Marc Murphy vs. Chris Judd

[Elite Master]

Out of the 2 going forward, who would you rather take?

Murphy looks to have stepped it up a gear and in my opinion has been better then Judd for the most part of the latter stages of last season. He looks even slicker this season. Absolute gun.

 

[WCEbrody]

Out of the 2 going forward, who would you rather take?

Murphy looks to have stepped it up a gear and in my opinion has been better then Judd for the most part of the latter stages of last season. He looks even slicker this season. Absolute gun.

Pretty obvious who you'd choose then, Judd is 29/30.

Still think Judd is better at certain parts of the game,but Murphy has overtaken him in a lot of areas and will continue to do so IMO.

 

[Elite Master]

Pretty obvious who you'd choose then, Judd is 29/30.

Still think Judd is better at certain parts of the game,but Murphy has overtaken him in a lot of areas and will continue to do so IMO.

Yes but if your club is in its premiership window and generally feel that Judd offers more right now then it all of a sudden swings in that direction.

Judd said a couple of years ago that Murphy reminded him of himself when he was at West Coast. Pretty sure he was referring to the similarities in his blistering pace which is fair to say he's lost a bit at Carlton.

 

[blues4flag]

Can't split the two. Imagine them on the same team.

 

[17beams]

Murphy eaisly thought he was just as good as Judd last night despite having someone actually play on him, uses the ball so much better than Judd as well.

 

[Bordi]

Murphy eaisly thought he was just as good as Judd last night despite having someone actually play on him, uses the ball so much better than Judd as well.

Did u not watch the part where they interviewed the brissy coach??? 'how are u going to control judd'..... 'its a team effort' thereby implying they will be rotating players off him.. u really think a team would let judd run free for a game? the doggies tried it a few yrs ago, going head to head with cooney.. heres a tip, it didnt work!

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Out of the 2 going forward, who would you rather take?

Murphy looks to have stepped it up a gear and in my opinion has been better then Judd for the most part of the latter stages of last season. He looks even slicker this season. Absolute gun.

"going forward" -> Murphy

Right this minute -> Judd

 

[eth-dog]

Did u not watch the part where they interviewed the brissy coach??? 'how are u going to control judd'..... 'its a team effort' thereby implying they will be rotating players off him.. u really think a team would let judd run free for a game? the doggies tried it a few yrs ago, going head to head with cooney.. heres a tip, it didnt work!

Do you not understand how much they're obsessed with Judd? Channel 7 cream themselves over him as much as Robert Walls does, which is way too much.

Murphy is the difference between Carlton and Essendon, if you think about it:

Watson=Judd
Murphy>>>Zaharakis (who we want to become the Murphy type player)
Stanton>Simpson
Hocking=Carrazzo
Heppell<Gibbs

 

[blues4flag]

Do you not understand how much they're obsessed with Judd? Channel 7 cream themselves over him as much as Robert Walls does, which is way too much.

Murphy is the difference between Carlton and Essendon, if you think about it:

Watson=Judd
Murphy>>>Zaharakis (who we want to become the Murphy type player)
Stanton>Simpson
Hocking=Carrazzo
Heppell<Gibbs

You are delusional if you think Murph is the only difference between our midfields.

 

[BoozeKreuze93]

Do you not understand how much they're obsessed with Judd? Channel 7 cream themselves over him as much as Robert Walls does, which is way too much.

Murphy is the difference between Carlton and Essendon, if you think about it:

Watson=Judd
Murphy>>>Zaharakis (who we want to become the Murphy type player)
Stanton>Simpson
Hocking=Carrazzo
Heppell<Gibbs

Watson as good as Judd??

 

[jonoman89]

Murphy is the difference between Carlton and Essendon, if you think about it:

Watson=Judd
Murphy>>>Zaharakis (who we want to become the Murphy type player)
Stanton>Simpson
Hocking=Carrazzo
Heppell<Gibbs

Did lol.

 

[17beams]

Did u not watch the part where they interviewed the brissy coach??? 'how are u going to control judd'..... 'its a team effort' thereby implying they will be rotating players off him.. u really think a team would let judd run free for a game? the doggies tried it a few yrs ago, going head to head with cooney.. heres a tip, it didnt work!

Did you not watch the game? The amount of times Brisbane left Judd to stand out by himself at a stopage was criminal. Murphy actually had a tagger, I'm sure Judd had a "matchup" but you can't afford to tag two players in the middle.

 

[The Edukator]

Do you not understand how much they're obsessed with Judd? Channel 7 cream themselves over him as much as Robert Walls does, which is way too much.

Murphy is the difference between Carlton and Essendon, if you think about it:

Watson<<<Judd
Murphy>>>Zaharakis (who we want to become the Murphy type player)
Stanton<Simpson(check polls board for solace)
Hocking<Carrazzo
Heppell<<<<<<<<Gibbs

EFA.

were u meant to post this in the bay?

 

[bradles7]

Out of the 2 going forward, who would you rather take?

Murphy looks to have stepped it up a gear and in my opinion has been better then Judd for the most part of the latter stages of last season. He looks even slicker this season. Absolute gun.

murphy is a gun yes but i would still say judd from experince