Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

McPharlin an Eagle???

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

LOL... remember the Polly frenzy a couple of years back? The palpitations for them over McPharlin would put some of them in hospital... ;)
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

In a flash. No worries... :D

You'll have to chuck your 4th rounder in as a sweetener though. Actually, no, we'll chuck ours in instead. :p
 
ImperialPurple said:
In a flash. No worries... :D

You'll have to chuck your 4th rounder in as a sweetener though. Actually, no, we'll chuck ours in instead. :p
Click to expand...

Deal. ( with you chucking in your 4th rounder)
 
kidstyler said:
i second that!

woosha would give his left leg for a player that can mark up foward! :D
Click to expand...
Oh goody another Eagles v Frockers thread :)

Pavlova has been a great marking power up forward for you this year and I'm sure that you are aware that he leads the comp in this stat to date. Respect to him for that, but if you take a look at the whole stats list you would be very disappointed with what comes after.

I'll help you out with a cut and paste to save you searching. I'll even make it pretty (simple) for you with some fancy colours.


MARKS
1. Matthew Pavlich Fremantle 132
2. Warren Tredrea Port Adelaide 122
3. Robert Murphy Western Bulldogs 116
4. Matthew Richardson Richmond 115
5. Adam McPhee Essendon 113
6. Brett Montgomery Port Adelaide 107
7. Barry Hall Sydney Swans 102
8. Joel Bowden Richmond 100
9. Leo Barry Sydney Swans 97
10. Shane Crawford Hawthorn 94
11. Jess Sinclair Kangaroos 94
12. Brad Green Melbourne 92
13. Brad Johnson Western Bulldogs 91
14. Rohan Smith Western Bulldogs 91
15. Nathan Thompson Kangaroos 90
16. Andrew Welsh Essendon 90
17. Andrew Embley West Coast Eagles 89
18. Chad Fletcher West Coast Eagles 89
19. Andrew Kellaway Richmond 89
20. Troy Simmonds Richmond 88 (Oops)
21. Chad Cornes Port Adelaide 88
22. Ashley Hansen West Coast Eagles 88 (Average 6.28)
23. Cameron Ling Geelong 88
24. Peter Everitt Hawthorn 85
25. Nathan D. Brown Melbourne 85
26. Dean Cox West Coast Eagles 84
27. Daniel Cross Western Bulldogs 83
28. Matthew Scarlett Geelong 83
29. Shannon Grant Kangaroos 83
30. Darren Milburn Geelong 83
31. Lance Whitnall Carlton 83
32. Paul Licuria Collingwood 83
33. Scott Lucas Essendon 83
34. Jarrad Waite Carlton 82
35. Russell Robertson Melbourne 82
36. Brad Miller Melbourne 81
37. Darryl Wakelin Port Adelaide 81
38. Luke Hodge Hawthorn 81
39. Heath Black Fremantle 80
40. Justin Leppitsch Brisbane Lions 80
41. Michael Braun West Coast Eagles 80
42. Nathan Eagleton Western Bulldogs 79
43. Adam Hunter West Coast Eagles 79
44. Jason Johnson Essendon 79
45. Leigh Colbert Kangaroos 78
46. Lindsay Gilbee Western Bulldogs 78
47. Fraser Gehrig St Kilda 77
48. Wayne Campbell Richmond 76
49. Ben Cousins West Coast Eagles 76
50. Kent Kingsley Geelong 76
51. James Clement Collingwood 75
52. Chris Tarrant Collingwood 75
53. Mark Coughlan Richmond 75
54. Adam Goodes Sydney Swans 74
55. Daniel Giansiracusa Western Bulldogs 74
56. Justin Murphy Essendon 74
57. Jonathan Brown Brisbane Lions 74
58. Daniel Bradshaw Brisbane Lions 73
59. Trent Croad Hawthorn 73
60. Brett Voss St Kilda 73
61. Clint Bizzell Melbourne 73
62. Mark Johnson Essendon 72
63. Ian Perrie Adelaide 72
64. Tim Clarke Hawthorn 71
65. Kane Cornes Port Adelaide 71
66. Brendon Goddard St Kilda 71
67. Mark Williams Hawthorn 70
68. Justin Longmuir Fremantle 70
69. Paul Medhurst Fremantle 70
70. Chris Johnson Brisbane Lions 70
71. Tarkyn Lockyer Collingwood 70
72. Shane Wakelin Collingwood 69
73. Jimmy Bartel Geelong 69
74. Luke McPharlin Fremantle 69 (Average 6.27)

Looks like Woosha limbs are safe on this one kid ;)
 
Eagles4Eva said:
Oh goody another Eagles v Frockers thread :)

Pavlova has been a great marking power up forward for you this year and I'm sure that you are aware that he leads the comp in this stat to date. Respect to him for that, but if you take a look at the whole stats list you would be very disappointed with what comes after.

