Post your team thread V.2

[Dylz48]

Here is my current supercoach team for 2009.
Give me some advise on how I can make my team better.
Made some changes to my team
Got $2,700 left

I'd get rid of Drummond overrated in my opinion I'd try and fit in Mackie or bock. Othe than that pretty good

heres my team
B: L.Hodge -- N.Bock -- A.Mackie-- T.Williams-- Raines-- A.Toovey -- S.Hill (Em: A. Rance & N.Suban)
M: G.Ablett-- S.Pendelburry -- S.Mitchell-- J.Sellwood-- A.Swallow -- D.Rich (Em: D.Beams & P. Dangerfield)
R: Hille -- K.Tippet (EM: M. Leunburger & J.Spencer)
F: Pavlich -- M.Richardson-- A.Didak-- J.Roughhead-- B.Fevola-- S.Higgins-- T.Hentschel (Em: J.Zibbell& J.grant)
I have 35K left

Will Suban, Spencer, Grant, Rance get game time threw most of em in as cheapys but would like to know there half decent.

Should I keep Ablett?

Was also thinking of getting rid of swallow + mitchell and getting cotchin + Boak but am worried I will have to many richmond players)

Any other thoughts??

 

[piggyboy]

It has taken a few edits to get to this team, but I'm fairly happy with it. Any comments would be appreciated

Gilbee, Bock, Cornes C, Adcock, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Hurley, Rance)

Ablett (c), Bartel, Cornes K, Gibbs, Hasleby, Rich (Anthony, Robinson)

Cox, Tippett (Vickery, Spencer)

Pavlich, Deledio, Lovett, Rioli, McKinley, Higgins, Krakouer (Walker, Grant)

$9400 remaining

 

[Lids12]

Backs: Goddard, Fisher/Gilbee, C.Cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Raines, Hill
Suban Rance

Midfield: Judd, Dal Santo, Murphy, Selwood, Foley, Rich
Beams, Anthony

Rucks: Hille, McIntosh
Spencer, Currie

Forwards: Harvey, Deledio, Richo, T.Cloke, Higgins, Skipworth, Krakouer
Brown, Walker

I am not too sure between Fisher and Gilbee?
and
Harvey + Cloke
or
Franklin/O'Keefe/Goodwin/Chapman + Fevola

 

[nofeet]

I'd get rid of Drummond overrated in my opinion I'd try and fit in Mackie or bock. Othe than that pretty good

heres my team
B: L.Hodge -- N.Bock -- A.Mackie-- T.Williams-- Raines-- A.Toovey -- S.Hill (Em: A. Rance & N.Suban)
M: G.Ablett-- S.Pendelburry -- S.Mitchell-- J.Sellwood-- A.Swallow -- D.Rich (Em: D.Beams & P. Dangerfield)
R: Hille -- K.Tippet (EM: M. Leunburger & J.Spencer)
F: Pavlich -- M.Richardson-- A.Didak-- J.Roughhead-- B.Fevola-- S.Higgins-- T.Hentschel (Em: J.Zibbell& J.grant)
I have 35K left

Will Suban, Spencer, Grant, Rance get game time threw most of em in as cheapys but would like to know there half decent.

Should I keep Ablett?

Was also thinking of getting rid of swallow + mitchell and getting cotchin + Boak but am worried I will have to many richmond players)

Any other thoughts??

N.Suban: He is a chance of playing in round 1 and play most of the year.

J.Spencer: He will probably play the first 8-10 games of the year because of M.Jamar being injured.

J.Grant: I wouldn't have him in my team you should go for S.Hogan or T.Walker.

A. Rance: A good chance of getting some game time over the year keep him.

I don't know with Ablett. 50/50

I would trade A.Swallow for H.Skipworth

 

[BIGANT]

Commented previously at top of page so not commenting again; then had to edit page Take two !!....

Backs; Goddard, Newman, Houli, Hill - Petrenko/Suban
Malceski, Houlihan, Raines

Mids; GA'J, J. Selwood, Masten - Rich/ Beams
Gibbs, Cousins, T. Tuck

Rucks; Hille, Jolly - White/Spencer

Forwards; Pavlich, Deledio, Giansiracusa, Yarran - M. Brown/Walker
J. Reiwoldt, Higgins, Skipworth

 

[nofeet]

Here is my current supercoach team for 2009.
Give me some advise on how I can make my team better.
Made some changes to my team
Got $8,000 left

 

[BIGANT]

Commented previously at top of page so not commenting again; then had to edit page Take two !!....

Backs; Goddard, Newman, Houli, Hill - Petrenko/Suban
Malceski, Houlihan, Raines

Mids; GA'J, J. Selwood, Masten - Rich/ Beams
Gibbs, Cousins, T. Tuck

Rucks; Hille, Jolly - White/Spencer

Forwards; Pavlich, Deledio, Giansiracusa, Yarran - M. Brown/Walker
J. Reiwoldt, Higgins, Skipworth

Feedback please....

 

[Wilso]

Looks fine BIGANT, not sold on Cousins but I'm not going to talk you out of it in this pre season of generic team after generic team.

Its good to have some different picks, and it's the different picks that make or break you

 

[TigerGlory]

Heres my latest attempt, thoughts?

 

[Ochre]

Heres my latest attempt, thoughts?

im wary on pav, freo reckon he'll play midfield this year and while he a very good mid, he aint a $593 000 one

johnson is also getting older and his scores'll probably drop imo

apart from that its pretty good

my team

still have $132700, thoughts on where to spend it

 

[reddahaydn1]

BIGANT

I dont agree with Wilso, I definately think cousins is worth it and he is definately cheap. i think your midfield is pretty much spot on, gibbs will kill it and t tuck should be really good value.
Rucks look good, i'm hoping spencer will get some early games and make some money.
Lot of younguns in our forward line, i dont think it's quite strong enough. Saying that I think that yarran, higgins and skipworth are all good buys and riewoldt should be good, but i think if your going to keep reiwoldt you need to upgrade maybe yarran to a 250k player, or higgins to a 320-350k player....or upgrade riewoldt to rioli. while cousins is good if u need the extra cash u could downgrade him to haselby as your midfield is pretty strong. rioli is expensive but being a second year he's only going to go up...he was born a gun!

NOFEET

comment on others teams please....

on the ground your team looks shit hot actually.
i think there may be better options for dawson, jacobs, walker and hogan on your bench tho....

here's mine after a few major changes...
any thoughts? suban or rance?

i have 23k left. i was thinking of upgrading gilbee to enright but i'm unsure if the ball is even going to get into geelongs backline while it might be in the doggies a fair bit? thoughts? he's 20k more for a av of 101 instead of 97...gilbee played 21 games, enright 22....seems worth it for 20k extra?

or i could use it to upgrade pav to riewoldt?

BACKS - Gilbee, Bock, C Cornes, J Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, S Hill (Suban, Petrenko)
MID - Ablett (C), Bartell (VC), Cross, Gibbs, Hasleby, D Rich (M Robinson, D Beams)
RUCKS - Hille, McIntosh (D Currie, J Spencer)
FORWARDS - Harvey, Pavlich, Delidio, Roughead, Higgins, Skipworth, Yarran (J Grant, M Brown)

Cheers Guys

 

[reddahaydn1]

im wary on pav, freo reckon he'll play midfield this year and while he a very good mid, he aint a $593 000 one

johnson is also getting older and his scores'll probably drop imo

apart from that its pretty good

my team

still have $132700, thoughts on where to spend it

selwood to bartell. fev to anyone else. or change either brown or delidio to reiwoldt.
or sandilands to cox although although i don't like spending huge money inthe ruck, get injured to much.
for that money you'd be close to ugrading butler to cousins...about 20k short....could u find it somewhere?

My team is in my comments above....

