Post your team thread V.2

[Spudregus_87]

B: Fisher, Newman, Cornes, Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, Hill, (Rance, Petrenko)
Tried to fit in Fisher AND Goddard, but no luck yet. Adcock & Malceski are a tad risky, but I think I'm prepared to take the risk.

M: Judd, Corey, Cross, Hayes, Haselby, Rich, (Robinson Beams)
Really happy with it. Known scorers, and hopefully Hasleby goes back to 25+ possie games, I think Rich will occupy the 6th MF spot for about 98% of SC teams.

R: Cox, McIntosh (Currie, Pike)
McIntosh has shown me enough to get picked. Seems to be big enough wraps on Currie for him to be my 1st emg.

F: Boomer, Pav, Lids, Lucas, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Hogan, Ballantyne)
A few riskys here, but gotta take a few risks here and there. Can always downgrade Corey/Boomer to make Ziebell an emg and get someone like J.Brown

Uh guys......any feedback appreciated

 

[hello10]

Back: Hodge Drummond Adcock Malceski Houlihan Raines Hill (A.Rance, Z.Dawson)
Obviously quite weak but i think hodge will be a star and avg. 120+ this year and i see most of the pts coming out of the mids/forwards

Mids: Judd Pendlebury Foley Hasleby T.Tuck Rich (Anthony, M.Robinson)
hard decision between pendles and selwood just gave pendles the nod what do ya think? also see great value in tuck.

Rucks: Petrie Hille (Roughhead, Currie)
decided against cox just because of his woeful preseason and for 100k less i see petrie onyle avg about 10-15pts less than cox anyway. hille very consistent

Forwards: N.Riewoldt N.Brown J.Brown Roughead Fev Higgins Krakour (Ziebell, J.Grant)
riewoldt is a superstar that will again dominate. i see n.brown regainin his brownlow favouritism form before his leg injury. you cant not have j.brown!! roughead i see him rising due to buddy playing more time up the ground. fev great value. not sure bout skipworth?

i have 90k left in the bank. any thoughts appreciated?

 

[Shut up Flanders]

I think the general policy was to comment on another team and then you get feedback.

*hint* mines just a few posts above without a comment

 

[IhateMondays]

Hey Flaaaandeeeeers, you're also supposed to explain your team. but ill comment anyway.

Backs: B.Goddard, H.Shaw, C.Cornes, H.Taylor, N.Malceski, R.Houlihan, J.Grimes (S.Hill, N.Suban)

Mids: G.Ablett, J.Bartel, C.Judd, B.Gibbs, D.Rich, J.Ziebell (D.Beams, M.Robinson)

Rucks: D.Cox, B.Ottens (D.Currie, J.Meeson)

Fwds: B.Harvey, B.Deledio, A.Didak, B.Fevola, S.Higgins, H.Skipworth, J.Grant (M.Brown, S.Gumbleton)

Defence looks solid, though im not convinced by one good game from taylor. i love the midfield though, should get lots of points-if laidley gives ziebell a game! Get rid of Meeson, hes a dud. Forwards also look solid, though i would be starting brown or gumby ahead of grant. Also dont trust the Fev, for while he looks great now hell still throw in some shockers.

hello10s team:

Back: Hodge Drummond Adcock Malceski Houlihan Raines Hill (A.Rance, Z.Dawson)
Obviously quite weak but i think hodge will be a star and avg. 120+ this year and i see most of the pts coming out of the mids/forwards

Mids: Judd Pendlebury Foley Hasleby T.Tuck Rich (Anthony, M.Robinson)
hard decision between pendles and selwood just gave pendles the nod what do ya think? also see great value in tuck.

Rucks: Petrie Hille (Roughhead, Currie)
decided against cox just because of his woeful preseason and for 100k less i see petrie onyle avg about 10-15pts less than cox anyway. hille very consistent

Forwards: N.Riewoldt N.Brown J.Brown Roughead Fev Higgins Krakour (Ziebell, J.Grant)
riewoldt is a superstar that will again dominate. i see n.brown regainin his brownlow favouritism form before his leg injury. you cant not have j.brown!! roughead i see him rising due to buddy playing more time up the ground. fev great value. not sure bout skipworth?

