Matt Crouch is just a plodder.

[Asgardian]

DBJ is gonna be one damn good POWERMAN

 

[Brentmeister]

Which reminds me.......... how IS Cameron "The next Adam Goodes" Ellis-Yolmen going?

Don't think anyone was calling CEY the "next adam Goodes". About 99% of poort power fans were calling John Butcher "the future" though. Lol

 

[Brentmeister]

What exactly does krouch do well as a footballer?

In and under, hard-nosed mid. Gets plenty of contested ball and clearances at the coal face and feeds it out to the runners. If you can't see the value in that then you are truly cooked.

 

[RonSon]

DBJ got 0 votes, but Crouch should have got more than 7 votes, which means that DBJ is a better player. Love that logic.

So what you're trying to say is that Boak is a better captain than Walker?

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

So what you're trying to say is that Boak is a better captain than Walker?

Sloane > Gray?

 

[RonSon]

Sloane > Gray?

It was a question, ask douglyzia but it seems to be the crux of his argument that your captain is worse than ours.

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

It was a question, ask douglyzia but it seems to be the crux of his argument that your captain is worse than ours.

Keep clutching those straws Ronny

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

In and under, hard-nosed mid. Gets plenty of contested ball and clearances at the coal face and feeds it out to the runners. If you can't see the value in that then you are truly cooked.

"In and under midfielder" and "gets plenty of contested ball" lol literally do you even watch him? Literally every week by the end of the year I was coming on here saying Krouch with another 18-20 uncontested disposals. He averages 11 contested and 18 uncontested? You're kidding yourself if you think that is a in and under midfielder.

Let's look at his last games
Sydney- 21 uncontested
North- 23 uncontested (only 5 contested)
WC- 18 uncontested
Port- 21 uncontested
Fremantle- 18 uncontested
Brisbane- 27 uncontested (only 6 contested)

I could literally go on but I think you got the point... you're absolutely kidding yourself if you actually believe what you're saying... the facts are he finds easy disposals through uncontested disposals and handballs it to people with talent. That's all he does.

 

[RonSon]

Keep clutching those straws Ronny

How else am I supposed to interpret his post? He's the one suggesting Boak > Walker.

 

[relapse]

LOL! which is exactly our point.. every port person here has said he is good at finding the ball, but he does absolutely nothing with those disposals.. this is evident through his pathetic Brownlow score for midfielder who averages such high disposals

Matt Crouch's disposal stats were similar to Taylor Adams, Jack McRae and Dylan Shiel

Taylor Adams 5 votes
Jack McRae 1 vote
Dylan Shiel 7 votes

You Puffers really don't think before you post

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

How else am I supposed to interpret his post? He's the one suggesting Boak > Walker.

Since when do you suddenly care about his opinion? Is it because it now suits your argument?

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Matt Crouch's disposal stats were similar to Taylor Adams, Jack McRae and Dylan Shiel

Taylor Adams 5 votes
Jack McRae 1 vote
Dylan Shiel 7 votes

You Puffers really don't think before you post

Taylor Adams: lol clutching at straws, 14 games in a bottom 8 team, still nearly beat Krouch who played 20 in a team that won 16 lol
I'm assuming jack Macrae: what a surprise that a player who averages a truck load of uncontested disposals and handballs in a team with a good midfield doesn't get votes... he is exactly like krouch (krouch gets more votes coz he is playing in a team with a shit midfield) but jack is more talented.
Shiel: unlucky, should had got more votes, but with gws talent, no surprise other stole votes off him

 

[Maddogmetro]

Nice av D/H

Lol when your argument resorts to that, you know you've lost.

You see, I actually backed my own team, who happened to lose a tough final. Unlike Poort flogs who only back a favourite, which never includes their own pathetic team.

 

[Maddogmetro]

Pretty funny that, with all the Puffing and trying to discredit the explanations about why Crouch is a good footballer (which includes OBJECTIVE stats), there is no talk at all about DBJ. None. The Puffers are trying to draw attention away from how pathetic DBJ's second half of the season was.

There is no way on earth that you can honestly say that DBJ is a better player. You can criticise Crouch all you want, but he is better by a mile.

 

[Brentmeister]

"In and under midfielder" and "gets plenty of contested ball" lol literally do you even watch him? Literally every week by the end of the year I was coming on here saying Krouch with another 18-20 uncontested disposals. He averages 11 contested and 18 uncontested? You're kidding yourself if you think that is a in and under midfielder.

Let's look at his last games
Sydney- 21 uncontested
North- 23 uncontested (only 5 contested)
WC- 18 uncontested
Port- 21 uncontested
Fremantle- 18 uncontested
Brisbane- 27 uncontested (only 6 contested)

I could literally go on but I think you got the point... you're absolutely kidding yourself if you actually believe what you're saying... the facts are he finds easy disposals through uncontested disposals and handballs it to people with talent. That's all he does.

Crouch is 25th in the competition for contested possessions per game and 33rd for clearances per game. The only Poort players above him in those categories are Gray and Wines. Where are the rest of your mids? Boak? Lol

Comparing Crouch Jr to DBJ is unfair as DBJ is so ordinary. Comparing him to Wines is probably more accurate. Sadly Wines' ball use is so crap he's a glorified SANFL player.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Pretty funny that, with all the Puffing and trying to discredit the explanations about why Crouch is a good footballer (which includes OBJECTIVE stats), there is no talk at all about DBJ. None. The Puffers are trying to draw attention away from how pathetic DBJ's second half of the season was.

There is no way on earth that you can honestly say that DBJ is a better player. You can criticise Crouch all you want, but he is better by a mile.

But yet you and your flogs that can't think of anything that Krouch actually does well as a footballer! The only response to that question included lies and delusion, saying he gets heaps on contested ball which is a lie.


A young, fast, skilful HBF is better then a slow, non skilful, easy disposals, handballing plobber

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Crouch is 25th in the competition for contested possessions per game and 33rd for clearances per game. The only Poort players above him in those categories are Gray and Wines. Where are the rest of your mids? Boak? Lol

Comparing Crouch Jr to DBJ is unfair as DBJ is so ordinary. Comparing him to Wines is probably more accurate. Sadly Wines' ball use is so crap he's a glorified SANFL player.

View attachment 294196

He is actually equal with 2 other men at 28th in the comp di*khead, do your research. For a man that averages 28 disposals, that pretty much proves my point.


You say all this but wines ended up with more Brownlow votes then Krouch, and Wines isn't in a team that finished with 16 wins, lol pretty much paints the picture.

And let's ignore that wines is better at most stats then krouch in that graphic

 

[RonSon]

Since when do you suddenly care about his opinion? Is it because it now suits your argument?

I didn't put forward an argument. I asked a question.

He was the one making the argument that you can blindly follow brownlow votes as a complete gauge of a players worth and that Boak is a better and fairer captain than Walker.


I suggest you take up the issue with douglyzia.

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

I didn't put forward an argument. I asked a question.

So who do you think is the better captain? Boak or Walker?

 

[Brentmeister]

He is actually equal with 2 other men at 28th in the comp di*khead, do your research. For a man that averages 28 disposals, that pretty much proves my point.

Well done numuts! Maybe you should do some research. And keep the language down. It really illustrates how much you're melting!! lol

You say all this but wines ended up with more Brownlow votes then Krouch, and Wines isn't in a team that finished with 16 wins, lol pretty much paints the picture.

So because Wines got more brownlow votes than Crouch, he's a better player. What does that say about Crouch and DBJ/Impey? Lol you just fell victim to your own poxy argument! Lol

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Well done numuts! Maybe you should do some research. And keep the language down. It really illustrates how much you're melting!! lol

View attachment 294201



So because Wines got more brownlow votes than Crouch, he's a better player. What does that say about Crouch and DBJ/Impey? Lol you just fell victim to your own poxy argument! Lol

Are you really that dumb that you can't even see when someone is using your own stupid argument against you to show you how stupid it is... lol

 

[Maddogmetro]

But yet you and your flogs that can't think of anything that Krouch actually does well as a footballer! The only response to that question included lies and delusion, saying he gets heaps on contested ball which is a lie.


A young, fast, skilful HBF is better then a slow, non skilful, easy disposals, handballing plobber

Lol there you go with your amazing objective stats again,

'Young! Fast! Skilful!' well done on that amazing analysis. You seriously are mentally challenged if you don't understand this after 58 ****ing pages.

 

[RonSon]

So who do you think is the better captain? Boak or Walker?

Why would you like an answer, do you value my opinion?

 

[Drakescoffeecake]

Why would you like an answer, do you value my opinion?

Absolutely not. I just would like to know. So tell me.

 

[RonSon]

Absolutely not. I just would like to know. So tell me.

lol