 

[the mighty T]

BACKS - Gilbee, Bock, C Cornes, J Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, S Hill (Suban, Petrenko)
MID - Ablett (C), Bartell (VC), Cross, Gibbs, Hasleby, D Rich (M Robinson, D Beams)
RUCKS - Hille, McIntosh (D Currie, J Spencer)
FORWARDS - Harvey, Pavlich, Delidio, Roughead, Higgins, Skipworth, Yarran (J Grant, M Brown)

Cheers Guys

bit of risk in that backline with adcock and malceski in the side, but i think they'll have bigger seasons this yeah ( thats why ive got adcock in my team )
i think the only things i would change is potentially ablett...i know hes a gun but justifying 700+K for one player is alot to spend when you consider you could downgrade to hodge and still save 100
The other is Yarran. A lot of hype about the boy but will he play round one + enough games to warrant beaing chosen in the first team?

otherwise i think its a good side, a lot like mine...very balanced

hope that helps

 

[reddahaydn1]

Thanks Mate. i thought that at the start about ablett but then decided to put him in anyway.
Think i'm going to keep him...he's being rested in the forward line and if i decide i want him in later it's probably going to take 2 trades, whereas if i have him and decide i dont want him at least i'll have spare money to trade in a rookie for a better player.

Any suggestions to trade yarran for? i'd have 170k to get someone else....

 

[Lids12]

BACKS - Gilbee, Bock, C Cornes, J Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, S Hill (Suban, Petrenko)
MID - Ablett (C), Bartell (VC), Cross, Gibbs, Hasleby, D Rich (M Robinson, D Beams)
RUCKS - Hille, McIntosh (D Currie, J Spencer)
FORWARDS - Harvey, Pavlich, Delidio, Roughead, Higgins, Skipworth, Yarran (J Grant, M Brown)

Cheers Guys

Strong defence, though i recommend maybe upgrading Bock to someone like Goddard in there, by downgrading Ablett, who i believe cannot go any further up. I am targeting him as an upgrade after a few bad rounds for my team.

Strong midfield too; i have already said what i needed to say bout Ablett. In your reserves, look at Liam Anthony

Like the ruck combination, exact same as mine

Nothin to criticise about your forwards; except i think there are better options than roughead.


Here's my team; again; as it still hasn't been commented on...
Need help with the players mentioned in bold.

Backs: Goddard, Fisher/Gilbee, C.Cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Raines, Hill
Suban Rance

Midfield: Judd, Dal Santo, Murphy, Selwood, Foley, Rich
Beams, Anthony

Rucks: Hille, McIntosh
Spencer, Currie

Forwards: Harvey, Deledio, Richo, T.Cloke, Higgins, Skipworth, Krakouer
Brown, Walker

I am not too sure between Fisher and Gilbee?
and
Harvey + Cloke
or
Franklin/O'Keefe/Goodwin/Chapman + Fevola

 

[reddahaydn1]

Thanks mate...which options would u suggest instead of roughy? I was thinking rioli for 60k less, 10pt/w average less, both second year players, both still gota lot of improving they will do.
Cheers abotu liam anthony too, everyone seems to have robinson so would be good to have something different.

On your team...looks good. very balanced. I think either fisher or gilbee are a good choice, as you can see i took gilbee. i've been looking at enright for 20k more as well but not sure.
i would look at trying to get dal santo up to bartell in the midfield if you don't want ablett....there's no denying geelong are going to get a lot of the ball, i would think at least one if their stars is a must.
i would stick with harvey and delidio in your forward line. not so sure about richo. I wouldnt be putting franklin and fev in the same team, if they both have a bad week it could take 200 points off the score you should have got and could cost u winning a game. they're both to inconsistant....one or the other but not both (thats only my opinion tho) I wouldnt get chapman either but goodwin would be a good choice, hows his price compared to cloke?
I think your other forwards are all going to do well...higgins and skipworth should improve well over the year so you can afford to only have 4 big names and make some more money on the younguns.
hope that helped mate

 

[johno_1989]

mate i rekon u need harvey back in the frwds dnt really like gia

if u dnt have the coin u cld turn ablett to bartel which is still pretyy good and get harvey back in ther

i like gibbs
u got balls 2 choose drummond (injury history)
apart from that cant fault u anywhere else

look to change yarran to ziebeill depending on team sheets but thats the only other decision u wld have to make

Cheers, yeah im not to confident about gia aswell he is a good consistent performer but doesn't rip the game apart. I only have 17k in the bank so gotta find the extra 80k to buy harves.

