Official 2020 Planning Thread

[Battlepants]

Surely Mills goes to the midfield next year.

I'm not falling for that one again.

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

Will definitely select Gawn /Grundy and then any rucks who have DPP.
I'll then watch as CD change their scoring for rucks and I'll be stuck with half a dozen big dopey kents pulling 70s.

 

[Nelso]

I will be locking Hayes in at R3 next year

This kid is going to be a star.

Matched it with Jacobs in the SANFL a few weeks ago in only his 4th game back from an ACL.

He will very quickly overtake Lycett as the number 1 ruck at Port.

 

[ubeaut]

Surely Mills goes to the midfield next year.

Ah the old "Mills will play midfield" chestnut eh?

 

[4tune8]

Ah the old "Mills will play midfield" chestnut eh?

I got sucked in this year, **** it until I see some solid numbers

 

[Obese Arachnid]

I will be locking Hayes in at R3 next year

This kid is going to be a star.

Matched it with Jacobs in the SANFL a few weeks ago in only his 4th game back from an ACL.

He will very quickly overtake Lycett as the number 1 ruck at Port.

Another Port ruck, Here2tellyouwhy is all....

A

 

[samFFC]

I will be locking Hayes in at R3 next year

This kid is going to be a star.

Matched it with Jacobs in the SANFL a few weeks ago in only his 4th game back from an ACL.

He will very quickly overtake Lycett as the number 1 ruck at Port.

Ruck rookies are gold!

Locks at this stage: Docherty, Titchell.
Probably get Brayshaw, Witherden again

 

[Benno_900]

rip in peace benno, when not providing screenshots finally got him.

I had to take one for the team.

Birchy could have at least left me as OP before suspending me.

 

[SavDog23]

No love for Mitchell

Titch is a lock, he'll only be around 550k. Was talking more about the high end priced premos from this year.

 

[SavDog23]

I am 1000% starting a RCK/FWD to go with my R3 loophole. Gawn set to miss a few games with no cover is f**ked.

 

[Benno_900]

I am 1000% starting a RCK/FWD to go with my R3 loophole. Gawn set to miss a few games with no cover is f**ked.

Source?

 

[SavDog23]

Source?

There's a few rumours flying around. I guess we'll know for sure tonight.

 

[stevebbb]

I am 1000% starting a RCK/FWD to go with my R3 loophole. Gawn set to miss a few games with no cover is f**ked.

Ryder at GWS as their number 1 ruckman, coming off a full preseason, priced at a ~82 average, with FWD/RUCK DPP
Locklocklock

 

[Andrew Birch]

I like your optimism but the stats don't really support it...
TOP 10 AVGING SC FWDS
2019
1) Marshall - plays ruck - 113.1
2) Danger - midfielder - 113.1
3) Boak - midfielder - 112.8
4) Dunkley - midfielder - 112.6
5) T.Kelly - midfielder - 103.2
6) Walters - small fwd/mid - 101.4
7) Daniel - HBF - 100.3
8) Lyjett - ruck - 99.8
9) Billings - med forward/outside mid - 96.3
10) Heeney - flog medium forward/mid - 94.6

2018
1) Danger - midfielder - 121.7
2) Hawkins - KPF - 101.8
3) Westhoff - floating utility - 101.2
4) Buddy - KPF - 100.1
5) Menegola - midfielder - 100.0
6) D. Smith - half forward/mid - 97.9
7) T. McDonald - KPF - 97.6
8) Heeney - mid/fwd - 97.5
9) R. Gray - mid/fwd - 96.8
10) Gunston - KPFish? - 96.0

2017
1) Menegola - midfielder - 100.4
2) Buddy - KPF - 98.3
3) Heeney - mid/fwd - 97.6
4) Greene - medium forward - 96.1
5) Kennedy (WCE) - KPF - 93.5
6) Wingard - mid/fwd - 93.0
7) Billings - half fwd/outside mid - 92.7
8) R. Gray - mid/fwd - 91.7
9) Dixon - KPF - 90.9
10) Dahlhaus - mid/fwd - 90.7

2016
1) Danger - mid/fwd - 131.8
2) R. Gray - mid/fwd - 108.1
3) Wells - midfielder - 100.6
4) Kennedy (WCE) - KPF - 97.8
5) Dahlhaus - mid/fwd - 95.7
6) Buddy - KPF - 94.6
7) Ziebell - mid/fwd - 94.5
8) Lynch (GCS) - KPF - 93.2
9) Mundy - midfielder - 93.2
10) Gunston - KPFish? - 92.3

With the exception of this year there's probably around 3 KPFs in the comp in the top 10 averaging forwards (never with an average higher than 101.8); if we remove Buddy who's been the exception to the rule it's basically only 2 KPFs in the entire league that are really going to be worth selecting in the long term. A lot can happen between now and R1 2020 but I think there's basically no chance we get a string of KPFs averaging 110+. If we can get 1 that averages the ton I think we'll be lucky. Gold is and will still be with the high half fwd/mid rotators... but I reckon scores across the board will drop next year

You left out

2016
Nick Riewoldt - HF - 101 average (21 games)

I reckon if Carlton ever get going Charlie curnow will average 100-110+ Needs to roam more NRoo style. He certainly has the tank to do so.