I'll help you out with a cut and paste to save you searching. I'll even make it pretty (simple) for you with some fancy colours.


MARKS
1. Matthew Pavlich Fremantle 132
2. Warren Tredrea Port Adelaide 122
3. Robert Murphy Western Bulldogs 116
4. Matthew Richardson Richmond 115
5. Adam McPhee Essendon 113
6. Brett Montgomery Port Adelaide 107
7. Barry Hall Sydney Swans 102
8. Joel Bowden Richmond 100
9. Leo Barry Sydney Swans 97
10. Shane Crawford Hawthorn 94
11. Jess Sinclair Kangaroos 94
12. Brad Green Melbourne 92
13. Brad Johnson Western Bulldogs 91
14. Rohan Smith Western Bulldogs 91
15. Nathan Thompson Kangaroos 90
16. Andrew Welsh Essendon 90
17. Andrew Embley West Coast Eagles 89
18. Chad Fletcher West Coast Eagles 89
19. Andrew Kellaway Richmond 89
20. Troy Simmonds Richmond 88 (Oops)
21. Chad Cornes Port Adelaide 88
22. Ashley Hansen West Coast Eagles 88 (Average 6.28)
23. Cameron Ling Geelong 88
24. Peter Everitt Hawthorn 85
25. Nathan D. Brown Melbourne 85
26. Dean Cox West Coast Eagles 84
27. Daniel Cross Western Bulldogs 83
28. Matthew Scarlett Geelong 83
29. Shannon Grant Kangaroos 83
30. Darren Milburn Geelong 83
31. Lance Whitnall Carlton 83
32. Paul Licuria Collingwood 83
33. Scott Lucas Essendon 83
34. Jarrad Waite Carlton 82
35. Russell Robertson Melbourne 82
36. Brad Miller Melbourne 81
37. Darryl Wakelin Port Adelaide 81
38. Luke Hodge Hawthorn 81
39. Heath Black Fremantle 80
40. Justin Leppitsch Brisbane Lions 80
41. Michael Braun West Coast Eagles 80
42. Nathan Eagleton Western Bulldogs 79
43. Adam Hunter West Coast Eagles 79
44. Jason Johnson Essendon 79
45. Leigh Colbert Kangaroos 78
46. Lindsay Gilbee Western Bulldogs 78
47. Fraser Gehrig St Kilda 77
48. Wayne Campbell Richmond 76
49. Ben Cousins West Coast Eagles 76
50. Kent Kingsley Geelong 76
51. James Clement Collingwood 75
52. Chris Tarrant Collingwood 75
53. Mark Coughlan Richmond 75
54. Adam Goodes Sydney Swans 74
55. Daniel Giansiracusa Western Bulldogs 74
56. Justin Murphy Essendon 74
57. Jonathan Brown Brisbane Lions 74
58. Daniel Bradshaw Brisbane Lions 73
59. Trent Croad Hawthorn 73
60. Brett Voss St Kilda 73
61. Clint Bizzell Melbourne 73
62. Mark Johnson Essendon 72
63. Ian Perrie Adelaide 72
64. Tim Clarke Hawthorn 71
65. Kane Cornes Port Adelaide 71
66. Brendon Goddard St Kilda 71
67. Mark Williams Hawthorn 70
68. Justin Longmuir Fremantle 70
69. Paul Medhurst Fremantle 70
70. Chris Johnson Brisbane Lions 70
71. Tarkyn Lockyer Collingwood 70
72. Shane Wakelin Collingwood 69
73. Jimmy Bartel Geelong 69
74. Luke McPharlin Fremantle 69 (Average 6.27)

Looks like Woosha limbs are safe on this one kid ;)
Click to expand...

