most valuable trade items, in order:

1. Kennedy
2. Naitanui
3. Le Cras
4. Shuey
5. Darling
6. Gaff
7. Hurn
8. Waters
9. M Brown
10. S Selwood

 

[September_Glory]

Hypothetical question...

Say Woosha doesn't get a contract extension and the club decides to go another direction.

Who do you want to taking over for the next 10+ years?

 

[Byron_Clanger]

No, he'll coach Melbourne or Bulldogs next year

Kennedy, LeCras, Cox, Shuey, NicNat, Kerr, Darling, Gaff

 

[BOND 007]

Hypothetical question...

Say Woosha doesn't get a contract extension and the club decides to go another direction.

Who do you want to taking over for the next 10+ years?

Paul Roos firstly followed by Rodney Eade. Both are fantastic man managers with excellent match days skills

and in order of trade value

1) Kennedy
2) NN
3) Lecras
4) Hurn
5) Shuey and Darling

 

[September_Glory]

Paul Roos firstly followed by Rodney Eade. Both are fantastic man managers with excellent match days skills

Good ones. Eades I've always liked.

Scott Burns is going to make a fantastic head coach one day.

 

[Masto]

Wouldn't take Eade for anything. Has been coaching for years but never won a premiership despite some decent talent.

 

[September_Glory]

His work at Sydney is underrated.

He came within inches of being a premiership coach (and hence "untouchable" status) TWICE.

 

[Shazzman]

what if we had traded pick 4 for wells last year? would we be top 4?

hindsight is a bitch ay

 

[September_Glory]

what if we had traded pick 4 for wells last year? would we be top 4?

hindsight is a bitch ay

Nope.

Super tough 6 weeks ahead (killer month after the bye) so we're not going top 4 with Wells.

Also, if Wells is in. Who is out?

Rosa gets less opportunities playing that outside role, certain players don't get develop time etc etc.

 

[Jootube]

If Worsfold wasn't to get a contract extension I would love to see Paul Roos at the eagles. Always had the utmost respect for that guy.

 

[Patron]

What if freo get omeara?
fyfe, Hill, Morabito, Barlow, Mundy, Pitt, Omeara. I am genuinely scared of that.

 

[Evelyn208]

What if freo get omeara?
fyfe, Hill, Morabito, Barlow, Mundy, Pitt, Omeara. I am genuinely scared of that.

You scare easy.

 

[SwiftforPM]

His work at Sydney is underrated.

He came within inches of being a premiership coach (and hence "untouchable" status) TWICE.

It's a shame for him he was a couple of inches short

 

[jknothimjustafan]

If Carlton wanted (and if both players wanted) to trade Judd back to us with Kennedy back to them straight swap would you want to do it?

 

[Evelyn208]

If Carlton wanted (and if both players wanted) to trade Judd back to us with Kennedy back to them straight swap would you want to do it?

No.

But if any club wanted Masten I would give him away for free.

 

[eagles rule]

no to mickey

Most valued trade -Shuey -Nicnat -Masten

 

[flylikeaneagle]

If Worsfold wasn't to get a contract extension I would love to see Paul Roos at the eagles. Always had the utmost respect for that guy.

No, do not want us to slow down the play, kick backwards 50% of the time and flood at any opportunity.

 

[The lynch mob]

What if instead of trading Judd to Carlton for there offer, Kennedy and picks 3 (Masten) and 20 (Notte) we instead took up Richmonds offer of pick 2 (Cotchin) and pick 18 (Rance) ?