POTY Votes - Round 20 vs. Brisbane Lions

[SouthSwans]

5. Goodes
4. Mathews
3. Barlow
2. J Bolton
1. Fosdike

 

[s2 Swans Dragons]

5. Goodes
4. Barlow
3. Buchanan
2. Fosdike
1. Jude Bolton

 

[swantastic]

5. Goodes
4. B1
3. Fossie
2. Captain
1. Cheese

 

[grimlock]

5 - Goodes
4 - Barlow
3 - Kirk
2 - CBolton
1 - Richards

 

[Footylover1]

My votes went goes to:

5: Adam Goodes
4: Eddie Barlow
3: Craig Bolton
2: Nick Malceski
1: Amon Buchanan

 

[Skystyler]

5. Goodes
4. Bolton, C
3. Barlow
2. Bolton, J
1. Matthews

 

[CAS79]

5: A Goodes
4 J Bolton
3 C Bolton
2 N Malceski
A Buchanen


Mentions to

T.Richards,
E Barlow Great debut
A Shneider .. when he had the ball he looked like creating something and
Luke Brennen who in my opinion played his best game for us last night.

 

[grimlock]

I'm sorry but I think Malceski was horrible last night. Granted Brisbane applied terrific pressure all game, but it was a terrible game from the Eski.

 

[Jeffers]

It was a horrible game from Eski. Didn't deserve any votes IMO. But i have a feeling he'll be in the votes for the next 5 or so weeks

Mine from this depressing draw.

5. Goodes
4. CHEESE!
3. Fosidke
2. C Bolts
1. Captain Kirk

Hall would of gotten high votes if he didn't keep ****ing missing.

 

[Tuco]

Wow. Very hard to pick this time.

5. Goodes
4. C. Bolton
3. Jude
2. Fosdike (but wow did he have some clangers!)
1. Ed Barlow - because he made the night a little less painful an experience)

 

[Corpuscles]

5. A Goodes
4. C Bolton
3. T Richards
2. J Bolton
1. A Buchanan


Hon: Barlow and the rest

 

[natlovestheswans]

Hm, i don't know. This round it's verryy hard!

5. Goodes
4. Fosdike
3. Barlow
2. J. Bolton
1. Richards

 

[Here It Is]

Each to their own opinion, but why is everyone voting for Goodes so high?
He got better as the night went on but I reckon he couldn't hit a target by hand or foot for at least half of it.

5. J. Bolton
4. E. Barlow
3. A. Buchanan
2. P. Bevan - yes, one and the same. Did a great job on J. Brennan.
1. L. Brennan

 

[Tuco]

Each to their own opinion, but why is everyone voting for Goodes so high?
He got better as the night went on but I reckon he couldn't hit a target by hand or foot for at least half of it.

5. J. Bolton
4. E. Barlow
3. A. Buchanan
2. P. Bevan - yes, one and the same. Did a great job on J. Brennan.
1. L. Brennan

Not sure. I guess he just presented and demanded the footy so much. But I think that's the difficuty of voting for such a dire game. For example Amon and Bevan who you voted for had their effective disposal woes as well. No one really had an error free night.

 

[Footylover1]

Each to their own opinion, but why is everyone voting for Goodes so high?
He got better as the night went on but I reckon he couldn't hit a target by hand or foot for at least half of it.

5. J. Bolton
4. E. Barlow
3. A. Buchanan
2. P. Bevan - yes, one and the same. Did a great job on J. Brennan.
1. L. Brennan

Why didn't you even give him one vote for? Clearly he was best on ground. In the HUN they gave him 4 votes.

 

[natlovestheswans]

Each to their own opinion, but why is everyone voting for Goodes so high?
He got better as the night went on but I reckon he couldn't hit a target by hand or foot for at least half of it.

Whilst you don't know why we rated him so highly, i don't see how you couldn't give him even a single vote.

Adam Goodes was the only Swans player to make the team of the week on the AFL website.

http://www.afl.com.au/Default.aspx?tabid=208&newsId=49449

Adam Goodes (Sydney) – Sydney's best player in its draw against the Brisbane Lions, Goodes continued his fine second half of the season with 28 disposals – including a game-high 11 contested possessions – and seven clearances.

 

[Footylover1]

Whilst you don't know why we rated him so highly, i don't see how you couldn't give him even a single vote.

Adam Goodes was the only Swans player to make the team of the week on the AFL website.

http://www.afl.com.au/Default.aspx?tabid=208&newsId=49449

Goodes, made my team of the week. Him and Craig Bolton did I think.

 

[Here It Is]

As I said, each to their own, and I respect your opinions. It was just the numerous errors he made in the first half that really seemed to stick in my mind. I did consider him for a vote but maybe I just marked him too harshly for what he's capable of.
Point taken, and he'll still get five votes in this award. Fair enough.

I compare Goodes' game to the one played by Judd in the 05 grand final when he got a heap of the ball, stuffed a lot of it up, and was given the Norm Smith Medal when we all knew he didn't deserve it.

 

[Footylover1]

As I said, each to their own, and I respect your opinions. It was just the numerous errors he made in the first half that really seemed to stick in my mind. I did consider him for a vote but maybe I just marked him too harshly for what he's capable of.
Point taken, and he'll still get five votes in this award. Fair enough.

I compare Goodes' game to the one played by Judd in the 05 grand final when he got a heap of the ball, stuffed a lot of it up, and was given the Norm Smith Medal when we all knew he didn't deserve it.

Yeah agree, Judd only got that award because he's a media darling. Nic Fosdike should have been the worthy winner.

 

[SouthSwans]

Yeah agree, Judd only got that award because he's a media darling. Nic Fosdike should have been the worthy winner.

LRT.

 

[Footylover1]

LRT.

Either one of them should have got it ahead of the media darling Judd.

 

[J-swan]

5. Goodesy
4. B2
3. Fozzie
2. SuperTed
1. Cheese

 

[is2SWaNz]

I can't even remember how the game went. It's all just a blur now...

5. Goodes
4. Fosdike
3. J.Bolton (I thought he was pretty good...)
2. Barlow
1. C.Bolton (although Brown kicked that goal, he was still pretty good)

Honourable mentions to Kirk and Hall. When Kirk kicked that goal, I thought we'd won it. And as for Hall, he's in good form and only the accuracy was a problem. He made some goal assists.

Buchanan and Teddy too.

 

[liz]

I normally try to watch a replay before voting but haven't had the chance this week. So from memory

5 Goodes
4 Craig B
3 Mathews
2 Cheese
1 Kirk

 

[SouthSwans]

Round of voting completed.

70 Goodes
36 Barlow
32 C Bolton
28 J Bolton
22 Fosdike
8 Mathews
9 Buchanan
2 Malceski
7 Kirk
7 Richards
2 Bevan
1 Brennan