News Injury List (25th February)

Vicky Park · Mar 20, 2013

Always concerned when the injury list indicates 6 to 8 weeks, which seems to be code for 'a long time and we dont really know how long'. Horrible bad luck for Broomy and Grundy, but they will be well cared for. Hope to see them playing in the VFL at Vic Park late in the first half of the season, and who knows what might happen after that?

Mame · Mar 26, 2013

Injury List
As of Tuesday 26 March 2013
http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/season/injury-list

Corey Gault (Groin): Available
Jackson Paine (Concussion): Available
Dale Thomas (Ankle): Available

Ben Reid (Knee): Test

Jackson Ramsay (Groin): 1-2 weeks
Andrew Krakouer (Match Fitness): 1-3 weeks
Luke Ball (Knee): 2-3 weeks
Alan Didak (Hamstring): 2-3 weeks

Brodie Grundy (Back): 4-6 weeks
Lachlan Keeffe (Knee): 6-8 weeks
Tim Broomhead (Glandular Fever): 8 weeks

blaze036 · Mar 26, 2013

Mame said:
Injury List
As of Tuesday 26 March 2013
http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/season/injury-list

Corey Gault (Groin): Available
Jackson Paine (Concussion): Available
Dale Thomas (Ankle): Available

Ben Reid (Knee): Test

Jackson Ramsay (Groin): 1-2 weeks
Andrew Krakouer (Match Fitness): 1-3 weeks
Luke Ball (Knee): 2-3 weeks
Alan Didak (Hamstring): 2-3 weeks

Brodie Grundy (Back): 4-6 weeks
Lachlan Keeffe (Knee): 6-8 weeks
Tim Broomhead (Glandular Fever): 8 weeks

Jeez didak still 2-3 weeks away.. doesn't look good for him sadly

JOELY · Mar 27, 2013

Gault went from 4-6 to available in one week. :thumbsu:

Hardas · Mar 27, 2013

JOELY said:
Gault went from 4-6 to available in one week.

Yep, if they all can do that we'll be flying in a couple of weeks!

Kirby · Mar 27, 2013

JOELY said:
Gault went from 4-6 to available in one week.

It makes a bit of a mockery of the estimated return dates doesn't it?

Maybe he dipped his groin in the waters at Lourdes?

Also, haven't they said that Krak is playing tomorrow night in the VFL game against AIS? (or am I imagining that?)

The Royal Sampler · Mar 27, 2013

Kirby said:
Also, haven't they said that Krak is playing tomorrow night in the VFL game against AIS? (or am I imagining that?)

One does tend to gain match fitness by playing in matches.

Hardas · Mar 27, 2013

Kirby said:
It makes a bit of a mockery of the estimated return dates doesn't it?

Maybe he dipped his groin in the waters at Lourdes?

Also, haven't they said that Krak is playing tomorrow night in the VFL game against AIS? (or am I imagining that?)

Apparently Bucks said as much at the convention.

blaze036 · Mar 27, 2013

Kirby said:
It makes a bit of a mockery of the estimated return dates doesn't it?

Maybe he dipped his groin in the waters at Lourdes?

Also, haven't they said that Krak is playing tomorrow night in the VFL game against AIS? (or am I imagining that?)

It really is just an estimate, a lot of injuries can be impossible to accurately predict. Injuries can heal really fast or really slow seemingly randomly. I suspect if gault does play it was a case of an original misdiagnosis combined with a fast recovery

Hardas · Mar 27, 2013

Just noticed that Hartley has another shoulder injury - bugger!
Anyone know if it's the same shoulder? The article on CFC doesn't make it clear, although it does add:

'In other injury news, Dale Thomas (ankle), Alex Fasolo (hamstring) and Ben Reid (knee) all hold hope of playing football in some capacity this week.'

I guess that's glass half full, right?