Urgently need to reconsider your defence bench, maybe spangher, grimes or hurley are some options? Hill has a very weak body and i cant see him playing more than 60% of the game. I'd go Selwood, but thats just because i played sport with him last year. Respect your decision not to have Cox, but i won't be going there. No idea how Roughead will go either, haven't heard much. Forwards fluctuate a lot, sp maybe it would be a good idea to downgrade a couple and upgrade elsewhere so you can trade to them later. Perhaps wait on Brown and see if he recaptures that form, and skippy is an excellent downgrade option.

My Team V666:
Goddard, Fisher, Newman, Malceski, Houlihan, Grimes, Collier (Hill, Spangher)
Lots of cows here, but a solid bench in case they dont work out and to avoid the back bench conundrum.

Ablett, Selwood, Gibbs, Knights, Tuck, Rich (Otten, Robinson)
Ablett is in because i need a reliable captain, and hes the man. Saves me a trade later too for when i upgrade to him. Knights is my favourite player, so dont bother commenting on him.

Cox, Hille (J white, graham)
Enough said

Pavlich, Deledio, Chapman, Higgins, Skipworth, Krakouer, Yarran (M Brown, Gumbleton)
Again, lots of cheap options because of the aforementioned forward fluctuations. Brown and gumby should both get lots of games as cover for the other ones, yarran in particular is a worry for me.

Salary remaining: $105,600.

Thoughts, criticisms, angry yelling about Ablett, knights and not having Hasleby?(that seems to be all this team gets....)

 

[mattys123]

Back: Hodge Drummond Adcock Malceski Houlihan Raines Hill (A.Rance, Z.Dawson)
Obviously quite weak but i think hodge will be a star and avg. 120+ this year and i see most of the pts coming out of the mids/forwards

Mids: Judd Pendlebury Foley Hasleby T.Tuck Rich (Anthony, M.Robinson)
hard decision between pendles and selwood just gave pendles the nod what do ya think? also see great value in tuck.

Rucks: Petrie Hille (Roughhead, Currie)
decided against cox just because of his woeful preseason and for 100k less i see petrie onyle avg about 10-15pts less than cox anyway. hille very consistent

Forwards: N.Riewoldt N.Brown J.Brown Roughead Fev Higgins Krakour (Ziebell, J.Grant)
riewoldt is a superstar that will again dominate. i see n.brown regainin his brownlow favouritism form before his leg injury. you cant not have j.brown!! roughead i see him rising due to buddy playing more time up the ground. fev great value. not sure bout skipworth?

i have 90k left in the bank. any thoughts appreciated?

Overall, pretty good team.

You may have problems with the backs, with Adcock, Malceski and Drummond all past injury worries, but apart from that, good.
Like your mids, I have no clue on Tuck, but he is well priced, so could be a cash cow.
Only problem with your forwards are both Roughead and Fev, both marking forwards who rely on goals rather then other stats, might be a risk to have 2 in one side.
I dont have Skipworth, he never scored highly at Adelaide, why would he now.

Anyway, my team at the moment is;

Backs: Goddard, C.Cornes, Lockyer, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Hill
em: Suban, Rance

Mids: Ablett (C), Bartel, Pendlebury, Salopek, Morton, Rich
em: Beams, L.Anthony

Rucks: Cox, Maric
em: White, Currie

Fwds: O'keefe, Deledio, Davis, Mcphee, Hansen, Krakouer, Ziebell
em: M.Brown (geel), W.Thompson.

THOUGHTS?

 

[bombers own]

B; Goddard, Cornes, Adcock, malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Hill
Crap, but IMO 3-4 keepers and the rest will make me $$$

C; Ablett, Judd, Dal Santo, Murphy, Haselby, Rich (Danger, Swift)
Reliable captain option in Ablett, should have all keepers by round 10.

R; Cox, Kruezer (Currie, Graham)
IMO Kreuzer will make a fair bit of $$$, easy upgrade.

F; Pav, Lids, J.Brown, Steve J, Lucas/Skipworth, Higgins, Sidebottom(Brown, Gumby)
4 keepers, the rest money-makers.

