Recommitted Miles Bergman [re-signed for 2 years]

[ABAB]

No worries buddy, best of luck come finals.

View attachment 2356164

We aren't premiership contenders yet

 

[#Port Patriot#]

Youngers doesn't mean quality youngsters and don't name Sinn or Jones.

Younger team then Crows last year and this year and they literally made preliminary final last season. where were Crows? This year they've sucked for majority and unfortunately had injuries and troubles since round 1 putting structures out of whack. Seriously, out of all the Crows posters, you are a stain and delusional self absorbed imbecile.

 

[ABAB]

Younger team then Crows last year and this year and they literally made preliminary final last season. where were Crows? This year they've sucked for majority and unfortunately had injuries and troubles since round 1 putting structures out of whack. Seriously, out of all the Crows posters, you are a stain and delusional self absorbed imbecile.

Again younger player doesn't mean quality young players. I mean, I didn't say Bergman and Soldo to the Saints for NWM lol.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Commiserations Crows fans.

 

[ReturningHawk]

Guess you don’t watch Port games then.

I have watched enough to know that Bergman is not in the same category as Rankine. Is that controversial to you?

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Seriously good signing from Port if this eventuates.

Thought he was gone for all money.

If they add NWM and don't lose Butters or Bergman they are turning their back on a rebuild that is for sure.

If butters and Bergman re sign I don’t see how they could possibly get a trade done for nwm

 

[PortAdelFC1997]

If butters and Bergman re sign I don’t see how they could possibly get a trade done for nwm

Only way I can see a hypothetical trade work out is if Port gets access to Doug Cochrane as an NGA player in the 2026 draft and is in the mix to be taken as the No.1 Pick.

From there Port will use their 2026 1st rounder as the basis of the deal and do all those mumbo jumbo pick swaps etc.

Having said that, I think NWM will recommit to St Kilda for two years.

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Only way I can see a hypothetical trade work out is if Port gets access to Doug Cochrane as an NGA player in the 2026 draft and is in the mix to be taken as the No.1 Pick.

From there Port will use their 2026 1st rounder as the basis of the deal and do all those mumbo jumbo pick swaps etc.

Having said that, I think NWM will recommit to St Kilda for two years.

One first won’t be enough though

 

[OneGreatClub]

We aren't premiership contenders yet

True. You’ve had a very easy draw.

 

[ABAB]

True. You’ve had a very easy draw.

Double up games against Collingwood (top team), Hawks (potential top 4) and GCS (look top 4 at one stage).

 

[projectv]

Nice work Port, would have really liked him to somehow get to the Saints.

 

[OneGreatClub]

Double up games against Collingwood (top team), Hawks (potential top 4) and GCS (look top 4 at one stage).

Those WC NM double ups must have been devastating, hey.
Anyway, remind Tex not to try the Stance if you make the GF

 

[Yoda_]

Thank you Port, saving him from ourselves (Essendon)

A nice player but probably not too different from a few players on our list already


Good luck and hope he gets a rich reward when this deal expires

 

[Cosmicwinduptoy24]

Your use of etc is interesting as there is only one more including JHF with gap everywhere in your defense and forward.

Name a side that doesn't have gaps if you only count the younger players on their list? You'd actually struggle to find many that have talent to the level of the players I just mentioned. You've got NFI.

 

[drcollossimo]

Double up games against Collingwood (top team), Hawks (potential top 4) and GCS (look top 4 at one stage).

Now tell us about your double ups against West Coast and North like come on man just piss off out of this thread pls

 

[manureid]

People still in here arguing with this tool ABAB. I reckon Scott hodges banged his mum or something, thats how hung up on Port he is.

 

[sexyhunk]

Great whispering

from voices in his head.

 

[largebus]

Special credit to the bloke who convinced him to stay, Lord Kenneth Hinkley of The Angle Park Greyhound Track.

We'll see if Josh Carr

Josh Carr

Age

45

Ht

179cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

17.8

4star

K

10.6

4star

HB

7.2

4star

M

4.0

4star

T

3.3

5star

CL

2.0

4star

No current season stats available

D

12.2

3star

K

7.2

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.6

3star

T

0.8

3star

has the same Midas Touch for Butters (assuming they don't trade him)

 

[SC_Power]

Special credit to the bloke who convinced him to stay, Lord Kenneth Hinkley of The Angle Park Greyhound Track.

We'll see if Josh Carr has the same Midas Touch for Butters (assuming they don't trade him)

If Ken is leaving, why would Bergman sign for him? (ps I know you are kidding)

He’s signed on for Carr. It’s a big affirmation for the change in coach (but only the first, need a few more like Butters to do so to convince the world)

 

[Chip Scab1]

I have watched enough to know that Bergman is not in the same category as Rankine. Is that controversial to you?

I would take Rankine over Butters, not even close whether you'd take him over Bergman! Anyone with half a brain would.

 

[Papa G]

I would take Rankine over Butters, not even close whether you'd take him over Bergman! Anyone with half a brain would.

Hey some everybodies preferences are different, that's why there are some many cateories of prawn, and Rankine is a fine footballer, but he'd want to have an absolutely exceptional second half to his career to be even in the same conversation as Zak Butters. Butters has already been in the AA twice, tracking for a 3rd this year, won AFLCA's player of the Year and 2 club Bnfs. Izak's greatest accolade so far is making the Indigenous All Stars team last year. Same draft year.

 

[scooter600x]

I would take Rankine over Butters, not even close whether you'd take him over Bergman! Anyone with half a brain would.

You weren't the same guy who traded next years pick 3 for this years pick 27, were you?

 

[Chip Scab1]

You weren't the same guy who traded next years pick 3 for this years pick 27, were you?

Come on mate... as shit as we've been/still are, I'll go to my grave seeing as least double the Flags you have.

Hey some everybodies preferences are different, that's why there are some many cateories of prawn, and Rankine is a fine footballer, but he'd want to have an absolutely exceptional second half to his career to be even in the same conversation as Zak Butters. Butters has already been in the AA twice, tracking for a 3rd this year, won AFLCA's player of the Year and 2 club Bnfs. Izak's greatest accolade so far is making the Indigenous All Stars team last year. Same draft year.

Very true. Except by trading for him now you aren't exactly concerned about what he's done, it's more what he is likely to do... surely.

Butters will have to be outstanding to be of more value than Rankine from here on.

There's clearly not a lot in it but I'm taking Mr Izak for Norf.

 

[ABAB]

Hey some everybodies preferences are different, that's why there are some many cateories of prawn, and Rankine is a fine footballer, but he'd want to have an absolutely exceptional second half to his career to be even in the same conversation as Zak Butters. Butters has already been in the AA twice, tracking for a 3rd this year, won AFLCA's player of the Year and 2 club Bnfs. Izak's greatest accolade so far is making the Indigenous All Stars team last year. Same draft year.

Rankine would have easily made AA last year had he played enough game, a bit down compared to last year and he has someone called Dawson in the side whereas Butters doesn't.

 

[Papa G]

People still in here arguing with this tool ABAB. I reckon Scott hodges banged his mum or something, thats how hung up on Port he is.

Yeah just saw his deluded reply to my reasoned post, may have been more than Scott Hodges, all at the same time.