Lewis may have been tantalising but he had a superb season in 1997 when he was neck and neck with Cressa for the places in the B&F count (behind Kelly as the clear stand out). I think he just missed out and finished 3rd.
Davis hasn't really threatened a top 10 finish in the B&F in his 5 years at the Swans.
Also, soon after Lewis came of age and produced that one great season, he suffered 3 consecutive years of horrendous luck on the injury front, including twice fracturing his forearm on the eve of the season. I reckon we were robbed of his best years by those injuries.
Davis is a wonderfully gifted player but for someone who reckons he could have won a Brownlow or two, he is a woeful underachiever in the consistency stakes. I'd have him in my team, for sure, but he's delivered nothing like the talk that he's talked, notwithstanding one quarter that we'll always cherish him for.