I like this team personally, thoughts?

 

[Liuy]

Defenders

Goddard B, Newman C, Cornes C, Harley T, Malceski, N, Raines,A, Grimes J
(Hill S, Petrenko, J)


midfield

Bartel, J Judd, C Tuck, S Selwood, J Gibbs, B Rich, D
( Beams, D Robinson, M)

rucks

Cox, D Jolly, D

( White, J Currie, D)


Forwards

Fevola, B Brown, J Franklin, L Higgins, S Skipworth, H Westhoff, M Yarran, C
( Ziebell, J Garlett, J)


$3800

Ahh, where to start.
Backs, you need more keepers along with Newman. Harley's injured, so no point having him.

Mids: I like it, but one midfielder too heavy, downgrade Selwood or Tuck to strengthen up cash.

Rucks: Jolly's too expensive free up the cash and put it somewhere else.

Forwards: Again more keepers needed.


now my team.


Backs:Goddard, Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Raines, Grimes, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)

Mids:Bartel, Judd, Hayes, Gibbs, T.Tuck, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

Rucks:Cox, Ottens (Currie, Graham)

Forwards:Harvey, Pav, Deledio, Didak, Higgins, Skippy, Ziebell (Dick, M.Brown.)
Thoughts Appreciated.

 

[jakee]

a risk with dick on your bench. will he get a game?
other than that your team looks good.. strong forward line!

my team.

B: Goddard, Cornes, Houli, Taylor, Adcock, Houlihan, Raines
em: Rance, Schoenmakers
M: Bartel, Harvey, Gibbs, Jackson, Tuck, Masten
em: Rich, Beams
R: Hille, Kreuzer
em: Currie, Sellar
F: Pavlich, Deledio, Didak, Roughead, Higgins, Krakouer, Yarran
em: Sidebottom, Gumbleton

 

[Shinboner '07]

you need another keeper for the defence, take out taylor
you need another premium midfielder, take out jackson
not sure about krakouer and yarran starting, dont think krakeour will be a regular at port

my team, which is pretty much finalised:

BACKS: Hodge, Goddard, Fisher, Mackie, Malceski, Raines, Grimes
(Hill, Suban)

MIDS: Judd, Murphy, J. Selwood, Gibbs, Masten, Beams
(Robinson, Anthony)

RUCKS: McIntosh, Gilmore
(Graham, Jacobs)

FORWARDS: Franklin, O'Keefe, Didak, Medhurst, Fevola, Higgins, Ziebell
(Sidebottom, Gumbleton)

 

[Baker_for_PM]

you need another keeper for the defence, take out taylor
you need another premium midfielder, take out jackson
not sure about krakouer and yarran starting, dont think krakeour will be a regular at port

my team, which is pretty much finalised:

BACKS: Hodge, Goddard, Fisher, Mackie, Malceski, Raines, Grimes
(Hill, Suban)

MIDS: Judd, Murphy, J. Selwood, Gibbs, Masten, Beams
(Robinson, Anthony)

RUCKS: McIntosh, Gilmore
(Graham, Jacobs)

FORWARDS: Franklin, O'Keefe, Didak, Medhurst, Fevola, Higgins, Ziebell
(Sidebottom, Gumbleton)

Rucks are abit weak i think gilmore is overated, beams on the field is abit of a risk same as ziebell i might be going with hill but you never no how the coach is going to play them. I heard a "rumor" that franklin isnt top notch and the thumb injury is a smokescreen so thats why ive stayed away. An Malceski is also under an injury cloud on whats really wrong.

Whats the best option:

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Hill S (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Masten C (Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Hall B, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

or

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Raines A (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Hill S or Rich,(Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Petrie D if hill and Goodwin if Rich, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

 

[Satan]

Rucks are abit weak i think gilmore is overated, beams on the field is abit of a risk same as ziebell i might be going with hill but you never no how the coach is going to play them. I heard a "rumor" that franklin isnt top notch and the thumb injury is a smokescreen so thats why ive stayed away. An Malceski is also under an injury cloud on whats really wrong.

Whats the best option:

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Hill S (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Masten C (Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Hall B, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

or

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Raines A (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Hill S or Rich,(Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Petrie D if hill and Goodwin if Rich, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

spencer is rookie listed so may not play for a while

 

[maggers]

Rucks are abit weak i think gilmore is overated, beams on the field is abit of a risk same as ziebell i might be going with hill but you never no how the coach is going to play them. I heard a "rumor" that franklin isnt top notch and the thumb injury is a smokescreen so thats why ive stayed away. An Malceski is also under an injury cloud on whats really wrong.

Whats the best option:

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Hill S (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Masten C (Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Hall B, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

or

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Raines A (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Hill S or Rich,(Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Petrie D if hill and Goodwin if Rich, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

Backs:
I would mayby say Raines over Hill, only because Hill is small and Raines has experience and has had an awesome pre-season. Rest looks good.

Mids:
Pretty strong line up. I'm too sure who I would recommend out of Masten, Hill and Rich. All look set to have big seasons. Rich is good value for money. Hill is a bit overpriced for his first season. Masten looks set to fire.

Rucks:
Ditch Meesen, now. Rest is good. Spencer is a rookie but he's too good to pass up. When hes eligble to be elevated then he will be worth it.

Front:
I wouldnt take Barry Hall, but thats mainly because I don't like him. Rest is strong. Would probably take Goodwin over Petrie.

My Team

Defence
B. Goddard, C. Cornes, H. Taylor, R. Houlihan, A. Raines, J. Grimes, S. Hill (J. Petrenko, R. Schoenmakers)

Fairly happy with this setup. I've mainly poured alot of cash into the midfield, because I believe thats where the game is won. I'm happy with everyone except I'm not entirely convinced with Houlihan, but I can't see anyone worth taking at his value. I'm also not sure about Hill starting, I would need a major reshuffle to get him on the bench though. I want proven player to start.

Midfield
C. Judd, S. Mitchell, B. Gibbs, B. McLean, R. Griffen, ??????? (D. Rich, M. Robinson)

I'm really happy with this setup. Can't pass Judd with a full preseason, Micthell served me very well last year and I can't pass him up, Gibbs looks set to pounce, I'm a Melbourne supporter so I can't go pass McLean, always been a fan of Griffen.

I need help on selecting my next gun midfielder. I have alot of cash but can't decide who to take. I had Pendlebury but I keep having second thoughts about him. I need advice on who to take out of the following:

A. Goodes, L. Power, D. Cross, S. Pendlebury, S. Thompson, J. Selwood

I like all of them and can't decide who.

Ruck
A. Sandlilands, D. Hille (M. Pyke, J. Spencer)

I originally had Hille and P. Johnson. But I wasn't convinced on having Hille as my first ruckman and wasn't sure if Johnson could be consistent. Went to a sure fire in Sandlilands. Big man always does well.

Forward
L. Franklin, B. Deledio, P. Chapman, J. Roughead, S. Higgins, H. Skipworth, J. Ziebell (W. Thompson, S. Hogan)

Fairly happy with this. Love Buddy, he is the man, no doubt about it. Deledio excites me, Chappy is very consistent. Not 100% on Roughy. Higgins is ready to excite again. Spikworth has shown me he really wants to make the most of his opportuntity. Ziebell is a gun of the future and will get better and better.

I'm considering to slot Fev somewhere in there. Roughead or Fevola? Or Neither?

 

[trix17]

Whats the best option:

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Hill S (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Masten C (Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Hall B, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

or

Backs: Goddard, Cornes C, Lockyer T, Taylor H, Clarke M, Grimes J, Raines A (petrenko,rance)

Mids: Bartel J, Deledio B, Gibbs B, Hasleby P, Tuck T, Hill S or Rich,(Robinson,Beams)

Rucks: Cox D, McIntosh H (Messen, Spencer J)

Fow: Riewoldt N, Pavlich M, Petrie D if hill and Goodwin if Rich, Roughead J, Houlihan R, Higgins S, Skipworth H ( Walker T, Brown M)

i would go with the 2nd option for sure. i personally wouldnt have deledio in the mids since you can get him as a forward. get rich over hill as he will play more games, then move deledio to the forward line instead of goodwin, then pick up dal santo or hayes i would reccomend in the middle, but thats just my opinion.

my team currently looks like:

BACK: Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, Houli, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
i like my top 4 here, all over happy with this line apart from houlihan, not sure if he is a great option, but cant find anyone better at that price.

MID: Bartel, Judd, Dal Santo/Hayes, Selwood, T.Tuck, D.Rich (M.Robinson, D.Beams)
very happy with my midfield, i would love to have ablett, but cant seem to fit him in while keeping the team even. not sure whether to go dal santo or hayes?

RUCK: Cox, Ottens (Currie, Sullivan)
happy with it provided ottens stays fit

FORWARD: Harvey, O'Keefe, Deledio, Al.Davey, S.Higgins, Skipworth/Henstchel, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Grant)
not completely happy with davey being my 4th forward, any opinions on a way to make that position better? otherwise happy with forwards.

thoughts on my team would be helpfull.
Cheers

 

[mister2]

BACK: Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, Houli, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Petrenko)
i like my top 4 here, all over happy with this line apart from houlihan, not sure if he is a great option, but cant find anyone better at that price.

MID: Bartel, Judd, Dal Santo/Hayes, Selwood, T.Tuck, D.Rich (M.Robinson, D.Beams)
very happy with my midfield, i would love to have ablett, but cant seem to fit him in while keeping the team even. not sure whether to go dal santo or hayes?

RUCK: Cox, Ottens (Currie, Sullivan)
happy with it provided ottens stays fit

FORWARD: Harvey, O'Keefe, Deledio, Al.Davey, S.Higgins, Skipworth/Henstchel, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Grant)
not completely happy with davey being my 4th forward, any opinions on a way to make that position better? otherwise happy with forwards.

thoughts on my team would be helpfull.
Cheers

Looks pretty solid to me ... a good 12-13 keepers and seem to have the cash cows covered. Agree it's those mid-tier that will be make or break

Backs - doesnt look like you can do much there but if your really not happy with Houiihan, maybe Dempsey as an alternative or Petterd if you are willing to take some risks and free up some dollars for your forward line.. I think you've got it right though

Forwards - again pretty damn good ... not sure I see O'keefe as great value but just my opinion. Assume you considered Lucas instead of Davey and decided against that



Also happy for opinions on mine:

DEF: Goddard, C Cornes, Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Suban)

MID: Bartel, Judd, Pendlebury, Del Santo, T Tuck, Rich (probably Dangerfield + Robinson)

RUC: Cox Hille (White, Messen)

FWD: Harvey, Pavlich, Deledio, Lucas, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebel (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)

Obviously the back line is little risky but good value prospects there. Midfield and ruck I'm pretty comfortable with as a starting point.

Big concern is the lucas/skipworth combination in the forward line - might change one or both of those

thoughts?

 

[BAK2BAK]

fairly similar too mine so would like some comments too
cheers...
Backs - Goddard, cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes
Emg - Hill, Rance

Mid - Ablett, Judd, Pendelbury, Gibbs, Tuck, Rich
Emg - Robinson, Beams

Rucks - Cox, Leuenberger
Emg - White, Sellar

Fwd - Pavlich, Franklin, Deledio, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Henderson
Emg - Ziebell, Thorp

Any thoughts much appreciated....

 

[asanque]

Re: Post your team thread V.2 - if you dont comment, you dont get feedback

With the start nearing, i thought this thread would be a little bit more effective than the previous. Similar to the other one except:
- You must comment on someone else's team before posting your own, if you dont comment, you dont get feedback
- When posting your team you put a line or two about your thought process and who you are thinking of excluding/including (optional)
- Ensure you include how much $$ left

If you don't like this thread or the idea behind it, post in the other one .

Here's mine, i'll comment on whoever's next.

B: Goddard, Shaw, Drummond, Cornes, Malceski, Raines, Hill (Grimes, Petrenko)
I'm thinking like last year, backs will struggle so have decided ill take the most risks here.

M: Bartel, Judd, Selwood, Gibbs, Petterd, Rich (Beams, Swift)
Think Selwood and Gibbs will continue to improve. Had Skippy but have gone for Petterd cos i needed the funds.

R: Cox, Ottens (Currie, Sellar)
Emergencies will need to be looked at.

F: Deledio, Richardson, LDavis, Fevola, Houlihan, Higgins, Ziebell (Sidebottom, Gumbleton)
Staying away from traditional big forwards in the early part. Davis is not someone id usually look at but going in with a diff strategy this year.

Cash: $12,500

Looking forward to another competitive year from the runner-up in our league last year

I haven't finalised my team as yet.

My quick comments are as follows:

Backs: Very close to mine. Drummond, Malceski, Raines all risky but well priced.

Midfield: Pricy midfield. I had Selwood and Judd in initially but took both out for more value players. I'd try and improve Petterd, and Beams and Swift aren't my emergencies

Rucks: Cox is a lock. The balance looks fine and will be similar to my approach.

Forwards: Similar to my initial set up but then I got rid of Deledio and Richo. I considered Leon but feel there is better value. I also couldn't squeeze in Higgins.

Overall: Very nice balanced team and it looks like you have done your homework this year After premierships in the last two years I have been taking it easier this year, but will be ramping up soon

We're not very loyal to our teams
You have 1 Essendon player (Gumbleton) and I have 1 Hawthorn player (Thorp).

 

[IDIG]

Re: Post your team thread V.2 - if you dont comment, you dont get feedback

Looking forward to another competitive year from the runner-up in our league last year

I haven't finalised my team as yet.

My quick comments are as follows:

Backs: Very close to mine. Drummond, Malceski, Raines all risky but well priced.

Midfield: Pricy midfield. I had Selwood and Judd in initially but took both out for more value players. I'd try and improve Petterd, and Beams and Swift aren't my emergencies

Rucks: Cox is a lock. The balance looks fine and will be similar to my approach.

Forwards: Similar to my initial set up but then I got rid of Deledio and Richo. I considered Leon but feel there is better value. I also couldn't squeeze in Higgins.

Overall: Very nice balanced team and it looks like you have done your homework this year After premierships in the last two years I have been taking it easier this year, but will be ramping up soon

We're not very loyal to our teams
You have 1 Essendon player (Gumbleton) and I have 1 Hawthorn player (Thorp).

haha yeah my teams changed quite a bit since then. Pretty much on a daily basis but for the most part it's there. Looking forward to this year i think we;ll be able to give you a bit of competition..hopefully.

 

[Team Mo']

fairly similar too mine so would like some comments too
cheers...
Backs - Goddard, cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes
Emg - Hill, Rance

Mid - Ablett, Judd, Pendelbury, Gibbs, Tuck, Rich
Emg - Robinson, Beams

Rucks - Cox, Leuenberger
Emg - White, Sellar

Fwd - Pavlich, Franklin, Deledio, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Henderson
Emg - Ziebell, Thorp

Any thoughts much appreciated....

Very similiar to mine. Gone risky in the rucks to allow for more money elsewhere. Be weary of Pavlich is the rumour this year but I guess he is a superstar who very rarely misses games so his selection is justified.

Very risky backline and I'd probably grab one more injury free/consitent player in there just to give it that safety or security. But you do have Hill covering so it looks pretty safe.

Heres my team after 1000's of changes:

Backs: Goddard, Fisher, Newman, Drummond, Houlihan, Petterd, Grimes (Hill and Suban)

Mids: Ablett, Judd, Pendulbury, Gibbs, Tuck/Masten, Rich (Dangerfield and Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, Leuenberger (White and Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Deledio, Richo/Davis/Gia, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gumbleton and Gartlett/Walker)

 

[Italian Stallion]

fairly similar too mine so would like some comments too
cheers...
Backs - Goddard, cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes
Emg - Hill, Rance

Mid - Ablett, Judd, Pendelbury, Gibbs, Tuck, Rich
Emg - Robinson, Beams

Rucks - Cox, Leuenberger
Emg - White, Sellar

Fwd - Pavlich, Franklin, Deledio, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Henderson
Emg - Ziebell, Thorp

Any thoughts much appreciated....

yeah ill give u thoughts..
hender-WHO??
hes terrible!!

 

[Team Mo']

yeah ill give u thoughts..
hender-WHO??
hes terrible!!

Thanks for your input.

 

[Pissi123]

Very similiar to mine. Gone risky in the rucks to allow for more money elsewhere. Be weary of Pavlich is the rumour this year but I guess he is a superstar who very rarely misses games so his selection is justified.

Very risky backline and I'd probably grab one more injury free/consitent player in there just to give it that safety or security. But you do have Hill covering so it looks pretty safe.

Heres my team after 1000's of changes:

Backs: Goddard, Fisher, Newman, Drummond, Houlihan, Petterd, Grimes (Hill and Suban)

Mids: Ablett, Judd, Pendulbury, Gibbs, Tuck/Masten, Rich (Dangerfield and Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, Leuenberger (White and Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Deledio, Richo/Davis/Gia, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gumbleton and Gartlett/Walker)

Not know a huge lot about sc but ill give it a go...
Looks like a solid team, really like your backline goddard, fisher and newman, cant go wrong and your other players look like they could make a lot of money.
As for your midfield I would maybe downgrade ablett to free up some money but thats personal preference. I would go tuck as he should get a game everyweek in a champion team.
Rucks look good but dont know about leuenberger.
forward line looks solid and i would take gia out of the three.

as for my team

Backs - Goddard, Fisher, Cornes, Malceski, Houlihan, Raines, Grimes (Hill, Patrenko)

Midfield - Bartel, Judd, Cross, Pendlebury, Tuck, Rich (Dangerfield, Beams)

Rucks - Cox, Maric (Currie, Meesen(dont know about him, apparently a dud but dont know any other options at his price))

Forwards - Harvey, Pavlich, Deledio, J Riewoldt, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Ballantyne, Gumbleton)

 

[jonoman89]

Backs: Goddard, Fisher, Newman, Drummond, Houlihan, Petterd, Grimes (Hill and Suban)

Mids: Ablett, Judd, Pendulbury, Gibbs, Tuck/Masten, Rich (Dangerfield and Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, Leuenberger (White and Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Deledio, Richo/Davis/Gia, Fevola, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gumbleton and Gartlett/Walker)

Backs look great Mo. I think Drummond, while injury prone, is worth a punt. Voss seems to be implimenting a lot more of a midfield emphasis into their game plan, meaning his run and carry could be utilised even more.

Midds look good again. I dunno between tuck and Masten. I think Tuck will score more, but the midfield depth at the Hawks might keep him out for a few rounds. I had Rich as a starter too, then relised i could have Beams there and save 40k. They'll probably post similar scores anyway judging NAB form.

Rucks...Leue no guarantee to get 22 games. Have a look at Sam Jacobs on the bench - 99% sure to get at least 5 games this year and is only 83K. Don't think you'll make cash from ruck reserves, i've never been able to. All you can hope is to get the cheapest player who'll get occassional games.

Forward line a tad weak. Franklin, Deledio are fine, Richo is a punt considering he's 34. Davis' last 10 games is what got him a good average. Fevola very inconsistent. I'd take Walker over Garlett..unless Garlett gets promoted.

BACKS: Goddard, Cornes, Gilbee, H. Shaw, Raines, Houlihan, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)

MIDFIELD: Ablett, Judd, Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Kerr, Beams (Robinson, Swift)

RUCKS: Ottens, McIntosh (Jacobs, Pyke)

FORWARDS: Pavlich, Franklin, Deledio, J Brown, Higgins, Yarran, Gumbleton (Ballantyne, J. Grant)

I know my rucks are weak, but i will upgrade Ottens to Cox soon as he will no doubt jump in price.

 

[Pendles!]

BACKS: Goddard, Cornes, Gilbee, H. Shaw, Raines, Houlihan, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)

MIDFIELD: Ablett, Judd, Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Kerr, Beams (Robinson, Swift)

RUCKS: Ottens, McIntosh (Jacobs, Pyke)

FORWARDS: Pavlich, Franklin, Deledio, J Brown, Higgins, Yarran, Gumbleton (Ballantyne, J. Grant)

I know my rucks are weak, but i will upgrade Ottens to Cox soon as he will no doubt jump in price.

