Mooney and Ling - Reported.

[cats2rise]

Cannot remember the Ling incident exactly, but I think Mooney may be in trouble. It wasnt much, but the way the tribunal system is going at the moment, he might get a week.

 

[ablettjnr]

Mooney is as dumb as dog **** sometimes.

 

[thejester]

If Kerr could argue himself down to one so can Moons. I didn't see the Ling one - was it him lifting the arm on Lade?

 

[Buddha72]

Cats2rise, do you think Mooney will go?

 

[cats2rise]

He will probably get one week because of his 'past behaviour'

 

[fugsy]

Scarlett may be in trouble too if they choose to look at his little rib tickler that gave away the 50 to Tredrea a little more closely.

 

[TheTimeCometh]

and then he gives another one and gives away the free....

pathological restraint loser.

 

[catters05]

Bull**** if either go.

Actually which one have the pathetic AFL got mooney for, the little rib tickler or the punch on the post.

Will be pathetic if he goes.....

 

[Glassjaw]

There's a fair chance all three will be sitting the next week out.

 

[Ricardo]

Mooney will get a week, didn't see the others though..

 

[TheTimeCometh]

he is aware that there is at least ONE camera out there???????

 

[jim boy]

I don't know that Mooney will go, it wasn't high, it was of low force (great dive), it was in play, albeit late. 50 metre penalty definitely, not much else though.

Scarlett should be right, no force there

Apparently Ling is in a bit of trouble.

 

[CF]

this is why I am not a "Mooney for Captain" fan, he is great and I think highly of him. But he is prone to these undisciplined acts which a Captain shouldn't do.

 

[jess_555]

Gee Moons hardly did anything and if it was anyone else they would probably get off. With Mooneys bad record he will probably get a week. Remeber earlier in the season when he got suspended for doing like nothing!!! Grrrrr. His sort of injured anyways so yeah.

 

[JUBJUB]

Apparently Ling is in a bit of trouble.

What is the Ling report ?
Commetti made mention of it at the end of the game.

The player that will get a few weeks is Daryl 'Nightlight' Wakelin.He headbutted Bartel just before 1/2 time.There's clear vision of it.

 

[cats2rise]

His sort of injured anyways so yeah.

Jess, that shouldnt have anything to do with it. I would still rather a 75% fit Mooney in than no Mooney at all.

 

[Inferno]

I dont think any of them will be suspended due to the fact Port took more dives then the Italian soccer team.

 

[catempire]

Mooney:

Reckless conduct (two points), low impact (one point), in play (no points) and body contact (one points). Four activation points - level one offence drawing 75 demerit points.

How does his suspension from earlier in the year impact on this?

I think he has 4 matches suspended as a bad record which increases the penalty by 30% to 97.5 points. Then I think he has 21.88 residual points from the Holland headbutt which would take him to 119.38 activation points.

With a guilty plea, this would be reduced to 89.535 points and a reprimand.

Thoughts? Have I got these calculations right?

 

[Inferno]

Accually, if he aimed lower then it would be less

 

[Shell]

What is the Ling report ?
Commetti made mention of it at the end of the game.

The player that will get a few weeks is Daryl 'Nightlight' Wakelin.He headbutted Bartel just before 1/2 time.There's clear vision of it.

Yeah saw that one too. Maybe Wakes was getting inspiration from the World Cup there

IF Mooney goes for that ****, well... i wouldnt be surprised really.

 

[Shell]

Accually, if he aimed lower then it would be less

Hahahaha... its funny coz its true!

 

[thejester]

Let's face it, the way the tribunal is they could get anything - I'm still trying to get over how Kerr managed to get his charge downgraded to 'reckless' from 'intentional'...by admiting he had deliberately punched the player. It would take a special kind of stupid to buy that argument.

 

[Mr Magoo]

Well done today you guys outplayed us for a few minutes in the last quarter & we couldn't manage to get those goals back, so anyway good luck for the rest of the year
On topic yeah you really have to wonder what goes through Mooney's head sometimes as he does stupid things far too often. As for Ling i'm sure he was reported for striking but i can't remember which player he allegedly hit, possibly Burgoyne?

 

[geelong_boy]

Mooney:

Reckless conduct (two points), low impact (one point), in play (no points) and body contact (one points). Four activation points - level one offence drawing 75 demerit points.

How does his suspension from earlier in the year impact on this?

I think he has 4 matches suspended as a bad record which increases the penalty by 30% to 97.5 points. Then I think he has 21.88 residual points from the Holland headbutt which would take him to 119.38 activation points.

With a guilty plea, this would be reduced to 89.535 points and a reprimand.

Thoughts? Have I got these calculations right?

Does it still work like that when a players gets reported during the game? If he's found guilty at the tribunal isn't the penalty then handed down (ie. how things were done in the days before the Match Review Panel)?

 

[Ricardo]

On topic yeah you really have to wonder what goes through Mooney's head sometimes as he does stupid things far too often. As for Ling i'm sure he was reported for striking but i can't remember which player he allegedly hit, possibly Burgoyne?

Yeah, i thought he had gone past his brain lapse days........very annoying, i forgot that a report means an automatic 50m penalty.....didn't realise that was the rule.

Anyway, they showed a bit of the Ling incident on the news and if he gets anything for that the tribunal is surely a disgrace...should be thrown out.