Rumour JUH

[The Slitherin' Snake]

I was never a fan of him as a player.

For mine he sits in that grey area of not being enough to a Key Forward, and not being agile, fast and skillful enough to be a Small/Medium Forward.

And his kicking is not good.

The hype nowhere matched the reality of his capabilities.

I'm filthy on how 2025 went down, the position he put the Bulldogs in wand what we got as a trade. But its i think its undeniable he is a super talent. Theres a real chance he kicks 40 goals this year.

 

[Piggy Smalls]

I'm filthy on how 2025 went down, the position he put the Bulldogs in wand what we got as a trade. But its i think its undeniable he is a super talent. Theres a real chance he kicks 40 goals this year.

Its actually very similar to the Jesse Hogan exit from Freo. Cost a lot, provided nothing, traded for a bag of chips...
Now he's almost the premier big key forward in the comp. It hurts.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

But its i think its undeniable he is a super talent.

I literally just denied that he's a super talent.

 

[Golden_6]

I literally just denied that he's a super talent.

He had the 4th most shots on goal in the league in 2024 as a 22 year old. Top 10 for contested marks and marks inside 50 as well.

It’s undeniable that he’s a super talent.

 

[craffles]

Nice long con by GC and the AFL

I am yet to here a logical explanation from yourself as to why JUH would play his role in something that sees his salary go down by $500K PA and his reputation in tatters.

Me thinks you’ve been reading the conspiracies board too much.

 

[BringFevBack2021]

He had the 4th most shots on goal in the league in 2024 as a 22 year old. Top 10 for contested marks and marks inside 50 as well.

It’s undeniable that he’s a super talent.

He’s unbelievable

His ceiling is higher than Curnows

His floor unfortunately is also like a Dan McStay

However a 3rd tall foil that gets you 20-30 goals is still worth having in your side, I’m just hoping he can dominate on the GC

 

[Golden_6]

He’s unbelievable

His ceiling is higher than Curnows

His floor unfortunately is also like a Dan McStay

However a 3rd tall foil that gets you 20-30 goals is still worth having in your side, I’m just hoping he can dominate on the GC

The issue is that a 3rd tall foil has to impact the game in other ways. If he isn't taking marks and kicking goals, he generally struggles. He chooses when to tackle and chase and is often out of position in defensive structures when the ball is turned over.

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

If the plan included JUH looking like he was off the rails to tank his trade value, why would he accept a tiny wage? He’d have had to have been in on it.

Don’t underestimate the finagling by the AFL behind the scenes. The Bulldogs gave Jamarra every chance, every form of assistance, every leeway, yet were not allowed to sanction him in any way, and it was never made clear - to us fans - why that was.

The whole year was a big secret. I don’t even know if the other players knew what was going on.

A couple of ITKs claimed to know more but it’s still a mystery.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Don’t underestimate the finagling by the AFL behind the scenes. The Bulldogs gave Jamarra every chance, every form of assistance, every leeway, yet were not allowed to sanction him in any way, and it was never made clear - to us fans - why that was.

The whole year was a big secret. I don’t even know if the other players knew what was going on.

A couple of ITKs claimed to know more but it’s still a mystery.

You know why that was.

Dont be afraid to say it out aloud

 

[GWT6]

The mental health and indigenous cards were played to the max, no doubt. Which made any criticism verboten. So we really have NFI.

Most of us only had goodwill towards him for a long time. But that never was reciprocated.

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

Gotta admit, it makes me a bit uncomfortable.

 

[420]

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

lol. any suggestions on the PC phrase we can use? or do we prefer to ignore objective reality?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Gotta admit, it makes me a bit uncomfortable.

Mental Health has the exclusive rights to the card

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

It's not meant as a slur. Apologies if you thought so.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

lol. any suggestions on the PC phrase we can use? or do we prefer to ignore objective reality?

Referring to it as a 'card' suggests it's not legitimate.


You should read up on what 'objective reality' means.

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

Ok I'll delete the post.

 

[maddog37]

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

 

[Tandy]

That Jed Walter from GC will be coming for JUH. Hope it works out for JUH but it’s going to be tough to cement a spot. I like him, he reminds me of a 90s footballer. Whippet like. But I do agree with whoever said over hyped for capabilities or something similar.

 

[420]

Referring to it as a 'card' suggests it's not legitimate.


You should read up on what 'objective reality' means.

Because in this context, it isn't legimate. Why should race determine whether you are sanctioned when you fk up?

 

[420]

Using a slur like "the Indigenous card" should be an automatic ban.

No issue with the "mental health card" phrase GWT? Just the race one?

 

[Mighty Storm]

The issue is that a 3rd tall foil has to impact the game in other ways. If he isn't taking marks and kicking goals, he generally struggles. He chooses when to tackle and chase and is often out of position in defensive structures when the ball is turned over.

Pretty much the same as curnow when he doesn’t have the ball

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

Because in this context, it isn't legimate. Why should race determine whether you are sanctioned when you fk up?

How do you know it's not legitimate?

And race doesn't determine whether you are sanctioned when you fk up. Not always. But in some cases it absolutely can be a factor in how punishments, penalties and/or deterrents are approached.

It's utterly ignorant to not be aware of this.

 

[The Slitherin' Snake]

How do you know it's not legitimate?

And race doesn't determine whether you are sanctioned when you fk up. Not always. But in some cases it absolutely can be a factor in how punishments, penalties and/or deterrents are approached.

It's utterly ignorant to not be aware of this.

You've just unintenionally agreed with the point you are arguing against.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

You've just unintenionally agreed with the point you are arguing against.

Unless I misinterpreted the post I responded to, I'm not agreeing with it at all.

 

[GWT6]

lol. any suggestions on the PC phrase we can use? or do we prefer to ignore objective reality?

I bet you like Pauline Hansen because "she tells it like it is".