Remove this Banner Ad

Mitch Robinson Report

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Posts
2,415
Reaction score
4
Location
History above all others
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Melbourne Tigers
Tim Watson said at 3qtr time on the TV Robbo was reported for a hit on Selwood near the interchange gates.

On the radio (MMM) they said that Selwood was reported for hitting Russell near the interchage gate.

Obviosuly someone is right and someone is weong.

Did anybody see it??
 
On Fanfooty it says that Robbo was reported for rough play and Selwood was reported for striking.

Whether of not they are same thing or mistake has occured I'm not sure.
 
Both reported. Mitch was coming off, Selwood followed him to the interchange but did not come off, Mitch bumped Selwood well off the ball and reported for rough play, Selwood retaliated against Russell who ran on to replace Mitch with a round arm punch to the belly. Did not see any of this, just relaying what the papers say happened.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I would say that if Mitch gets rubbed out then Selwood should as well along with Kerr.
 
Quite a few of the match day reports from this season have been thrown out, so hopefully this one will as well. Personally, i'd be more worried if I was Daniel Kerr, with his hit on Marc Murphy prior to the 1st bounce. With his previous record, I suspect he might be sitting out a couple of weeks.
 
The Kerr one was pretty low actually, Murphy wasn't even ready and was looking away from Kerr. I am all for having a go and standing up on the footy field, but that was just pathetic.
 
On Fanfooty it says that Robbo was reported for rough play and Selwood was reported for striking.

Whether of not they are same thing or mistake has occured I'm not sure.

Another one of these mythical other footy sites, MoMan? Fair dinkum... :rolleyes:


 
How in the world did the umpire just look away after the hit on Murph? He isnt exactly the kind of player who milks a lot of frees...and regardless he was lying on the ground...but the umpire just allows the Weagles to take their free kick before the bounce.

At least the Blues showed them that for all their tough boy actions...3 goals to nothing early in the 1st Q shows who is really the tough guy!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I didn't see the robinson/selwood incident, but heard a lot of noise so i looked over and saw selwood run back a bit and russell coming on and selwood gave russell a very hard knock, and elbow to the stomach which russell didnt see coming.
was on his way off anyway and had a little spell to calm down , and what a supporter near me said
ohh look they've taken off little scott selwood to calm his older brother down.... oooooo
random comment..
i think he should get a week for it,
i didnt see the robinson incident,
and i think kerr should get a week for what he did, i didnt see it live, as i was just finding my seat, but saw it on a replay and i thought it was totally uncalled for.
 
Tip for you, Robbo me boy. Get the ball. Kick the ball. Simple game, quit trying to complicate things. Love your flair and passion and toughness but it don't make you Superman. Get some runs on the board before all the fancy stuff.
 
How in the world did the umpire just look away after the hit on Murph? He isnt exactly the kind of player who milks a lot of frees...and regardless he was lying on the ground...but the umpire just allows the Weagles to take their free kick before the bounce.

At least the Blues showed them that for all their tough boy actions...3 goals to nothing early in the 1st Q shows who is really the tough guy!
The umpire was not looking when Murphy was hit. Take a look at the footage: he is looking to the left away from Murphy and then once Marc gets hit he turns his head and sees him on the ground in pain.

It was a free kick but only if he saw it which he clearly didn't.
 
Yeh someone told me to google it. I felt like a priest at an orgy being on that site.

That's exactly what they say about Big Footy over at Talking Carlton. ;)
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom