Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. MSD Watch 2023 [NMFC select Robert Hansen Jnr with #2 in 2023 MSD]

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ryley Stoddart has started out the season well for Frankston and looks to have added some bulk to his frame. Can provide a bit of run and carry and is a beautiful left foot kick. We know Clarko loves the left footers.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I hope we stay the hell away from the MSD. Hosey, Edwards, Dawson, Ham - FFS


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I think if Dawson didn’t get a go with Logue and McKay out then he may aswell pack his bags now as he is not getting a greater opportunity to play.

As for Lowson, we have plenty of small/hybrid forwards who can kick goals like Stepho, Taylor, Curtis, Ford…

What we don’t have is a zippy small forward who can tackle, crumb and apply manic pressure like a Kozzie Pickett.

Spicer is done and is not showing enough by now. Cut our losses with him as he can’t even run down and stick a tackle in wet conditions that should favour him.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
I think if Dawson didn’t get a go with Logue and McKay out then he may aswell pack his bags now as he is not getting a greater opportunity to play.

As for Lowson, we have plenty of small/hybrid forwards who can kick goals like Stepho, Taylor, Curtis, Ford…

What we don’t have is a zippy small forward who can tackle, crumb and apply manic pressure like a Kozzie Pickett.

Spicer is done and is not showing enough by now. Cut our losses with him as he can’t even run down and stick a tackle in wet conditions that should favour him.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Correct about Spicer delist but with Goldstein probably done at the seasons end with doubts over Xerri and Coleman Jones to take 1st ruck could we look at Naismith from Port Melbourne he killed us in the VFL ex Sydney and has AFL experience probably the only concern is his knees .
 
is Clayton Oliver available?..
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Cheers mate, any notable performances you’ve come across so far this weekend from a msd perspective?

Shaun Mannagh had 24 disposals for Werribee in another BOG performance, but he kicked 0.5 from 7 shots on goal.

Jed Hagan was also impressive in the Port Adelaide Vs the AFL academy game. I thought he should’ve been drafted last year.

A new player who I’ve added to my interest list is Jack Buller from Claremont in the WAFL. 199cm & 99kg. Kicked 4.2 from 22 disposals and 14
Marks. He is only 21, but has had a few
Injury concerns in the past.

Sam Gilbey continued his comeback from a broken leg. Played WAFL reserves and had 20 disposals and 7 marks. Looked a class above especially with his kicking. Hoping he’ll get to play seniors soon.
 
Shaun Mannagh had 24 disposals for Werribee in another BOG performance, but he kicked 0.5 from 7 shots on goal.

Jed Hagan was also impressive in the Port Adelaide Vs the AFL academy game. I thought he should’ve been drafted last year.

A new player who I’ve added to my interest list is Jack Buller from Claremont in the WAFL. 199cm & 99kg. Kicked 4.2 from 22 disposals and 14
Marks. He is only 21, but has had a few
Injury concerns in the past.

Sam Gilbey continued his comeback from a broken leg. Played WAFL reserves and had 20 disposals and 7 marks. Looked a class above especially with his kicking. Hoping he’ll get to play seniors soon.

I’ve just had a read of Bullers stats, sounds interesting.
Any key position depth we can add would be a bonus.
 
I’ve just had a read of Bullers stats, sounds interesting.
Any key position depth we can add would be a bonus.

I know he was predominantly playing as a 2nd ruck last year, but seems to be playing more forward this year. I haven’t actually seen him play yet, but a mate of mine (who is a WA scout) said his game yesty was really solid.
 
At this early stage I think Shaun Mannagh would be my ideal pick in the MSD. Small forward who has natural goal sense and footy IQ but also has the ability to push up the ground to play in the midfield or a wing. Has solid running capacity. He is currently averaging 31.7 disposals, 4.5 goals, 5 marks and 7 tackles per game.

Ryley Stoddart would probably be next. 186cm Left footed half back/wing who is playing for Frankston. Spent time on Sydney's list. Fantastic athlete, he is currently averaging 27.3 disposals, 6.3 marks and 2 tackles per game. Looks to have matured physically over the past few years which is why his game is improving so much. Still only 23 years of age.
 
I think Ryan Maric will be a hot commodity, going at about 15 touches and a couple goals a game in the Coates league as a 193cm forward type.

A couple of the overage rucks in Clay Tucker and Flynn Riley might also attract interest at 204cm and 206cm respectively and being 2 of the better performing Coates league rucks.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I think Ryan Maric will be a hot commodity, going at about 15 touches and a couple goals a game in the Coates league as a 193cm forward type.

A couple of the overage rucks in Clay Tucker and Flynn Riley might also attract interest at 204cm and 206cm respectively and being 2 of the better performing Coates league rucks.

Ryan Maric has some really good wheels and is quite athletic. Doesn’t really play like a genuine key forward. Kind of like a Mason Wood type who is agile and handy below his knees.

Clay Tucker will definitely be on the radar of many clubs. Heard he added about 6/7kg to his frame during the off season which is pretty impressive.
 
At this early stage I think Shaun Mannagh would be my ideal pick in the MSD. Small forward who has natural goal sense and footy IQ but also has the ability to push up the ground to play in the midfield or a wing. Has solid running capacity. He is currently averaging 31.7 disposals, 4.5 goals, 5 marks and 7 tackles per game.

Ryley Stoddart would probably be next. 186cm Left footed half back/wing who is playing for Frankston. Spent time on Sydney's list. Fantastic athlete, he is currently averaging 27.3 disposals, 6.3 marks and 2 tackles per game. Looks to have matured physically over the past few years which is why his game is improving so much. Still only 23 years of age.
Thoughts on Samuel Stubbs? Although freo might pick him up
 
Thoughts on Samuel Stubbs? Although freo might pick him up

Don’t know a great deal about him, done the pre-season with Freo but they chose to leave a list spot open instead of picking him up. Looking purely at stats from his first few WAFL games this year it isn’t anything overly impressive.
 
Don’t know a great deal about him, done the pre-season with Freo but they chose to leave a list spot open instead of picking him up. Looking purely at stats from his first few WAFL games this year it isn’t anything overly impressive.
Hmm yeah, I think it had something to do with his fitness, would be good if we needed a med forward that can hit the scoreboard but we really need that pressure forward that can tackle lol
 
If we are in the bottom 4 come MSD, I can't see how the club can simply pass up a MSD pick.

We aren't in the position to be overlooking free shots at the MSD.

We will have to engineer a list spot, which will be the most interesting viewing how we go about that.

A possibility would be Shiels retiring mid season imo....

Or even "deactivating" someone like Edwards somehow.

Whilst it's not a hotbed of superstars:

Newcombe, Ash Johnson, Durham, Moyle, Sharman, McEntee, Culley, D'Ambrosio, Blanck

Leek Aleer was also eligible for it.

Have all come out of it in only 2 years.
 
Last edited:
If we are in the bottom 4 come MSD, I can't see how the club can simply pass up a MSD pick.

We aren't in the position to be overlooking free shots at the MSD.

We will have to engineer a list spot, which will be the most interesting viewing how we go about that.

A possibility would be Shiels retiring mid season imo....

Or even "deactivating" someone like Edwards somehow.

Whilst it's not a hotbed of superstars:

Newcombe, Ash Johnson, Durham, Moyle, Sharman, McEntee, Culley, D'Ambrosio, Blanck

Have all come out of it in only 2 years.
73A174CC-15CC-4011-8EE1-0A3E30BFCAA9.jpeg
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. MSD Watch 2023 [NMFC select Robert Hansen Jnr with #2 in 2023 MSD]

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top