Power votes

[lamby29]

I stopped watching shortly after half time.

******** effort.

3 - White: Only average.

2 - Rivers: Meh.

1 - Brown: A few effective kicks. Otherwise poor.

I refuse to give Bruce a vote because of ********house kicking around goal.

Our inaccuracy could hurt us come September.

 

[melbournemartin]

i only was able to listen 2 it on the radio but from wat i heard lade killed white in the ruck and it did sound like that

3 - Brown, probably the only player who didnt play a bad game but ya cant win games with only ya half back flanker standing up

2 - in contradiction to my previous vote, i think that James McDonald had a good game so ill give him 2 votes

1 - Bruce but gee man he needs to kicks straight, normally a beuatiful kick on the run and from set shot

 

[Ben_Asgari]

3. Brown
2. Bruce
1. Junior

Lets just try and forget about it and concentrate on next week.

 

[StingaArmstrong]

3 - White
2 - Brown
1 - McDonald

I think this was our worst game of the year considering how important it was. There was an abundance of softness, Port went in and got the hard ball. They absolutely smashed us close in, both in tackles and getting the ball out effortlessly from clearances. And Cam Bruce gave me the sh*ts, for someone with so much talent, he dropped several marks where he was the only person to get hands on the ball and his kicking was terrible. His technique falls away under pressure as its too much of a drop between hand and foot.

I'm still frustrated by ND's lack of reactivity when things are going badly, why not put Neitz in defence to slow the tide. Why not put Bizz at full forward. Why start Wheatley, our best defender this up forward. ND is great when things are going well but ordinary when they aren't.

Sorry to put so much in and be so critical, but the performance that we put up today was that of a bottom four team not a top four team. Of course Port played very well, but we were awful.

 

[melbournemartin]

we realli need to silence some new critics by winning the next 3 games and going into september with some real momentum

 

[Asgardian]

3 - White
2 - Brown
1 - McDonald

Sorry about questioning your votes, but how on earth could you give White your best player votes?

In my ever so nowhere near humble opinion, Lade absolutely belted White in the ruck, and around the ground.

 

[StingaArmstrong]

Sorry about questioning your votes, but how on earth could you give White your best player votes?

In my ever so nowhere near humble opinion, Lade absolutely belted White in the ruck, and around the ground.

I dont think lade pumped White, but Whites taps were well roved by the Power midfielder. White did alright around the ground. In true fairness, i dont think anyone deserved a vote.

 

[Deestroy]

...

 

[Supermercado]

0 votes x 22 players

 

[demon21]

3- Brown
2- Mcdonald
1- Bruce

 

[BT]

3 - Brown

2 - Macca

1 - Rivers

So forgettable, I've forgotten it!

 

[BT]

Brown 15
McDonald 8
White 6
Bruce 4
Rivers 2


3 - Brown

2 - McDonald

1 - White

One last comment on the White debate, yeah Lade pantsed him but if beating your opponent counted we'd have all done a Supermercado. He tried all day & really suffers from having to compete with the extremely high standards he's set all year.

Was he in Melbourne's best 3? Bigfooty.com says yes!

Leaderboard updated very soon.