Backs: looking fairly solid, bit risky with Raines, houlihan and hill but as long as 2 of the 3 play it will most likely pay off.

Midfield: looks pretty good,I expect nicky dal to bounce back after last year (yet he still ave. 100), not sure about kerr, will probably struggle to play 22 games.

Rucks: Both will rise in value and could pick up a Hille or Jolly, etc.

Forwards:Not to sure about, starting yarran and gumbleton, maybe downgrade ablett and up grade yarran for skipworth.

overall looks pretty good.

now my team.

Backs: Goddard, Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Raines, Grimes.
inter: Petrenko, suban.

Mids: Judd, Pendles, Kornes, Gibbs, Masten, Rich.
Inter: Robinson, Dangerfield.

Rucks: Hille, Fraser.
inter: Graham, Jake Spencer.

Forwards: Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, Fevola, Skippy, Higgins, Reid.
inter: Mitch Brown, Ziebell.
45k left

comments very much appreciated.

 

[Winner]

Team Version 30.7

Backs: Newman, P.Burgoyne, C.Cornes, J.Drummond, Adcock, Myers, Hill (Rance and Suban).
Midfield: Ablett, Selwood, Stanton, Osborne, Higgins, Robinson (Anthony and Swift).
Ruck: Cox and Ottens (White and Trengove).
Forward: Harvey, Deledio, Richardson, Didak, Lucas, Skipworth, Ziebell (Gartlett and Walker).

Feedback welcome.

 

[Satan]

Backs:
I would mayby say Raines over Hill, only because Hill is small and Raines has experience and has had an awesome pre-season. Rest looks good.

Mids:
Pretty strong line up. I'm too sure who I would recommend out of Masten, Hill and Rich. All look set to have big seasons. Rich is good value for money. Hill is a bit overpriced for his first season. Masten looks set to fire.

Rucks:
Ditch Meesen, now. Rest is good. Spencer is a rookie but he's too good to pass up. When hes eligble to be elevated then he will be worth it.

Front:
I wouldnt take Barry Hall, but thats mainly because I don't like him. Rest is strong. Would probably take Goodwin over Petrie.

My Team

Defence
B. Goddard, C. Cornes, H. Taylor, R. Houlihan, A. Raines, J. Grimes, S. Hill (J. Petrenko, R. Schoenmakers)

Fairly happy with this setup. I've mainly poured alot of cash into the midfield, because I believe thats where the game is won. I'm happy with everyone except I'm not entirely convinced with Houlihan, but I can't see anyone worth taking at his value. I'm also not sure about Hill starting, I would need a major reshuffle to get him on the bench though. I want proven player to start.

Midfield
C. Judd, S. Mitchell, B. Gibbs, B. McLean, R. Griffen, ??????? (D. Rich, M. Robinson)

I'm really happy with this setup. Can't pass Judd with a full preseason, Micthell served me very well last year and I can't pass him up, Gibbs looks set to pounce, I'm a Melbourne supporter so I can't go pass McLean, always been a fan of Griffen.

I need help on selecting my next gun midfielder. I have alot of cash but can't decide who to take. I had Pendlebury but I keep having second thoughts about him. I need advice on who to take out of the following:

A. Goodes, L. Power, D. Cross, S. Pendlebury, S. Thompson, J. Selwood

I like all of them and can't decide who.

Ruck
A. Sandlilands, D. Hille (M. Pyke, J. Spencer)

I originally had Hille and P. Johnson. But I wasn't convinced on having Hille as my first ruckman and wasn't sure if Johnson could be consistent. Went to a sure fire in Sandlilands. Big man always does well.

Forward
L. Franklin, B. Deledio, P. Chapman, J. Roughead, S. Higgins, H. Skipworth, J. Ziebell (W. Thompson, S. Hogan)

Fairly happy with this. Love Buddy, he is the man, no doubt about it. Deledio excites me, Chappy is very consistent. Not 100% on Roughy. Higgins is ready to excite again. Spikworth has shown me he really wants to make the most of his opportuntity. Ziebell is a gun of the future and will get better and better.

I'm considering to slot Fev somewhere in there. Roughead or Fevola? Or Neither?

Based on tonights game I think Selwood would be handy