Mock draft

[DCFCFAN84]

Edited on 30/06/2016

1. Essendon - Hugh McCluggage
2. Brisbane - Will Brodie
3. Fremantle - Sam Petrevski-Seton
4. GWS (Gold Coast bid) - Harrison MacReadie
5. Gold Coast - Ben Ainsworth
6. Gold Coast (Carlton Bid) - Jack Bowes
7. Carlton - Andrew McGrath
8. St Kilda - Josh Rotham
9. Richmond - Todd Marshall
10. GWS (Port Adelaide Bid) - Will Setterfield
11. Port Adelaide - Josh Battle
12. Brisbane (Adelaide Bid) - Jacob Allison
13. Adelaide - Jonty Scharenberg
14. West Coast Eagles - Tim English
15. GWS (Bulldogs Bid) - Harrison Perryman
16. Western Bulldogs - Jarrod Berry
17. North Melbourne - Sam Powell-Pepper
18. Gold Coast (Sydney Bid) - Brad Scheer
19. Sydney - Daniel Venables
20. Hawthorn - Brandon Parfitt

 

[doings]

Probably most agreeable mock I have seen, would have same top 10 maybe not Rotham
Interesting too see many of the academy kids going later than I would suspect.
Also you don't rate Todd Marshall in your top 20, MickAblett/Sando have him at 6 and 4

 

[HedgeFund]

Probably most agreeable mock I have seen, would have same top 10 maybe not Rotham
Interesting too see many of the academy kids going later than I would suspect.
Also you don't rate Todd Marshall in your top 20, MickAblett/Sando have him at 6 and 4

Sando also said he didn't know much about VM's MVP Andrew McGrath prior to the championships. I nearly fell of the couch in astonishment.

What's the bloke's job FFS?

Astonishing.

 

[marty36]

1. Essendon - Hugh McCluggage
2. Brisbane - Will Brodie
3. Fremantle - Sam Pretreski-Seton
4. GWS (Gold Coast bid) - Harrison MacReadie
5. Gold Coast - Ben Ainsworth
6. Gold Coast (Carlton Bid) - Jack Bowes
7. Carlton - Andrew McGrath
8. St Kilda - Josh Rotham
9. Richmond - Josh Battle
10. GWS (Port Adelaide Bid) - Will Setterfield
11. Port Adelaide - Jarrod Berry
12. Brisbane (Adelaide Bid) - Jacob Allison
13. Adelaide - Jonty Scharenberg
14. West Coast Eagles - Tim English
15. GWS (Bulldogs Bid) - Harrison Perryman
16. Western Bulldogs - Daniel Venables
17. North Melbourne - Sam Powell-Pepper
18. Gold Coast (Sydney Bid) - Brad Scheer
19. Sydney - Luke Stranadika
20. Hawthorn - Brandon Parfitt

You don't think Jack Graham, who won best player of the championship taking the medal a top 20 pick

 

[adammania9]

I like it. Really similar to mine, however I doubt WCE go tall with their first pick. I excpect another youbg mid to come out of it. If SPP is still there, I expect them to pounce.

 

[blueiris]

Don't think we would look at Brodie unless Rockliff left don't see the reason to pick another slow midfielder can see the Lions looking at a SPS or Mcgrath type

 

[HBF]

Essendon will take Brodie IMO, but a good effort nonetheless.

 

[DCFCFAN84]

Probably most agreeable mock I have seen, would have same top 10 maybe not Rotham
Interesting too see many of the academy kids going later than I would suspect.
Also you don't rate Todd Marshall in your top 20, MickAblett/Sando have him at 6 and 4

Can't believe I left Todd Marshall out not sure how that happened as I had him in the top 10 before my final edit will have to modify my mock.

I like it. Really similar to mine, however I doubt WCE go tall with their first pick. I expect another young mid to come out of it. If SPP is still there, I expect them to pounce.

I considered SPP in that spot but like many I felt his kicking is a concern. Eagles ruck depth is pretty weak IMO they shouldn't have traded Callum Sinclair out last year. I don't really rate Lycett and Nic Nat has had some injury troubles as of late.

 

[avishka5]

Can't believe I left Todd Marshall out not sure how that happened as I had him in the top 10 before my final edit will have to modify my mock.



