Paul Johnson

[Optimax]

lol, yeh we'll swap a stick ruckman for a big ruckman, good on ya, 2nd round is the going rate id say, ruckmen are worth significantly more then smalls even if they havent done much, see jolly as a prime example

yeah i know i just want Richards gone so badly waste of space. Jamar is a good ruckman isnt he? why did he fall out of favour? injury discipline form what happened to him

 

[dspeed]

yeah i know i just want Richards gone so badly waste of space. Jamar is a good ruckman isnt he? why did he fall out of favour? injury discipline form what happened to him

yeh the big russian isnt a bad tap ruckman with very good strength, also has the ability to go forward and would be one of the better contested marks at the club, it is only PJs athleticism keeping him out of the side at the moment, jamar isnt quite as quick around the ground

 

[master bate]

I'd happily trade Jamar for a high 30's low 40's pick. Promote Neaves and use the draft pick to get another ruckman who is tall - 200cm plus. At Jamar's age and with the number of games he has played I just don't see him improving, where as PJ won the Liston medal and has always showed more skills, it was just a matter of time and a luck with injuries until he got it together.

 

[Optimax]

yeh the big russian isnt a bad tap ruckman with very good strength, also has the ability to go forward and would be one of the better contested marks at the club, it is only PJs athleticism keeping him out of the side at the moment, jamar isnt quite as quick around the ground

fair enough id still have him at Collingwood. That Johnson though is lighting on the lead

 

[Deestroy]

Unless we get another ruckman in/upgrade Neaves we should hang onto Jamar as a backup.

 

[dspeed]

Unless we get another ruckman in/upgrade Neaves we should hang onto Jamar as a backup.

i think the ideal scenario would be get a second rounder for Jamar, upgrade Neaves and draft a ruckmen in the 3rd or 4th or a rookie, all dependant however on the clubs evaluation on how Neaves is developing