- Joined
- Jun 10, 2009
- Posts
- 29,794
- Reaction score
- 44,888
- Location
- Victorian Central Highlands
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels Beaufort Crows
- Thread starter
- #176
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Fantasy Footy Notice Image Round 7
SuperCoach Rd 7 SC Talk - Trade Talk - Capt/VC ,//, AFL Fantasy Rd 7 AFF Talk - AF Trades - Capt/VC
Jackson is just a footballer. Clean skills, clean take, efficient disposal, jeft footer and can swing on his right. While his contested stuff needs some work to make him a more balanced footballer, I can see some merit to the Simon Black comparisons. Not that Jackson will be as good but in terms of their build, their movement and just general demeanor on the field are similar.
Interesting to hear about the glandular fever. It explains why Jackson slipped that far compared to where he was projected to go 12 months ago. IIRC, a year ago he was projected to be a late 1st, early 2nd round pick in this year’s draft. I do know the club rated him. I remeber a player telling me early this year that Jackson looked really good on the track and he “broke the ankles” of a couple of Crows boys with one of his moves during the match simulation drills.
If he can have a career half as good as Black did, Jackson will be a heck of a player.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Does anyone know if Luke projects to be a KPP? He looks pretty damn tall for a 16 year old
Yep, made his debut against the Crows I think. Certainly played a few gamesSo Jackson played some SANFL league this year?
Looks like he’s got a bum in his arm. 
Last four games.So Jackson played some SANFL league this year?
Someone needs to teach him how to place his hands for optimum muscle definition.Looks like he’s got a bum in his arm.
![]()
He could be a r1 KPF pick for us in 2019? He's 15 and 186cm tall as of middle of this year - hoo boy!He plays as a CHF at Glenelg u/16's.
West AdelaidePlayers who are tall early, played as KPP, then stop growing ......nearly always fail, as they have only learn't to play as a tallHe could be a r1 KPF pick for us in 2019? He's 15 and 186cm tall as of middle of this year - hoo boy!
Players who are tall early, played as KPP, then stop growing ......nearly always fail, as they have only learn't to play as a tall
Players who are small when young, play as midfielders, then grow .....have a high success rate
Tex Walker played juniors as a Midfielder ......as did Tim English, the Bulldogs Ruckmen
If Luke Edwards stops growing at say 188cm ......he will not have learn't the playing style required for AFL ? ........just a warning
Exactly this. Guys who have only ever played as a Key position player are actually quite limited in there development, unless they are a Tom Lynch type endurance freak. And even he got traded before realising the true role he could play.Players who are tall early, played as KPP, then stop growing ......nearly always fail, as they have only learn't to play as a tall
Players who are small when young, play as midfielders, then grow .....have a high success rate
Tex Walker played juniors as a Midfielder ......as did Tim English, the Bulldogs Ruckmen
If Luke Edwards stops growing at say 188cm ......he will not have learn't the playing style required for AFL ? ........just a warning
Pretty sure Gibbs played as a KPP and even a ruckman early then stopped growing at about 188 cmPlayers who are tall early, played as KPP, then stop growing ......nearly always fail, as they have only learn't to play as a tall
Players who are small when young, play as midfielders, then grow .....have a high success rate
Tex Walker played juniors as a Midfielder ......as did Tim English, the Bulldogs Ruckmen
If Luke Edwards stops growing at say 188cm ......he will not have learn't the playing style required for AFL ? ........just a warning
Obviously he hasn't played at AFL yet (so unproven), but Jaidyn Stephenson too. Was basically a KPF up until this year, after he stopped growing at 189cmPretty sure Gibbs played as a KPP and even a ruckman early then stopped growing at about 188 cm
A perusal of the SANFL stats supports that, don't think a player that plays CHF would figure high in the Clearance count for his team like Luke does.Glenelg's own website referred to Luke Edwards as a "classy midfielder" when he won the u16s BnF and he was named in the midfield in games this year too. This suggests that he is indeed a midfielder.
Exactly this. Guys who have only ever played as a Key position player are actually quite limited in there development, unless they are a Tom Lynch type endurance freak. And even he got traded before realising the true role he could play.
Personally I stopped growing at 15/16, and went from a permanent CHB to a back flanker, but could still run and carry as it is what I had always done and in a similar position. It was at a low level, but still kind of applicable.
Ideally Tyson would ask the club to give him a bit of time developing his ground ball skills in the midfield or intercept marking off of half back. It would improve his all round game and act as a fail safe should he stop growing at ~188-190cm.
18 goals in eight games at U16 level though. Maybe he played CHF there and midfield at U18?A perusal of the SANFL stats supports that, don't think a player that plays CHF would figure high in the Clearance count for his team like Luke does.
http://sanfl.com.au/2017-u18-stats-pdf/
'Ask' vs 'dictate'I don't care who the parent is, but they have no right to dictate to a club on what and how to train their athlete.