-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Player Comparison Thread - Part 2
- Thread starter 54Dogs
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Not Burton, he won't play till August.
I'm kind of split on the other two. O'Keefe is the safer option and Sylvia gives you the highest potential rewards considering his 93 average over the last 7 rounds last year. If you're a gambling man, go Sylvia, if not go O'Keefe. I personally think Sylvia won't score well in the Melbourne forward line though, but if he gets a midfield move I think he'll have a breakout year.
Also, don't worry about who'll go up in price more. If you're paying 350k+ for a player, you should definitely be picking them to keep so unless they get injured the price becomes irrelevant.
Strachuniee
Team Captain
Definitely Gibbs IMO, all signs indicate his ready score big DT numbersthis year
T.TUCK v REILLY or neither
For me reilly's interesting as he has the scope for some good DT numbers but has struggled to get on the field due to a number of unlucky impact collisions.
Tuck looks the goods but its debatable whether he will keep his spot in the hawks midfield. Thoughts?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Comments Please!
Tuck.
Will hold spot early due to injuries and should get solid TOG.
Even if hes dropped I dont see it before round 7 or 8 pending form.
So he will have peaked and you can offload his ass to a premium.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
I'd go Tuck. Reilly's been in the system for a long time now but hasn't scored above 77 in any year, and he also seems to be very injury prone. Tuck will probably hold his spot for a while at least and looks capable of an 80+ average considering the quality of players around him.
catsdynasty
Team Captain
Sorry I am going away soon and wont be back on DT close towards the lockout. Which option do you think is the better one?? Am leaning towards option A but not sure what are your thoughts.
Also H2G I think Gibbs is the better option as he will score you points more regularly. And Decipher I think that Gabblet and Hille are the safer option as these two will score you more points regularly. But if you want the Big Cox it is up to you as that is also a good option but probably Gazza and Hille.
That's a hard one. I think Ablett and Hille, only because i think Pendlebury will get tagged a bit this year
hey guys who do you think is a better choice out of hasleby vs grigg?
- Oct 3, 2004
- 1,138
- 1
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Dream team
Can afford any midfielder from T Tuck downwards for my 4th mid spot... Am mainly looking at Tuck and Grigg, but have no idea who to choose. What are peoples thoughts on the two?
IMO, Tuck looks more likely to score better, but his spot in the side isn't as safe as Grigg.
IMO, Tuck looks more likely to score better, but his spot in the side isn't as safe as Grigg.
As mentioned elsewhere, Tuck's place in the team should be safe for several rounds, if not for the season. With the number of injuries at the Hawks plus his solid pre-season, he should be a safe. In saying that, Grigg could also average similarly.
I don't think you can really go wrong here. Both are in the same price range and should increase their value significantly.
FWIW, I'm going with Tuck.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Option A Corey + Kornes
or
Option B Ablett + Dalziell +7k
or
Option C Ablett + Selwood + 22k (over Option A, not B)
or
Option B Ablett + Dalziell +7k
or
Option C Ablett + Selwood + 22k (over Option A, not B)
Dalziell will score more than ABC this year. This boy was made for DT
Grigg or Haselby ?
Bowden v Goddard v S. Fisher
Bowden loves the cheap possies in the backline, but my only concern is his age and whether he isin the tigers best 22 atm? so do i save some coin and name either goddard or fisher instead?
would love to hear from some tiger fans on this one....
Bowden loves the cheap possies in the backline, but my only concern is his age and whether he isin the tigers best 22 atm? so do i save some coin and name either goddard or fisher instead?
would love to hear from some tiger fans on this one....
I'd probably take Grigg, i'm not sure but i think Grigg will probably take Stevens' spot in the midfield (maybe ask Carlton board on this). Haselby seems to much risk for me. He will probably be real good in the 2nd half of the season, but the 1st half it seems he may struggle. He could get injured a bit too.
Both these players don't fill me with much confidence though.
Bowden is a bit to high in price, his price would go down at some stage. Goddard is playing in the midfield and looks rather good. I'd take Goddard
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Hey guys who would you pick out of...
Reilly, Grigg, Hasleby.
Reilly, Grigg, Hasleby.
Jay-Z
North's Enforcer
Grigg for me. He has looked good this pre-season and there was an article on the AFL website the other day about him looking forward to a "full time midfield role"
sorry for another one guys... but i am stumped on this one.
Didak...Harvey or Richo...
Didak...Harvey or Richo...
jezza you beauty
Senior List
Personally, would go Didak, then Harvey and finally Richo.
Would leave richo until last, who knows how his body will hold up through the season. But save a trade and a spot in your team for him come finals.
Dont think there is a lot in it between Didak and Harvey. Have read that harvey is very consistant which is good, and will play a lot in the midfield which helps the score. But Didak is my pick, roams up the ground, but will also land a few goals to help the score. And it looks like the Pies will be a good DT team this year and use alot of the ball.
- Status
Similar threads