Hardas · Mar 27, 2013

blaze036 said:
It really is just an estimate, a lot of injuries can be impossible to accurately predict. Injuries can heal really fast or really slow seemingly randomly. I suspect if gault does play it was a case of an original misdiagnosis combined with a fast recovery

I guess they make an original 'guesstimate' then don't bother updating the list accurately, then voila!
Or they did send him to Lourdes...

blaze036 · Mar 27, 2013

Hardas said:
I guess they make an original 'guesstimate' then don't bother updating the list accurately, then voila!
Or they did send him to Lourdes...

I think it's much better to look at the numbers in terms of back playing really soon, back in couple and not going to play for a while; rather than the actual numbers listed which are fairly meaningless but some people demand a number.

Kirby · Mar 27, 2013

The Royal Sampler said:
One does tend to gain match fitness by playing in matches.

I get that bit. So am I read the estimate as a return to the seniors and not lower levels?

Is that why Gault was listed as 6 weeks last week and is playing tomorrow? I guess I can pencil in his senior debut for round 6 then?

P.s. I'm just kidding around of course haha

Kirby · Mar 27, 2013

blaze036 said:
It really is just an estimate, a lot of injuries can be impossible to accurately predict. Injuries can heal really fast or really slow seemingly randomly. I suspect if gault does play it was a case of an original misdiagnosis combined with a fast recovery

Seriously, their guesstimate can go from 4 to 6 weeks to playing in the space of one week? Who's the frickin doctor at the club? Wow!

I just think the injury list if a load of made up bullocks half the time!

blaze036 · Mar 27, 2013

Kirby said:
Seriously, their guesstimate can go from 4 to 6 weeks to playing in the space of one week? Who's the frickin doctor at the club? Wow!

I just think the injury list if a load of made up bullocks half the time!

I'd guess that they thought it was a certain grade tear, but it turned up to be a few grades lower and he healed much faster than expected

The Royal Sampler · Mar 27, 2013

Definitely a bit of smoke and shadows behind the glass with the injury list.

Old Spice · Mar 27, 2013

JOELY said:
Gault went from 4-6 to available in one week.

He built a tardis, good for him.

blaze036 · Mar 27, 2013

The Royal Sampler said:
Definitely a bit of smoke and shadows behind the glass with the injury list.

We were just trying to trick the AIS team, god forbid they knew Gault was going to play, they could work out a strategy to keep him out of it. Now we can spring this on them and catch em off guard. genius !

TheGreatGrundy · Mar 27, 2013

Old Spice said:
He built a tardis, good for him.

A time machine. I had to google it. Am I as incredibly ignorant as I feel?

blaze036 · Mar 27, 2013

MyManwasshowntheDawe said:
A time machine. I had to google it. Am I as incredibly ignorant as I feel?

It's a Dr Who thing

Old Spice · Mar 27, 2013

MyManwasshowntheDawe said:
A time machine. I had to google it. Am I as incredibly ignorant as I feel?

What's google, had to Yahoo it.

Ah generation gaps.

rose jam · Mar 27, 2013

How the hell is Dids still 2-3, did he get a recurrence or are they being super conservative

And where the hell is Fasolo?

TheGreatGrundy · Mar 27, 2013

Old Spice said:
What's google, had to Yahoo it.

Ah generation gaps.

Should I be 'yahooing' or you 'googling'? Which one of us is on the wrong side of the gap?! Please tell me it's you Old Spice?!!

Number 10 · Mar 27, 2013

rose jam said:
How the hell is Dids still 2-3, did he get a recurrence or are they being super conservative

And where the hell is Fasolo?

Maybe, just maybe.... Fasolo isn't injured any more....

Collingwoodity · Mar 28, 2013

Any news on the Seedsman injury? How severe is it?

Log In or Create New Account

Rd 9 + Club Forums »

News Injury List (25th February)

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

TheBrownDog

Shambolic Rube

Floreat Pica, Bitch!

TheBrownDog

Brownlow Medallist

TheBrownDog

TheBrownDog

Brownlow Medallist

Shambolic Rube

Shambolic Rube

Brownlow Medallist

Floreat Pica, Bitch!

Old Spice

Guest

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Old Spice

Guest

Norm Smith Medallist

Cancelled

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads