Mod. Notice Moderation of the WCE Board - Request for Feedback

[FKASC]

Bit of feedback, particularly when crunch time comes, nearing the trade period or draft.

The contract thread got hijacked by the baker trade so much that all else was lost in the wash.

The same happened with dev and Curtin the year before.

When it's obvious a particular topic is that HOT regarding disagreements and debate, could we start a specific thread for the debate.

Thanks

PS..."Harley's worth" will need to be a thread if he hasn't signed by the end of this year.

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yeah would be good if somehow a thread on a single topic could be split into two parallel columns - one outlining news and updates, and another for opinions and melts.

 

[Biggie]

Very keen to continue to have zero ‘No Oppo Supporter’ tags on this forum please

While we’re in charge this will always be something we stick with. Football is an inclusive world, and we welcome all opinions and input.

Life’s too short.

Cheers

 

[Bender_]

Yeah would be good if somehow a thread on a single topic could be split into two parallel columns - one outlining news and updates, and another for opinions and melts.

Can we get a 3rd column for puns and tired unfunny jokes?

 

[larrikin]

Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond to this thread and give your thoughts on how this board is moderated.

Whilst not the intention when starting the thread, it was pleasing to read so many positive posts.

There were a number of constructive suggestions on how things might be improved and they will be taken into consideration.

For example, we will look to act quicker in shutting down circular arguments between 2 or more posters that derail threads and also be mindful that whilst off topic (shit) posting can be funny in small doses and part of the fabric of this board, it can become tedious of over indulged.

So there will be some cosmetic changes that streamline threads somewhat without going overboard

That’s the superficial stuff out of the way

The most contentious issue, and the catalyst for this thread existing, was the treatment of outside posters, specifically briztoon who has polarised this board. Whilst most posters seem happy to accommodate outside views to a point, some thought we’d given him too much latitude.

That sentiment had led to a small group of posters, spearheaded by AsterixTheGaul , deciding to share their posts privately unless, and until, briztoon was banned, if not from the board completely, at least from the contracts thread

It is my, and the other mods, view that whilst not always agreeing with his posts, briztoon had not broken any rules. At least not to the extent that would justify a ban from the board or a specific thread. Clearly, that is not a universally shared view

The ultimatum issued privately by Asterix, put me in a Catch 22 position. I could either ban someone I felt hadn’t broken any rules and overlook one of my core principles to be accepting of outside views provided they weren’t trolling or have a group of our better and most informed posters withdraw themselves from open discussion

Hence this thread

Taking on board the views expressed and without wanting to get into an argument about whether or not briztoon is or isn’t a troll, I believe the following compromise, whilst not perfect, provides a workable solution

Two new threads will be started-
1) Draftees - for discussion on this years draft crop, including NGAs and Father/Sons, and who we may or may not be interested in, where they might go in the draft etc
2) List management- what holes do we have in the list, either existing or upcoming, and who should we target to fill those holes. This will likely also include discussion on who needs to be moved on from our list

It is intended that these threads will be moderated more tightly to ensure posts are on topic and aren’t derailed. Whilst they won’t be given a “No Opposition Supporters” tag, Briztoon specifically won’t post in them and any outside posters will be given a shorter leash

The existing Contracts thread will remain open as is for more robust discussion and for posts that cover multiple draft/trade/contract views. It will also serve as a catch all for posts in the separate threads that drift off topic but still offer something worthwhile. Briztoon will be allowed to post in that thread but he has agreed privately to pull back on posting on non-eagles issues which have been at the core of the angst towards his posting. Other visitors will be held to a similar standard

There is likely to be a teething period as we get used to the split of the threads and some adjustments might need to be made along the way so please be patient

Apologies for the long post and I trust the above satisfies the concerns raised - there has been considerable thought put into this over a number of weeks after I was put in the most awkward position I’ve been in as a moderator of this forum

Thanks Keys

There's no pleasing everyone with this stuff.

I echo Keys comments in asking for patience and for posters to at least try to post in the spirit on the splits of these threads. We'll keep monitoring and if it doesn't work we'll try something different.

 

[Bender_]

It's just a footy forum. A lot of us spend a heap of time on here catching up on footy news, sharing opinions or just plain talking shit (yes I realise that last one applies mainly to me), despite how much we frequent this site it's not serious business.

However, I (and most others) appreciate the unpaid job the moderators do in keeping this board in shape for us plebs, and for mine you guys being put in this position where you have one opposition poster who's a bit annoying but not really breaking any rules and having to accommodate regulars of the board who are choosing to not use the ignore function is a bit shit.

