NAB Challenge Discussion

[TheOz]

Menzel sighted yet? Plenty of talent but always looked like he was limping. Not the most durable family.

Hasn't played yet this pre-season for them, always seems to be carrying something and when he was ok his workrate was crap.

 

[TheOz]

Kept Fyfe relatively quiet.

13 disposals at 1/2 time and 7 contested possessions, probably still hit the half ton at the half.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Would rather Brad over Matt

Brad is the better AFL player I reckon but doesn't always translate into SC scores I guess. And being in a lil' bit of trouble is scaring people off Brad I imagine. On the plus side for Brad pickers he is cheaper and as I said, a better player.

Really think you'll get 100+ from all 3 of Crouch, Crouch and Libba though.

 

[manboob]

Any scores?

 

[TheOz]

23 disposals, 13 contested possessions, 2.1, 90 DT for Dangerfield at half time. That's almost Cripps like numbers for a half of footy.

 

[Chism]

Libba is currently owned by 55.44%

Wait for the lols with people panic trading after a nothing game

Better than starting with him and putting up with 50-70 scores a rookie could be getting then burning a trade to move him on. Libba is not going to make much cash averaging around that mark when he is priced at 357k which is awkward.

He could prove me wrong but i would rather take the chance on a kid now or swap him for a premo if you can as i reckon Libba may take a while to come back to full strength after that knee reco and he was never quick to begin with and looks 2 yards slower already.

Practice game or not Libba was out there and having a go but could not get near the pill at all. I am risking not starting with him and if slaps 100pt scores in my face so be it!

 

[Flandersss]

Kept Fyfe relatively quiet.

Not listening.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Darcy Moore is already better than Cloke

Darcy sounds gay, not that there's.....yeah you know the rest.
Serious question marks over the lad at pies HQ is there?
Gaydar going right owf.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Was I hearing things, or did Spud Frawley call Nakia "Cockatoo-Collins" during the first half?

 

[Metapod]

Great. Last week was operation get Fyfe in.
This week is operation get Danger in.
Now rocking Fyfe, Dangerfield, Pendles, Gaz and Rockliff in mid - at least I know they're keepers

 

[Flandersss]

Was I hearing things, or did Spud Frawley call Nakia "Cockatoo-Collins" during the first half?

Correct.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Was I hearing things, or did Spud Frawley call Nakia "Cockatoo-Collins" during the first half?

Lol

 

[TheOz]

Was I hearing things, or did Spud Frawley call Nakia "Cockatoo-Collins" during the first half?

Did it the last game they played too.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Honestly stuff starting a 120k rookie when you can pay an extra 180k for Brad Crouch. There are a lot more points to go around with Dangerfield gone as well, think I'll go with both Crouch brothers. The extra cash is nice to start

 

[joop]

may change, but that game didnt give me the biggest confidence in Libba with a stacked Dogs midfield

Did Libba score over 100 one week ago?

 

[TheOz]

Honestly stuff starting a 120k rookie when you can pay an extra 180k for Brad Crouch. There are a lot more points to go around with Dangerfield gone as well, think I'll go with both Crouch brothers. The extra cash is nice to start

$180k is not a trivial amount, it's the difference between being able to get a Goldstein vs a Callum Sinclair.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Did Libba score over 100 one week ago?

true

 

[Me Myself and I]

BULLDOGS

Lachie Hunter 124

Matthew Boyd 117

Jason Johannisen 113

Mitch Wallis 104

Jack Macrae 90

Matthew Suckling 90

Caleb Daniel 88

Luke Dahlhaus 82

Tom Boyd 82

Koby Stevens 82

Robert Murphy 78

Marcus Bontempelli 77

Liam Picken 74

Jake Stringer 72

Marcus Adams 72

Shane Biggs 70

Toby McLean 49

Dale Morris 46

Jack Redpath 45

Easton Wood 44

Tom Liberatore 41

Lin Jong 38

Tom Campbell 28

Kieran Collins 0

MAGPIES

Adam Treloar 110

Tom Langdon 101

Dane Swan 90

Taylor Adams 89

Jordan de Goey 88

Jarrod Witts 87

Steele Sidebottom 84

Jackson Ramsay 83

Jack Crisp 79

Darcy Moore 78

Alex Fasolo 76

Travis Varcoe 71

Jarryd Blair 68

Scott Pendlebury 68

Ben Sinclair 68

Corey Gault 63

Travis Cloke 56

Nathan J. Brown 50

Jonathon Marsh 41

Jack Frost 37

Brent Macaffer 36

Brayden Maynard 34

Marley Williams 26

James Aish 10

 

[joop]

Better than starting with him and putting up with 50-70 scores a rookie could be getting then burning a trade to move him on. Libba is not going to make much cash averaging around that mark when he is priced at 357k which is awkward.

He could prove me wrong but i would rather take the chance on a kid now or swap him for a premo if you can as i reckon Libba may take a while to come back to full strength after that knee reco and he was never quick to begin with and looks 2 yards slower already.

Practice game or not Libba was out there and having a go but could not get near the pill at all. I am risking not starting with him and if slaps 100pt scores in my face so be it!

If he starts with those scores downgrade him before round 3.
More chance Libba scoring high than a kid.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Doggies midfield bat deep libba he is no longer there main man in the middle.
He won't get tagged near as much as he used too.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

$180k is not a trivial amount, it's the difference between being able to get a Goldstein vs a Callum Sinclair.

700-410= 290

 

[TheOz]

700-410= 290

I picked Callum Sinclair as an example without knowing his price, lets go Stef Martin instead of Goldy then, the point still stands. Also look at Adelaide's early season draw and the fact that both of them haven't played together yet in their current midfield setup.

 

[Keg on legs]

Did Libba score over 100 one week ago?

No. Not true. He has never scored 100+ in his career. I for one can't believe he is worth 350k!

 

[Feerits Elf]

Having a look at the Dogs game

Lol @ Johannisen, Odell Beckham come on down

 

[rocker_oz33]

I don't like the new FF it only shows for the amount of touches under the Po column.
It used to have kicks,hand passes,tackles hit outs columns so much better.