- Joined
- Feb 25, 2014
- Posts
- 32,084
- Reaction score
- 70,159
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, England, Furies
- Thread starter
- #101
*****me, wish I'd written that.How many top picks did these clubs have before or during this? Our problem was that we were improving slowly, so not getting the best picks like Melb, didn't lose anyone and get compensated for it (Scully for example), no father sons like the Bullies (Wallis and Libba were 2 good gets) and with precious little quality cattle to trade. If we spend as much time at the very bottom as Melb did, we will eventually beat someone by a point despite them having killed us in virtually every stat and people could laud us as improving like you have done!
Dogs have been almost as disappointing as us this year.... they were meant to rise and haven't. They have quality players in their squad, Cooney, Griffen etc (who have played many big finals) but have really struggled to put it together since.
Melbourne have had 34 wins since 2006 (not counting this season). That has given them top draft picks prior to the compromised drafts and since.
Crap as we are, we've had 48 wins and some draws, without some of the above luxuries the others had and an upward trend until this year. The AFL haven't seen fit to give us millions of dollars to boost our coaching and development staff, despite finding that we were tanking and we've had to pull ourselves out of debt...
Port were down the bottom for 2 minutes, traded well, decided that the favourite son might not have been the best coach and got lucky with a coaching appointment (nobody wanted to coach Port and Hinkley got it by default) and made a coup with Burgess. Got a player that wanted to come home in Polec, top draft picks like Hartlett finally showed something, picked up Wines, Wingard kept their main guns in Boak, Trengrove, Kane Cornes etc and got quality in for Burgoyne, Chaplin etc. They've done well but it is an exception rather than a rule of how things go....
We have work to do but it was unlikely to be linear improvement forever. If it continues to be terrible next year then yeah, change a bunch of stuff but for now, I'd just be concentrating on getting rid of some players and bringing some quality youth and experience in.
For me:
Out: TV/Griff (need at least one of them on the list and we'll get better trade value for TV IMO), King, Newy, A.Edwards, Orren (ret), Hampson (delist - but will leave us very ruck poor so can understand him staying for 2015 as reserve ruck only), Helbig/O'Hanlon (let them fight for it), Knights (too injury prone), Thomas (limited with the pace of AFL now - happy to re-rookie)
In: Miles (elevate), 1st rounder, 2nd rounder X 2 (get at least this for TV, hopefully higher, or 2nd rounder + player - someone we need, like a crumbing forward, hit up forward), experience gun, throw the cash book around, 3rd rounder. Maybe even target a Luke Lowden type ruckman to develop/play. Anyone other than Hampson.
Probably haven't got my sums right but something along these lines for 2015. Further cuts of 6-8 the year after including Foley (unless we get a good deal for him this year), Helbig/O'Hanlon, Hampson definitely, Grigg, Gordon (if he hasn't made it), Batch if he hasn't made it....
Clear out the rookie list: Bye bye Todd Banfield, need state league ruckman here at least