 

[Nelso]

Ryder at GWS as their number 1 ruckman, coming off a full preseason, priced at a ~82 average, with FWD/RUCK DPP
Locklocklock

You are forgetting one thing

Ryder is cooked. His achillies is stuffed.

Even at that average, I would not be going anywhere near him as he will not be able to play a number of consecutive games.

 

[stevebbb]

You left out

2016
Nick Riewoldt - HF - 101 average (21 games)

I reckon if Carlton ever get going Charlie curnow will average 100-110+ Needs to roam more NRoo style. He certainly has the tank to do so.

Will be dirt cheap next season with his current average, might be worth a punt. Need to see "ripping preseason" in at least 4 Herald Sun articles before I consider though

 

[Loose at HB]

You left out

2016
Nick Riewoldt - HF - 101 average (21 games)

I reckon if Carlton ever get going Charlie curnow will average 100-110+ Needs to roam more NRoo style. He certainly has the tank to do so.

Apologies, I didn't realise SC gold deleted retired players when looking at previous season scoring

I agree completely about CCurnow regarding role and scoring potential. McKay should be the one staying deep predominately and let Charlie roam as the lead up. If he gets through pre-season unscathed I'll be very tempted to start him in 2020 pending other options.

TBH Jack Silvagni is another I'd keep a loose eye in pre-season. He's getting more of the pill since Teague, has played a heap of time in mids in VFL and club does seem to like him there so if he can build bigger tank in pre-season to enable more mid rotations he might be worth a look.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Apologies, I didn't realise SC gold deleted retired players when looking at previous season scoring

I agree completely about CCurnow regarding role and scoring potential. McKay should be the one staying deep predominately and let Charlie roam as the lead up. If he gets through pre-season unscathed I'll be very tempted to start him in 2020 pending other options.

TBH Jack Silvagni is another I'd keep a loose eye in pre-season. He's getting more of the pill since Teague, has played a heap of time in mids in VFL and club does seem to like him there so if he can build bigger tank in pre-season to enable more mid rotations he might be worth a look.

JSilvagni could be worth a nibble at his opening price if listed as a d/f playing as a utility. Has really come on this year. kudos to him.

 

[Benno_900]

Any rookie/mid-pricer that has spiked in scoring since the byes?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Any rookie/mid-pricer that has spiked in scoring since the byes?

Hunter Clark

 

[Benno_900]

Hunter Clark

The way he is going, his price is going to be awkward.

 

[AFDogs]

Some players I've been keeping an eye on and may be really good PODs next year:
Jordan Dawson (Syd) - clean user of the footy and has added goal kicking to his arsenal
Harmes (Melb) - been one of their best players this year, without Gawn he could win their bnf. Hard at it and kicks goals too
Blakely (Freo) - recommitted to the Dokers. Could see him become a full time mid with Mundy slowing and Fyfe being injury prone. Good player but having a somewhat down year.
McCluggage (Bris) - see Dawson
Petracca (Melb) - will he finally take that next step and become the gun people expected him to be?

 

[Andrew Birch]

The way he is going, his price is going to be awkward.

I don't mind the price awkwardness so long as he gets d/m dpp. His price will keep him relatively PODish.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Some players I've been keeping an eye on and may be really good PODs next year:
Jordan Dawson (Syd) - clean user of the footy and has added goal kicking to his arsenal
Harmes (Melb) - been one of their best players this year, without Gawn he could win their bnf. Hard at it and kicks goals too
Blakely (Freo) - recommitted to the Dokers. Could see him become a full time mid with Mundy slowing and Fyfe being injury prone. Good player but having a somewhat down year.
McCluggage (Bris) - see Dawson
Petracca (Melb) - will he finally take that next step and become the gun people expected him to be?

Jarrod Berry might be ready to step up from 80-85 to SP status

 

[Benno_900]

Potential breakout premos based on recent form...

Darcy Byrne-Jones
Hugh McCluggage
Jordan Dawson if DEF
Hunter Clark if M/D
Bayley Fritsch
Jarrod Lienert
Anthony McDonald-Tipingwuti if plays more mid time
Shai Bolton if plays more mid time
Jack Silvagni if plays more mid time
Callum Mills
Conor McKenna
Darcy Parish
Jy Simpkin
Jade Gresham