one player

[Tiger_Of_Old]

if we had one choice of getting any player from another afl club who would it be?

my pick
jonathon brown[bris].
clearly the next wayne carey of the afl.not only would he straighten up our side the fact of the matter is as history suggests a great chf and your half way towards success.

cheers!

 

[nineteen eighty]

Brown - 22 years of age and plays CHF in a way that makes all other coaches drool. Would straighten up any team and when he hits his 30's he can move down to FF and play out of the square.

Do you think we could offer Pettifer, Houlihan, Hilton for Brown.

 

[Captain Blood]

This is a tough one, we need a CHF and a CHB, we also need a classy running defender.
There are 100s pf player who we need, but because of his age and his ability I'd agree with J. Brown.
Butthen again I wouldn't mind Judd either

 

[DirtyDogTiger]

mmmmmm

We need another winner in the midfield so....

Chris Judd.

Other players who go alright are.....


Lenny Hayes moves well
Vossy would be a monty but ...that knee.
Gee James Hird is hard to overlook...another Brownlow?
Simon Black ...class.
John Brown is the premier forward.
Matty Lloyd would be handy eh?
Jason Johnson for obvious reasons.
Gardiner...wce have an ace in him.
Tarrant would be handy.
Danny wells ...quick player.

so many others....

 

[corporal]

It is easy to say now, and Kane Johnson is a great player,

however wouldn't it be nice to have Daniel Wells on the list

 

[Coach Required]

Ben Cousins, Simon Black or Paul Haselby

We lack quality midfielders other than Johnson and Coughlan

 

[diggler]

Ditto Brown and Id happily trade Brown, Coughlan and Ottens to get him.

 

[Wrenny]

we also need a classy running defender

One of the lonie boys for sure

 

[itsintheblood]

Keep dreaming everybody. All we do is recruit skeleton sized duds to the club.

 

[Fishfinger]

Riewoldt. CHF is just one of many positions he plays, all well.

 

[crazy_big_al]

If i was the tigers i would want Tredders

 

[cairo tiger]

a strong backman- scarlett?

 

[Darth_Tiger]

BROWN BROWN BROWN JOHNATHAN BROWN! - but zero chance of ever getting him

 

[mighty tiges]

Voss would be first choice if it wasn't for his knee. Leadership, classy skills and can dominate in the midfield or be a dangerous option up forward. The complete package.

Footy games are won in the midfield so I'll agree with DDT and go with Chris Judd. Appears to have the above Voss-like qualities and the bonus is he's still young.

 

[peejay]

Originally posted by diggler
Ditto Brown and Id happily trade Brown, Coughlan and Ottens to get him.

Ok - I'll bite

Statements for comments no doubt.

 

[kretchy]

Warren Tredrea for me. Easily as good as Brown but doesn't receive as many plaudits.

 

[jeka]

A. Goodes,

CHF and could share rucking duties with Ottens...plus he's pure class.

Maybe Hall can go to Sydney afterall