It's a trivial situation, but still shit.

 

[shoutsatclouds]

Can we get a 3rd column for puns and tired unfunny jokes?

I had this suggestion in my top 5

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

It's just a footy forum. A lot of us spend a heap of time on here catching up on footy news, sharing opinions or just plain talking shit (yes I realise that last one applies mainly to me), despite how much we frequent this site it's not serious business.

However, I (and most others) appreciate the unpaid job the moderators do in keeping this board in shape for us plebs, and for mine you guys being put in this position where you have one opposition poster who's a bit annoying but not really breaking any rules and having to accommodate regulars of the board who are choosing to not use the ignore function is a bit shit.

It's a trivial situation, but still shit.

Pretty much my thoughts too.

Weird arse situation but gg to the mods for dealing with it without banning someone who hasn't really broken the rules. We always point and laugh at the opposition boards with their no opposition fans signs. Long may it continue without the stench of hypocrisy.

 

[TY24]

Can we get a 3rd column for puns and tired unfunny jokes?

Better yet, make it a seperate board and you can moderate it

(Love you bro)

 

[TY24]

Keys, Biggie , larrikin, Thankyou all for your efforts, I’m sure it’s a very thankless task but you guys make this board what it is; the best on the site.

I’d thank HoneyBadger35 too, but I hate gingers.

 

[Mr Eagle]

Keys, Biggie , larrikin, Thankyou all for your efforts, I’m sure it’s a very thankless task but you guys make this board what it is; the best on the site.

Stop thanking them, they'll get soft and complacent!!!

 

[Matera92]

Soooo...is that a maybe on the Wheel of Banhammer for DS?

 

[HoneyBadger35]

However, I (and most others) appreciate the unpaid job the moderators do in keeping this board in shape for us plebs, and for mine you guys being put in this position where you have one opposition poster who's a bit annoying but not really breaking any rules and having to accommodate regulars of the board who are choosing to not use the ignore function is a bit shit.

It's a trivial situation, but still shit.

Uh…yeah. What he said.

 

[Schtinker]

Can we get a 3rd column for puns and tired unfunny jokes?

We can name it Benders Column

 

[bombard]

We can name it Benders Column

Gee.

 

[Bender_]

Gee.

100% hard pure rock.

 

[EdCurnowRules]

There are some argumentative campaigners on here who could be squeezed earlier, but I like following along the conversation without too many rules. That’s what the ignore button is for anyway…

Oppo supporters welcome always, especially the good ones. Shitheads are chased away and not only by mods.

Keep it up!!

 

[Doashuey]

Soooo...is that a maybe on the Wheel of Banhammer for DS?

https://pickerwheel.com/
Approved.
I also gave it a test run and it seems to work perfectly. First spin-

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

Dear Mr. Keys

There are too many threads these days.

Please eliminate three.

I am not a crackpot.

 

[ioppolo]

I'm bumping this but if I've missed an answer already or if I'm out of line then call me out, however I have this point to raise;

Harder moderation on opposition supporters on our board, even if it's just for this season. It's not just the Hawks followers either. Threads are turning to shit as outside supporters know they can get away with a far longer leash here. Threads are a travesty to read through. I can't be the only one feeling like this right now?

 

[Godfather32]

I'm bumping this but if I've missed an answer already or if I'm out of line then call me out, however I have this point to raise;

Harder moderation on opposition supporters on our board, even if it's just for this season. It's not just the Hawks followers either. Threads are turning to shit as outside supporters know they can get away with a far longer leash here. Threads are a travesty to read through. I can't be the only one feeling like this right now?

Meh, no more a travesty than the club right now. Seems appropriate

 

[Biggie]

Yeah it’s been a hard read. Threads are getting quite messy, we are cleaning up the Hawks thread but the other ones believe quite a convoluted mess when replies are made

We hear you guys, and will try and keep it cleaner

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

The only opposition supporter that adds value is the Essendon bloke who posts draftee videos.

But if "adds value" is the criteria then most of the posts by our supporters will be deleted too

 

[darksquare]

The recent arrivals have made me realise how much I appreciate briztoon

 

[Yeahnahmate]

The recent arrivals have made me realise how much I appreciate briztoon

You take that back right now!

 

[Bender_]

Meh, no more a travesty than the club right now. Seems appropriate

We wouldn't give a shit if we weren't frustrated with the club ourselves. Loser oppo supporters coming to piss on our wounds.