pick a player

[Opportunity Cost]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola

 

[waspy]

who would you rather ?

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten because of age only

matty scarlett or adam mcphee ????? completely different types of players

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola neither

 

[jazzadogs]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo (for future)


leo barry or darren glass (more creative)

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola

 

[Palmer Stoat]

who would you rather ?

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola

That's not factoring age into the equation.

 

[pouterburgoyne-no7]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredrea

mark williams or stephen milne none

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

Fraser Gehrig or brendan fevola

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

what do ya mean about Buchanan being a downhill skier ?

I watched it happen when Collingwood were in two grand finals in a row - When you're good, all of the players in your side look good. However, when you're not so good, there is always some players who are found out as being not quite as good as they looked.

This happened with guys like Ryan Lonie and Matthew Lokan on our team, and happens with every great team.

I'm not saying it would definitely happen with Buchanan, but you have to wary of players who hit their stride when their team is so good.

 

[MarkJohnson#1]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola

All pretty simple really for me to choose, a couple were 50-50 due to age comparisons but other than that I went for versatility, consistencty and 2005 form

 

[Ten Ton Hammer]

Since when has Brown proved himself to be better than Hall?

Brown has all the potential in the world, but as far as I'm concerned doesn't have the runs on the board yet.

Correct Hall is better than Brown at this stage due to consistency and plus i think brown's finals record is a bit overrated i measn he's only truly dominated 1 final aginst the saints last year when he kicked 6, but he has been influential in other finals.

 

[Bloods]

Correct Hall is better than Brown at this stage due to consistency and plus i think brown's finals record is a bit overrated i measn he's only truly dominated 1 final aginst the saints last year when he kicked 6, but he has been influential in other finals.

Spot on, and apart from the first 2 finals this year, Hall's finals' performances have been good.

 

[tomthehawk]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ? Chad Fletcher, underated player in the Eagles great midfield.

cameron ling or andrew embley Cameron Ling, great player that never gives up.

ben cousins or nick dal santo Dal Santo, both are great but Dal Santos a lot younger and is silky smooth.

leo barry or darren glass Darren Glass, great full back.

dustin fletcher or ben rutten Ben Rutten, great full back who is young.

matty scarlett or adam mcphee Adam McPhee, provides great run and drive out of defence and is a great playmaker.

luke hodge or david wirrpunda Luke Hodge, great player with a brownlow coming soon.

barry hall or jonathon brown Jonathon Brown, great kpp and can dominate the midfield.

matty pavliche or warren tredra Matt Pavlich, more versatile.

mark williams or stephen milne Mark Williams, can be a leading forward or a crumber.

rob murphy or ryan okeefe Ryan O'Keefe, class act so is Murphy nut i'd prefer O'Keefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh Michael O'Loughlin, quality forward and i don't think Welsh is that great.

frasier gherig or brendan fevola Frasier Gherig, i think he is a more willing forward and tries very hard, while Fevola is easily distracted and is an in and out player.

 

[Hodgie15]

amon buchanan or chad fletcher ?

cameron ling or andrew embley

ben cousins or nick dal santo


leo barry or darren glass

dustin fletcher or ben rutten

matty scarlett or adam mcphee

luke hodge or david wirrpunda


barry hall or jonathon brown

matty pavliche or warren tredra

mark williams or stephen milne

rob murphy or ryan okeefe

micheal oloughlin or scott welsh

frasier gherig or brendan fevola