And LOL yeah drummond is a major risk but im taking my chances with him for the 1st time in 4years

pretty strong side. only real queries are gia and yarran. gia is underrated as a player but there are better sc option at that price maybe petrie or even downgrade him to fev or roughead to make som $$. also im not convinced with yarran hasnt been that good in the preseason but cant see many other options maybe ziebell.

my team is

Back: Hodge Drummond Adcock Malceski Houlihan Raines Hill (A.Rance, Suban)

Mids: Judd Selwood Foley Hasleby Reilly Rich (Anthony, Beams)

Rucks: Petrie Hille (Roughhead, Currie)

Forwards: N.Riewoldt Franklin N.Brown J.Brown Fev Higgins Skipworth (Sidebottom M.Brown(WC)
suggestion on maybe downgrading riweoldt to chappy/richo and then upgrading reilly to kade simpson or griffen? also other suggestions or help appreciated?

Cheers, Yeah yarren is a bit iffy for me. I'm looking at trading him out if his not picked round 1 for zeibell.

Since no one has anaylised your team, ill give you some feedback.

Great even team! There aren't really any faults in your team, its well balanced with cash cows and premuims. Only fault i see is reily - who im not really a fan of, but he can avg 80+ which is a great score for a player of his price. I'd do your suggestion, downgrade reiwoldt to chapman, upgrade riely to griffen, looks the goods this year.
Just goes to show, without ablett you get a much more even team! But i can't pull the trigger and let him go lol

 

[Carlton Kid]

Re: Post your team thread V.2 - if you dont comment, you dont get feedback

I';m thinking that this will be my final team subject to injury...

Backs: Goddard, Cornes, Drummond, Adcock, Malceski, Raines, Hil (Suban, Dawson)

Midfield: Ablett (c), Judd (vc), Selwood, Gibbs, Mackay, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, Sandilands (Graham, Jacobs)

Forwards: Pavlich, Deledio, Chapman, Houlihan, Higgins, Skipworth, Krackouer (Ziebell, Brown)

I think Goddard, Cornes and Drummond can hold the backloine together. Drummond is a risk I'm willing to take while Adcock may be able to get =back to his previous averages. In the mids Ablett, Judd, Selwood and Gibbs will score nicely. Mackay is someone that many people don't know about but he will average strong numbers this year. Cox and Sandilands are going to be the best two ruck this year and I want them early. Up forward Pav, Deledio and Chapman should bring in the points while Houlihan, Higgins, Skipwrth and Krackouer should increase to over $300,000 easily and in Houlihan's case $400,000.

I have just $2,500 left and I'm very pleased with this team. It should do well. Thoughts? Feedback, any is appreciated.

*Note: only reason I didn't review a team is that I reviewed quite a few a few pages back so thought that was enough...

 

[Pissi123]

Here's my team; again; as it still hasn't been commented on...
Need help with the players mentioned in bold.

Backs: Goddard, Fisher/Gilbee, C.Cornes, Drummond, Malceski, Raines, Hill
Suban Rance

Midfield: Judd, Dal Santo, Murphy, Selwood, Foley, Rich
Beams, Anthony

Rucks: Hille, McIntosh
Spencer, Currie

Forwards: Harvey, Deledio, Richo, T.Cloke, Higgins, Skipworth, Krakouer
Brown, Walker

I am not too sure between Fisher and Gilbee?
and
Harvey + Cloke
or
Franklin/O'Keefe/Goodwin/Chapman + Fevola

Good solid side. I would take Fisher in the back line because of his consistency.Chapman and Fevola i think is the best option there. Chappy should have a big season if he stays on the park. Dont know about Travis Cloke though. He is great to our forward line but has yet to have a huge season, could be his year.

my team

Not completely sure about Walker and don't know if Broughton will get too many games. Any help apreciated

 

[c judd 4 ever]

Good solid side. I would take Fisher in the back line because of his consistency.Chapman and Fevola i think is the best option there. Chappy should have a big season if he stays on the park. Dont know about Travis Cloke though. He is great to our forward line but has yet to have a huge season, could be his year.

