Player Votes?

[jim boy]

Anyone running it this year?

Not really that keen to do it myself, but will if no-one else wants to.

rank best five from five to one and work out the average?

anyone got better ideas, eg 5 to 1 in winning matches and only 3 to 1 in losing matches (losers don't deserve the same accolades) for example?

 

[Blackjack5]

just do it on catsclaw

 

[Sammy D]

Ill do it again. Either how we did it last year 5-4-3-2-1 or give everyone a rating out of 10 and average it out. Whatcha think?

 

[Rodion]

5. Joel Corey
4. Cameron Ling
3. Corey Enright
2. Brad Ottens
1. Josh Hunt

 

[rizzo]

5- Ling
4- Kelly
3- Bartel
2- Scarlett
1- Ottens

 

[JUBJUB]

5 Ling
4 J Corey
3 Bartel
2 Enright
1 David Johnson

 

[della]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Kelly
2- Bartel
1- Wojinski


No way ottens was in our top 5 players.


della!

 

[cats56]

5- C.Ling.
4- C.Enright.
3- J.Corey.
2- P.Chapman.
1- J.Kelly.

 

[JUBJUB]

1- Wojinski


No way ottens was in our top 5 players.

True,but you've killed your statement by giving Wojcinski a vote.There would've been 10 players that were better than Wojcinski [Ottens being one].

 

[Ricketts]

5- Ling
4- chapman
3- bartel
2- enright
1- kent.

 

[jim boy]

5-Ling
4-Enright
3-Bartel
2-Corey
1-Mackie

 

[Cattas_21]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Corey
2 - Chapman
1 - Hunt

 

[dodgyhodgy]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Kelly
2 - Corey
1 - Tenace

 

[catempire]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Corey
2 - Kelly
1 - Chapman

Honourable mentions to Mackie (nice cameo), Ottens (a good performance under pressure), Kingsley (did what he has to produce week-in, week-out) and Bartel (typical solid performance).

 

[Tweak Talent]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Bartel
2 - Kelly
1 - Corey

 

[iameviljez]

5 - Cameron Ling, no contest
4 - Corey Enright
3 - Joel Corey
2 - Paul Chapman
1 - James Bartel

 

[Stripey PJs]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Corey
2 - Ottens
1 - Hunt

(Votes are subjective Del, I was impressed by his tackle count and effort)

 

[Fall Out Boy]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Ottens (His rucking was sublime, whilst his tackling and hard work in the forward line were a joy to behold)
2 - Chapman
1 - Playfair (Solid performance in a role he wasn't expecting to play)

 

[Sammy D]

5 - Ling
4 - Enright
3 - Corey
2 - Kelly
1 - Chapman

*VOTING CLOSED*

 

[Sammy D]

5. Ling - 74
4. Enright - 51
3. Corey - 32
2. Bartel - 18
1. Kelly - 17
Chapman - 14
Ottens - 8
Hunt - 3
Scarlett - 2
D. Johnson - 1
Kingsley - 1
Mackie - 1
Playfair - 1
Tenace - 1
Wojcinski - 1

Ling - 5
Enright - 4
Corey - 3
Bartel - 2
Kelly - 1

 

[catfan]

Grrr I knew there was something I forgot to do.

Not to worry as the top five votes there were in stark contrast to what I would of given anyway.