Most underated player

[goblues1976]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

 

[stevedarui]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

I would say Gibbsy is overrated by Carlton supporters and underrated by opposition supporters.

 

[Swanstar]

Mitch Clarke, Jarrad Brennan

 

[Kaan]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

Bias at its best.

 

[Duffman95]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

Surely this has to be a wind up?

 

[blues4flag]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

Should the thread title read "most underrated player from your club?"

 

[boulos]

Most lethal abuser of the English language: goblues1976

 

[wicksy]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

I think that for a 32 year old, you really are a FCKHEAD!!!

 

[Godfrey Jones]

bryan > cam cloke

 

[kingyubbo]

Probably Matthew Boyd from the Bulldogs. Have noticed that he never gets mentioned but plays a good tagging/run with role and gets a tonne of the footy.

Other than that, maybe Joel McDonald from Brisbane who has been pretty good this year but no one ever mentions him.

 

[McManus2Waterhouse]

daniel wells because every person on this site thinks hes overrated

 

[jiphoc]

daniel wells because every person on this site thinks hes overrated

I second this

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Gee, good to see original threads being created.

Was there something wrong with the "most under-rated player" thread that was created last week? Or the one that was created the week before that?

It's a ridiculous topic anyway. Whose rating of the player are you working with?

 

[fish_bowl]

i don't know if Scott Thompson is underrated. but every time i watch Craig Davids team he is in there best three. he is rated, but never in the same breath as a Kerr, or a Black... i also think Mitch Hahn is under rated, as is Jarred Mcveigh and Ryan Crowley

 

[BlueTube]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

Get your hand off it......excitement machine............shaun grigg has yet to prove himself.(although showing signs...4 quarters should e priority no. 1)...bentick was battling for a spot 5 rounds ago...but as we know 1 week is a long time in footy..jordan russel refused to put his noggin over the pill untill the second half of the prt game(must of received an almighty rocket......something changed... and clokeys ripper value best recruit in years..(value for $$ wise).

 

[SirJimi05]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

Yep, the 5 most underated players in the comp are all Carlton players.

Carlton is the most underated team going around and should actually win the flag this season. Only then will they get the recognition they so richly deserve.

 

[Bulldog Joe]

For me it would have to be definitely Shaun Grigg, Bryce Gibbs, Adam Bentick, or Jordan Russell with apologys to Cameron CLoke.

Who do you guys think???

I think that you should confine a comparison of Carlton players to the Carlton Board

 

[Accepted 04]

Richmond: Kelvin Moore and Chris Newman

The most underrated players in the COMP would have to be: Kane Cornes, Jarred McVeigh and Daniel Cross.

 

[halfback dasher]

RUSTYHAWK....... love his work and gives plenty,yet not mentioned much at all!

 

[carmi99]

Richmond: Kelvin Moore and Chris Newman

The most underrated players in the COMP would have to be: Kane Cornes, Jarred McVeigh and Daniel Cross.

Jarred McVeigh was a rubbish player until this season.

 

[Silvagnis]

Kade Simpson is underrated and a great get for pick 45.

Brad Fisher is overrated because of his marking and can't kick.

 

[Captain_Judd]

Bentick for us.

 

[dylan_mike]

Yep, Bentick. underate him at your own peril!

 

[Boogoos]

look at the carlton supporters talking up the trash players

 

[Willow_2000]

Joel McDonald, The guys a bloody gun.