my team

Not completely sure about Walker and don't know if Broughton will get too many games. Any help apreciated

very similar to my team. only differences are riewoldt walker raines and fisher.
i think fisher will have to play more defensive this year so will hurt his scores. walker fit is a gun and riewoldt is on the way up. good team overall.

heres mine, any help appreciated besides the risk of drummond lol, and the amount of carlton players.

b: goddard, scotland, cornes, drummond,houlihan, malceski, hill b)suban,petrenko

m:bartell,judd,selwood,gibbs,tuck,rich b)robinson,anthony

r cox,ottens b)spercer,graham

f pav,deledio,chapman,fevola,skipworth,higgins, hogan/brown/walker

cheers

 

[piggyboy]

heres mine, any help appreciated besides the risk of drummond lol, and the amount of carlton players.

b: goddard, scotland, cornes, drummond,houlihan, malceski, hill b)suban,petrenko

m:bartell,judd,selwood,gibbs,tuck,rich b)robinson,anthony

r cox,ottens b)spercer,graham

f pav,deledio,chapman,fevola,skipworth,higgins, hogan/brown/walker

cheers

not too bad a team cj4e. I'm not sure Hogan will play too much unless there are injuries. Maybe Grant instead? I like Spencer as a cash cow, he will play in the first half of the season.

Here is my team again - I posted it earlier without reading the guidelines on page 1 (my bad).It has taken a few edits to get to this team, but I'm fairly happy with it. Any comments would be appreciated

Gilbee, Bock, Cornes C, Adcock, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Hurley, Rance)

Ablett (c), Bartel, Cornes K, Gibbs, Hasleby, Rich (Anthony, Robinson)

Cox, Tippett (Vickery, Spencer)

Pavlich, Deledio, Lovett, Rioli, McKinley, Higgins, Krakouer (Walker, Grant)

$9400 remaining

still undecided on Ablett vs Judd or Selwood, and upgrade Bock with the difference. Also what about Rioli vs Osborne as both are about the same price

 

[UpTheGuts]

not too bad a team cj4e. I'm not sure Hogan will play too much unless there are injuries. Maybe Grant instead? I like Spencer as a cash cow, he will play in the first half of the season.

Here is my team again - I posted it earlier without reading the guidelines on page 1 (my bad).It has taken a few edits to get to this team, but I'm fairly happy with it. Any comments would be appreciated

Gilbee, Bock, Cornes C, Adcock, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Hurley, Rance)

Ablett (c), Bartel, Cornes K, Gibbs, Hasleby, Rich (Anthony, Robinson)

Cox, Tippett (Vickery, Spencer)

Pavlich, Deledio, Lovett, Rioli, McKinley, Higgins, Krakouer (Walker, Grant)

$9400 remaining

still undecided on Ablett vs Judd or Selwood, and upgrade Bock with the difference. Also what about Rioli vs Osborne as both are about the same price

I just think Vickery is a waste of $. Graham, or S Jacobs... use this $ to upgrade mckinley

 

[OzBomber]

Bit of bias I know. I could probably sack Fletcher.

 

[sirlothie]

Not having Dean Cox is a huge risk because he will undoubtedly again be the runaway dominant ruckman in the comp, so by not having him in you are immediately chasing lost ground.

Zac Dawson is cheap and will play but he won't be chasing kicks he will be just wearing somebody else like a blanket so therefore his potential upside is extremely limited. I would go with a rookie defender who is more likely to win more of the ball.

This is my team I am still tinkering with:

Backs:

Hodge, Adcock, Hunter, Malceski, Myers, Houlihan, Raines (Hill, Suban)

Mids:

K. Cornes, Cousins, Griffen, Cotchin, Hasleby, Masten (Rich, Beams)

Rucks:

Cox, Ottens (Currie, Graham)

Forwards:

Riewoldt, Pavlich, Didak, McKinley, J. Anthony, Higgins, Hentschel (Skipworth, Ziebell)



Comments?

 

[Frazenoast]

SEAN

Do you follow football at all????

Presti - NO

Hurley - Injured

McVeigh - might not start round 1

U might want to put somebody in ur backline (Reserves) and make them an emergency rather then having 2 in the forwardline

I really think you should rethink your team, u need to start from scratch again...