jefffff34
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 20, 2001
- 17,832
- 4,290
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
9. Burns
9. Swan
8. Lockyer
7. Thomas
7. R.Shaw
9. Swan
8. Lockyer
7. Thomas
7. R.Shaw
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
MVP Votes round 3
- Thread starter jefffff34
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Jul 18, 2004
- 2,781
- 1
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood
What? No Rocca or Meds?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Banned
- #5
Pretty spot on I think
Thomas and Pendles both looked really, really good. So much poise, it's unbelievable
And gez I hope Lockyer plays like this all year
my votes go to mick malthouse.. did a great job of getting the boys up.. did well bringing three younjg guns in.
9- Lockyer- Superb all night
8- Swan- Another top performance
8- Thomas- Showing there are no 2nd year blues
7- Burns- Worked hard all night, alot of it went unnoticed
7- Rocca- Although I agree he was useless early, he won us the game
8- Swan- Another top performance
8- Thomas- Showing there are no 2nd year blues
7- Burns- Worked hard all night, alot of it went unnoticed
7- Rocca- Although I agree he was useless early, he won us the game
My votes -
8 - Burns
8 - Lockyer
7 - Thomas
7 - Swan
6 - Rocca
Special Mention to the rookies - Toovey (3 goals, excellent debut), D1ck (alot of upside, looks as though he has that something special) and Coxy (good, solid debut, did his job down back allnight).
R Shaw just missed a vote, was very good of half back
Fraser excellent last quarter. Good come back from a ordinary 3 quarters.
Medhurst 4 goals, lead and presented well in the second half.
O'Brien continues to get better every game he plays.
8 - Burns
8 - Lockyer
7 - Thomas
7 - Swan
6 - Rocca
Special Mention to the rookies - Toovey (3 goals, excellent debut), D1ck (alot of upside, looks as though he has that something special) and Coxy (good, solid debut, did his job down back allnight).
R Shaw just missed a vote, was very good of half back
Fraser excellent last quarter. Good come back from a ordinary 3 quarters.
Medhurst 4 goals, lead and presented well in the second half.
O'Brien continues to get better every game he plays.
- Oct 8, 2004
- 13,088
- 5,909
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
9. Swan
8. Burns
8. Lockyer
7. Rocca
7. Thomas
8. Burns
8. Lockyer
7. Rocca
7. Thomas
9 Burns
8 Lockyer
8 Swan
7 Rhyce Shaw
7 Thomas
8 Lockyer
8 Swan
7 Rhyce Shaw
7 Thomas
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
9. Lockyer
8. Burns
8. Thomas
7. Rocca
7. Swan
I know the votes I've given are pretty high, but I still don't think it was necessarily indicative of a great game by the team.
8. Burns
8. Thomas
7. Rocca
7. Swan
I know the votes I've given are pretty high, but I still don't think it was necessarily indicative of a great game by the team.
- Oct 8, 2004
- 13,088
- 5,909
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
Swan gets 6 votes for 35 possessions, 11 marks, 4 tackles and a goal...
You've got a heart of steel jabso...
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
I'm changing it to 7. I gave him 6 because in the first half even though he got a lot of it, he didn't do much with it. However I gave Rocca 7 despite his even poorer first half.
Very hard
9 - Tarkyn Lockyer
8 - Scott Burns
8 - Dale Thomas
7 - Dane Swan
6 - Rhyce Shaw
Unlucky - Pebbles, Toovs and Cheesy
9 - Tarkyn Lockyer
8 - Scott Burns
8 - Dale Thomas
7 - Dane Swan
6 - Rhyce Shaw
Unlucky - Pebbles, Toovs and Cheesy
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
I am quite amazed at how Lockyer is playing despite it being early days. His weaknesses were always:
- Despite his nice skills he took the wrong option a lot of the time and made alot of mistakes
- he was slow
- crap one on one
- not intense enough
- doesn't get enough of the hard ball, yet not damaging enough to be an outside mid.
I think he has improved on every single one of those points.
- Despite his nice skills he took the wrong option a lot of the time and made alot of mistakes
- he was slow
- crap one on one
- not intense enough
- doesn't get enough of the hard ball, yet not damaging enough to be an outside mid.
I think he has improved on every single one of those points.
Yes, his form has had me scratching my head this year. It makes you wonder what the catalyst for this improvement has been.
9 - Rocca
8 - Swan
8 - Lockyer
7 - Obree
7 - Burns
Just missed out Thomas, Pendles, Presti, Fraser, Shaw
8 - Swan
8 - Lockyer
7 - Obree
7 - Burns
Just missed out Thomas, Pendles, Presti, Fraser, Shaw
Tarkyn Lockyer easily one of the most improved players at the club, let alone the league.
Even better, he is playing in the midfield, where he was a success before he did his knee in 2003. Great to see...we all knew Tarks would be a great player in 2007 four years ago.
Personally I don't think he has improved that much, I mean, seriously, he was All-Australian material at the half-way mark in 2006 (no joke) but was exposed in the second half as a defender.
Even better, he is playing in the midfield, where he was a success before he did his knee in 2003. Great to see...we all knew Tarks would be a great player in 2007 four years ago.
Personally I don't think he has improved that much, I mean, seriously, he was All-Australian material at the half-way mark in 2006 (no joke) but was exposed in the second half as a defender.
Not even close IMO.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
At a guess, an injury free run and some games under his belt. A lot more confidence in his knee?
Jabso
Brownlow Medallist
Round 3 Totals
D.Swan 42
T.Lockyer 42
S. Burns 40
D. Thomas 37
A. Rocca 28
R. Shaw 7
A really high voting round with only 6 different players getting votes. The 5 voters couldn't split Lockyer and Swan's game. Burns and Thomas weren't far off the mark while Rocca despite being named BOG by the Herald Sun was only rated the 5th best on ground, probably due to his poor first half.
D.Swan 42
T.Lockyer 42
S. Burns 40
D. Thomas 37
A. Rocca 28
R. Shaw 7
A really high voting round with only 6 different players getting votes. The 5 voters couldn't split Lockyer and Swan's game. Burns and Thomas weren't far off the mark while Rocca despite being named BOG by the Herald Sun was only rated the 5th best on ground, probably due to his poor first half.