I thought the thread was someone who can mark up forward, not in the middle of the ground?? that 6.27 would be in either the forward 50 or defensive 50 would it not?
 
yes i think eagles4eva has the arse end of the stick!

embley is now injured so for the rest of the season you are going to rely on chad Fletcher to take all your marks inside 50?! :rolleyes:

you know whats funny but! where is lynch in that list?! :D
 
rickjames said:
I thought the thread was someone who can mark up forward, not in the middle of the ground?? that 6.27 would be in either the forward 50 or defensive 50 would it not?
Click to expand...

Re: McPharlin an Eagle
kidstyler said:
woosha would give his left leg for a player that can mark up foward! :D
Click to expand...

kidstyler seems to think he is, but i agree with you that he has played both back and forward for those marks.
Even so, Hansen has taken more grabs than any other player from Freo bar Pavlich, then you throw in Embley at 6.35 per game and it proves that we do have reasonable marking power up forward.

It's no big deal but just a responce to kidstylers comments that we are struggling in the "marking" departmant of our game.

Maybe he will learn to do a little research next time before he shoots his mouth off.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ImperialPurple said:
The sub-title when Luke was being interviewed:

Luke McPharlin
Eagles Defender

Like I said - they wish...
Click to expand...

You're Right IP In there dreams
 
Eagles4Eva said:
Oh goody another Eagles v Frockers thread :)

Pavlova has been a great marking power up forward for you this year and I'm sure that you are aware that he leads the comp in this stat to date. Respect to him for that, but if you take a look at the whole stats list you would be very disappointed with what comes after.

I'll help you out with a cut and paste to save you searching. I'll even make it pretty (simple) for you with some fancy colours.


MARKS
1. Matthew Pavlich Fremantle 132
2. Warren Tredrea Port Adelaide 122
3. Robert Murphy Western Bulldogs 116
4. Matthew Richardson Richmond 115
5. Adam McPhee Essendon 113
6. Brett Montgomery Port Adelaide 107
7. Barry Hall Sydney Swans 102
8. Joel Bowden Richmond 100
9. Leo Barry Sydney Swans 97
10. Shane Crawford Hawthorn 94
11. Jess Sinclair Kangaroos 94
12. Brad Green Melbourne 92
13. Brad Johnson Western Bulldogs 91
14. Rohan Smith Western Bulldogs 91
15. Nathan Thompson Kangaroos 90
16. Andrew Welsh Essendon 90
17. Andrew Embley West Coast Eagles 89
18. Chad Fletcher West Coast Eagles 89
19. Andrew Kellaway Richmond 89
20. Troy Simmonds Richmond 88 (Oops)
21. Chad Cornes Port Adelaide 88
22. Ashley Hansen West Coast Eagles 88 (Average 6.28)
23. Cameron Ling Geelong 88
24. Peter Everitt Hawthorn 85
25. Nathan D. Brown Melbourne 85
26. Dean Cox West Coast Eagles 84
27. Daniel Cross Western Bulldogs 83
28. Matthew Scarlett Geelong 83
29. Shannon Grant Kangaroos 83
30. Darren Milburn Geelong 83
31. Lance Whitnall Carlton 83
32. Paul Licuria Collingwood 83
33. Scott Lucas Essendon 83
34. Jarrad Waite Carlton 82
35. Russell Robertson Melbourne 82
36. Brad Miller Melbourne 81
37. Darryl Wakelin Port Adelaide 81
38. Luke Hodge Hawthorn 81
39. Heath Black Fremantle 80
40. Justin Leppitsch Brisbane Lions 80
41. Michael Braun West Coast Eagles 80
42. Nathan Eagleton Western Bulldogs 79
43. Adam Hunter West Coast Eagles 79
44. Jason Johnson Essendon 79
45. Leigh Colbert Kangaroos 78
46. Lindsay Gilbee Western Bulldogs 78
47. Fraser Gehrig St Kilda 77
48. Wayne Campbell Richmond 76
49. Ben Cousins West Coast Eagles 76
50. Kent Kingsley Geelong 76
51. James Clement Collingwood 75
52. Chris Tarrant Collingwood 75
53. Mark Coughlan Richmond 75
54. Adam Goodes Sydney Swans 74
55. Daniel Giansiracusa Western Bulldogs 74
56. Justin Murphy Essendon 74
57. Jonathan Brown Brisbane Lions 74
58. Daniel Bradshaw Brisbane Lions 73
59. Trent Croad Hawthorn 73
60. Brett Voss St Kilda 73
61. Clint Bizzell Melbourne 73
62. Mark Johnson Essendon 72
63. Ian Perrie Adelaide 72
64. Tim Clarke Hawthorn 71
65. Kane Cornes Port Adelaide 71
66. Brendon Goddard St Kilda 71
67. Mark Williams Hawthorn 70
68. Justin Longmuir Fremantle 70
69. Paul Medhurst Fremantle 70
70. Chris Johnson Brisbane Lions 70
71. Tarkyn Lockyer Collingwood 70
72. Shane Wakelin Collingwood 69
73. Jimmy Bartel Geelong 69
74. Luke McPharlin Fremantle 69 (Average 6.27)