I considered SPP in that spot but like many I felt his kicking is a concern. Eagles ruck depth is pretty weak IMO they shouldn't have traded Callum Sinclair out last year. I don't really rate Lycett and Nic Nat has had some injury troubles as of late.

Eagles number one need is a mid. English is a gun but his rucking it self is quite average
They wont overlook venables and spp if both cane around that pick. We will probs look at darcy cameron later tho.

 

[Sin City]

McGrath is interesting. If he can play at HBF straight away we could move Docherty to the midfield which we really need to do.

Essendon add to their already impressive future midfield group of Heppel, Merrett, Laverde, Zaharakis, Parish with McLuggage or Brodie. Setting themselves up well there.

There's a few home grown selections there, I wonder if West Coast really need anything more than a developing rookie ruck having Nic Nat and Lycett already and perhaps be after an inside mid or a sprinter instead. Same with Adelaide, not sure an inside mid is a huge need at the moment.

I reckon the Bulldogs would love a talented outside player like Berry to compliment their inside brigade, North would be happy to start developing the next generation of inside mids with SPP after picking up tall prospects the last few years and the Swans would be thrilled with Venables if it worked out the way you have them.

 

[blueiris]

Essendon will take Brodie IMO, but a good effort nonetheless.

Who do you think Lions take at 2?

 

[HBF]

Who do you think Lions take at 2?

Probably SPS.

 

[blueiris]

Probably SPS.

Yeah maybe I think we lack that outside class that's who I've been hoping for most of the season

 

[MrNextgen]

I think Todd Marshall deserves to be in the top 20 for sure, none the less, good attempt at a mock draft.

 

[MightyDons4]

I think Todd Marshall deserves to be in the top 20 for sure, none the less, good attempt at a mock draft.

9

 

[MrNextgen]

9

holy shit im blind :/

 

[freebloke]

I'd be surprised if Saints took Rotham. Saints need mids, mids and more mids. Venables / Taranto is who I like around Saints pick.

 

[Supersuns]

Probably SPS.

Would SPS be a flight risk?

 

[adammania9]

holy shit im blind :/

You weren't wrong. He edited it to include Marshall because he left him out.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Edited on 30/06/2016

1. Essendon - Hugh McCluggage
2. Brisbane - Will Brodie
3. Fremantle - Sam Petrevski-Seton
4. GWS (Gold Coast bid) - Harrison MacReadie
5. Gold Coast - Ben Ainsworth
6. Gold Coast (Carlton Bid) - Jack Bowes
7. Carlton - Andrew McGrath
8. St Kilda - Josh Rotham
9. Richmond - Todd Marshall
10. GWS (Port Adelaide Bid) - Will Setterfield
11. Port Adelaide - Josh Battle
12. Brisbane (Adelaide Bid) - Jacob Allison
13. Adelaide - Jonty Scharenberg
14. West Coast Eagles - Tim English
15. GWS (Bulldogs Bid) - Harrison Perryman
16. Western Bulldogs - Jarrod Berry
17. North Melbourne - Sam Powell-Pepper
18. Gold Coast (Sydney Bid) - Brad Scheer
19. Sydney - Daniel Venables
20. Hawthorn - Brandon Parfitt

Yeah....Hawks 4 in a row....Like it.

If Dylan Clarke is still around at 20, then we'd be mad not to take him....Player of the Champs for mine.

 

[HedgeFund]

I'd take Taranto at 20 over Parfitt every day of the week and twice on Sunday's.

 

[HBF]

Would SPS be a flight risk?

Maybe, but take him anyway. Can't worry about that. I think I heard he wouldn't have an issues going to the Lions.

 

[marty36]

I'd take Taranto at 20 over Parfitt every day of the week and twice on Sunday's.

But then I would take Jack Graham over Taranto, with justification on his results

 

[Bicks]

But then I would take Jack Graham over Taranto, with justification on his results

And you'd be wrong IMO, Taranto offers so much more to his game than Graham, just for starters the comparison of their foot skills is chalk and cheese.

 

[marty36]

And you'd be wrong IMO, Taranto offers so much more to his game than Graham, just for starters the comparison of their foot skills is chalk and cheese.

You do realise Graham now has the runs on the board with player of the championship, would have to give him some credit and count for something as the best player of the under 18 championship