milburn v mcphee v osborne

[ad4eva]

cant go anything over this price range (304,000) or sumthing so these are my best options, along with roughead and bradshaw.

how should i go for?

 

[Schulzenfest]

Definitely not Osborne, if I was you I would wait a few weeks for McPhee to drop in price further and if he starts playing well out of the backline again then pick him. If you can't wait Milburn will definitely average around 80 and is the safest bet. It's a risk/reward between him and McPhee

 

[Hirdy_5]

Would go for Milburn as he is the most consistant of the lot, Im not sold on Osbourne yet, and i wouldnt get Mcphee untill he start playing of the Half backline again which won't be untill Lucas comes back...

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Milburn!!!

 

[maverick001]

Is Drummond worth a punt at $334k? Solid dream teamer last year, is there any reason why he shouldnt perform again this year? Perhaps not as good value as Milburn though....
I have Symes sitting on my bench, hence a defender short. Anyone else think he will struggle to avg. 80 trying to break back into Crows' bolstered midfield now that all Crows mids are fit and firing. Ie thinking of trading him to Milburn/Drummond or trading one of Proud/SDT to Myers

 

[Blinger]

Is Drummond worth a punt at $334k? Solid dream teamer last year, is there any reason why he shouldnt perform again this year? Perhaps not as good value as Milburn though....
I have Symes sitting on my bench, hence a defender short. Anyone else think he will struggle to avg. 80 trying to break back into Crows' bolstered midfield now that all Crows mids are fit and firing. Ie thinking of trading him to Milburn/Drummond or trading one of Proud/SDT to Myers

Wait at least another week or two on Drummond.

 

[Daz]

Wait at least another week or two on Drummond.

way too injury prone! avoid him at all costs. have a look at the gaes he's played since 2005.

2005: 14
2006: 7
2007:13
2008: he's already been injured once!

just for good measure lets look at how durable milburn is

2005:25
2006: 22
2007: 23
2008: played every game.

if that doesn't convince you nothing will

 

[maverick001]

thanks dazza, will steer clear