Looks like Woosha limbs are safe on this one kid ;)
Click to expand...
imagine 6.27 + 6.28 in the forward line. Embley takes most of his marks across the centre and Fletcher takes most in the back half. You are telling me you would prefer Lynch or Hansen to Mcpharlin? What a knob. If freo had your midfield mcpharlin would average 10-12 marks a game.
 
Eagles4Eva said:
Oh goody another Eagles v Frockers thread

Pavlova has been a great marking power up forward for you this year and I'm sure that you are aware that he leads the comp in this stat to date. Respect to him for that, but if you take a look at the whole stats list you would be very disappointed with what comes after.

I'll help you out with a cut and paste to save you searching. I'll even make it pretty (simple) for you with some fancy colours.


MARKS
1. Matthew Pavlich Fremantle 132
2. Warren Tredrea Port Adelaide 122
3. Robert Murphy Western Bulldogs 116
SNIP....
Click to expand...


Unless you plan on transplanting your midfield to your forward line, I don't see what the point of that was E4E. I suppose you have to keep the nonsensical ramblings quota up though :p .


Come on, are you seriously saying you'd rather Lynch as a marking target than McPharlin? UNIT and the rest of your brains trust can go on about how the "Big Unit will start to pull those overhead marks in", but it's kind of like us saying "Dion WILL lay a sheperd or a tackle someday, lets keep him in the team" ;).
 
Of course i would have Pavlich or McPharlin any day before any of our tall forwards, but i suppose the point i was trying to prove (in responce to kidstylers post) is that the inclusion of Hansen in our forward line has certainly strightened up our spine and given us a target up forward. The lad has done well and relished the opportunity handed to him this year and can only get better.

As for Lynch, no, I'm still far from convinced that he is the man for FF, but with McDougall out of form and the injury to Smith, what would you do if you were JW? At least he's a big body, always gives 100%, and provides a contest which gives the small forwards a chance.
 
that why i said this:

woosha would give his left leg for a player that can mark up foward!

you know what up forward is ... in the forward line like where that hack lynch plays (who isnt on ya little stat sheet btw)!! listern next time. make ya self look like an idiot pulling out stats from midfielders marking....
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

kidstyler said:
i second that!

woosha would give his left leg for a player that can mark up foward! :D
Click to expand...

Yes, it must be terrible for Woosha to have the best attack in the competition. We really need your players to come and help us out. Maybe CC could come and give us some coaching tips as well.
 
MSR273 said:
Yes, it must be terrible for Woosha to have the best attack in the competition. We really need your players to come and help us out. Maybe CC could come and give us some coaching tips as well.
Click to expand...

io mate i hear someone opening up a bottle of WA's finest. run along now....
 
kidstyler said:
io mate i hear someone opening up a bottle of WA's finest. run along now....
Click to expand...

Does this mean we don't get McPharlin. Oh well, looks like we will have to struggle on without him.
 
MSR273 said:
Does this mean we don't get McPharlin. Oh well, looks like we will have to struggle on without him.
Click to expand...

yeah who are you going to give us for mcpharlin?!

mcdud?!
 
ImperialPurple said:
As if your lot wouldn't love to have McPharlin in bluenyella.... ;)
Click to expand...
It would be an improvment for anyone rather than rednwhitengreennpurplen..umm.. did i leave one out? :confused:

:p
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom