Mooney or Harley

[Falconer02]

to fill the CHB role? personally I think mooney not because of talent but size and it gives the cats the ability to free up Harley and let him create and help out others. by the way hi everybody havent been on for a while.

 

[Tha Boss]

Harley, not because of his talent or anything, but because Mooney is absolutely pathetic and is lucky to still be on an AFL list. I mean Aaron James had size.........

 

[Seb]

Originally posted by Tha Boss
Harley, not because of his talent or anything, but because Mooney is absolutely pathetic and is lucky to still be on an AFL list. I mean Aaron James had size.........

Clueless.

In the modern era, CHB isn't really a position now. We have 6 defenders, roughly 2 - 3 of those players are tall and wrestle with the gorillas. Mooney, Harley and Scarlett will not be placed in a particular position, it will depend on their opponent each week.

 

[jim boy]

It's a bit of horses for courses. Every coach tries to nullify the effectiveness of the opposition by matching up against the likely opposition. Harley is a good intelligent defender who won't be outsmarted while mooney uses Brawn and an innate natural footy talent. Put these fellas on the wrong match ups and both would get slaughtered.

 

[JUBJUB]

Originally posted by Shaitan
Clueless.

In the modern era, CHB isn't really a position now. We have 6 defenders, roughly 2 - 3 of those players are tall and wrestle with the gorillas. Mooney, Harley and Scarlett will not be placed in a particular position, it will depend on their opponent each week.

Exactly.In the first WizFizz game Mooney was more of a back pocket,because Port had 2 talls around the goal square.In the GF he was more of a CHB.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Neither will be a permanent CHB, as Seb said, they will alternate in their roles, depending on who we are playing.

Gumby has his weaknesses, as does Tommy, hence the need to choose their roles on a game-by-game basis.