Player review vs Blues......lets hear ya!

[Quicky]

I agree with your comment that it was hard to find a player that won their respective position last night. It was a truly poor performance across the board. Considering this I'm surprised that the margin was so close. Beams having a down night comparitive to his recent form and Pendles absence was felt. Goldsack was really poor forward but even worse when switched back. I think we need another forward target to help Cloke out, Dawes just isn't providing a chop out. With Tarrant playing forward in the VFL I think a swap with him for Paine would be wise. Tarrant FF, Cloke CHF and Dawes either dropped for Ceglar or HFF. He might go alright with a bit of pressure taken off him. I feel he would benefit from some confidence in the twos.

 

[Snoop Dog]

I agree with your comment that it was hard to find a player that won their respective position last night. It was a truly poor performance across the board. Considering this I'm surprised that the margin was so close. Beams having a down night comparitive to his recent form and Pendles absence was felt. Goldsack was really poor forward but even worse when switched back. I think we need another forward target to help Cloke out, Dawes just isn't providing a chop out. With Tarrant playing forward in the VFL I think a swap with him for Paine would be wise. Tarrant FF, Cloke CHF and Dawes either dropped for Ceglar or HFF. He might go alright with a bit of pressure taken off him. I feel he would benefit from some confidence in the twos.

I am thinking thats about right. Lets just put it down to a poor night after 10 very good weeks.

I think you have to persist with Dawes but Witts would have to be getting close for mine. I would play him over Ceglar as his kicking has looked appalling at times.

Truly find it odd that people give Maxwell 5 votes

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Truly find it odd that people give Maxwell 5 votes

Given that Maxwell was playing on Duigan who kicked 3 goals, it is indeed a wonder that Maxwell hyas even been included in the best players.

 

[Quicky]

I am thinking thats about right. Lets just put it down to a poor night after 10 very good weeks.

I think you have to persist with Dawes but Witts would have to be getting close for mine. I would play him over Ceglar as his kicking has looked appalling at times.

Truly find it odd that people give Maxwell 5 votes

I think Ceglar has more versatility in terms of him playing forward. If Tarrant were to go to full forward i'd see that second ruckman spending more time half forward than deep which Ceglar is more suited to. I also think Ceglar offers as much/more in terms of his hitouts compared to Witts at this stage too.

 

[sloth6]

Witts isn't ready for senior football.

 

[ksardog]

We can't win the flag with Wood.

Jobe Watson stop liking every OP of our negativity threads you ******* Moo piss off to your Essendon board.

we didint win it with jolly last year either. his best is so far behind him now its scary.

 

[ksardog]

Buckley made one outstanding mistake for the night, albeit a very, very bad one.

He was one player that I wanted the ball in his hands, in the open a lot more. Set up two of our eight goals.

i never want the ball in his hands

 

[Cory]

we didint win it with jolly last year either. his best is so far behind him now its scary.

I would like to see how we would go with Wood seriously

 

[MISFITS]

Changes for next week

Out: Buckley, Clarke, Williams, Wellingham, Paine
In: Tarrant, Didak, Brown, Seedsman, Pendlebury[/quote]

Keep Clarke.
He was a late call up and had no real role except for a short spell on Judd.(where he got murdered)
Basically, we have no more taggers apart from Clarke. There is no point bring in Martin Clarke for one game, destroying his confidence and sending him back to the 2s.
He has been servicable and is still learning the game.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

I would like to see how we would go with Wood seriously

We could if he was given a chance to do so.

Not really fair that he never gets more than a week or two to get a rhythm going. I still think that if given a serious chance, he'd be better than Jolly. But I'm 99.99% sure I'm in the minority on that one.

 

[Cory]

I think it would be a good opportunity to play him against maybe North?

I reckon we should rest Jolly against GWS and give Witts a go.

 

[DThomas]

I think it would be a good opportunity to play him against maybe North?

I reckon we should rest Jolly against GWS and give Witts a go.

UNLEASH THE BEAST!

Play a giant against the Giants. Sounds good to me!

 

[robstewart23]

Pies need the % against GWS. No one will be rested.

 

[Quicky]

UNLEASH THE BEAST!

Play a giant against the Giants. Sounds good to me!

Nah DT it's:

UNLEASH THE BEHEMOTH!!!!!!!!

 

[HotPiesWithSauce]

I was thinking...

UNLEASH THE GARGANTUAN!!!!!!!!

 

[DThomas]

^These guys know what I'm talking about.

 

[SuperSub17]

42 hitouts to 24 our way against the no. 1 draft pick who smashed him in rd 3...puh-leeeaase, give Jolly a break.