Port Adelaide Player Of The Year Thread

[Macca19]

Round 10 Votes:

114 - Wanganeen - 33
87 - Paxman - 26
39 - James - 11
26 - Stevens - 8
24 - Wakelin - 7
21 - Che C-Collins - 6
12 - Pickett - 3
8 - Schofield - 2
6 - Kingsley - 2
4 - Tredrea - 1
2 - Thurstans - 1
1 - Carr - 0
1 - Cochrane - 0

GavinBoard (Top 15):

230 - Wanganeen
150 - Stevens
87 - P Burgoyne
70 - K Cornes
62 - Tredrea
59 - James
51 - Brogan
36 - C Cornes
35 - Wakelin
32 - Paxman
31 - Pickett
30 - S Burgoyne
22 - Montgomery
14 - Hardwick
14 - Lade

 

[Macca19]

ROUND 11 Votes:

85 - Tredrea - 33
53 - Stevens - 21
38 - Schofield - 15
30 - Wanganeen - 12
27 - Cochrane - 11
11 - Wilson - 4
5 - Burgoyne - 2
5 - Wakelin - 2
1 - James - 0

LEADERBOARD

242 - Wanganeen
171 - Stevens
95 - Tredrea
88 - P Burgoyne
70 - K Cornes
59 - James
51 - Brogan
37 - Wakelin
36 - C Cornes
32 - Paxman

 

[sog35]

Interesting anomoly in our votes that at the end of round 10 S Burgoyne is leading Broges in the rookie votes yet Broges is infront in the BFPOTY.

Is Junior good at being young?

 

[mic59]

Originally posted by sog35
Interesting anomoly in our votes that at the end of round 10 S Burgoyne is leading Broges in the rookie votes yet Broges is infront in the BFPOTY.

Is Junior good at being young?

Brogan has re-taken the lead. But when you expect all eligible players to get a vote no matter how crap they play, it tends to be difficult for anyone who is in the team week in, week out to set up a lead. After all, Toby Thurstans would probably be leading if he was a regular in the team himself.
And with the occasional 2,1 votes it's possible for a player to be miles better than another and only get a few more votes than him. Maybe next year the rookie votes should be on the system that the News had in the 80s. You could vote any of 5,4,3,2,1 and you didn't need to vote if you thought a rookie didn't deserve a vote.

 

[Eago77]

Originally posted by mic59
Brogan has re-taken the lead. But when you expect all eligible players to get a vote no matter how crap they play, it tends to be difficult for anyone who is in the team week in, week out to set up a lead. After all, Toby Thurstans would probably be leading if he was a regular in the team himself.
And with the occasional 2,1 votes it's possible for a player to be miles better than another and only get a few more votes than him. Maybe next year the rookie votes should be on the system that the News had in the 80s. You could vote any of 5,4,3,2,1 and you didn't need to vote if you thought a rookie didn't deserve a vote.

Yes we obviously have a flawed system at the moment. Maybe next year we each give each rookie a mark out of ten and then add them up and weight them so that every week each rookie gets a mark out of 100.

 

[PAfolwr]

Originally posted by sog35
Interesting anomoly in our votes that at the end of round 10 S Burgoyne is leading Broges in the rookie votes yet Broges is infront in the BFPOTY.

Is Junior good at being young?

It shows that when Brogan is good, he can be very good for the team.