Prelim Final

[hotpie]

My selection tips:

In: Holland, Betheras (or possibly Davis)
Out: Walker, Williams

Great return by Presti makes Walker redundant. Williams has to go.

And Holland is an automatic selection. The only other question is who else comes in - I would prefer Rupe who can play inside or also can play the receiver role, but it will depend on matchups and on Willy form.

 

[Zeke]

I agree that Williams must be dropped, and Dutchy is an automatic selection...

I think Walker could be a chance to hold his spot, he did a few good things last night. I actually don't think he knows what a physical presence he could be in a game of footy - when he does, look out.

I can't see that Betheras could add anything to the mxi that is currently missing.

 

[Babylove]

Holland will come in.

I think it could be for Ben Kinnear who didn't play well.

 

[guess_who]

Holland will come in for...BK or Walker...
Williams will not be dropped...

 

[Nic]

I'd like to see Holland in, Williams out, but it won't happen. Walker or Kinnear will be the unlucky bloke to go.

 

[Cyclops]

Too soon to call, Lokan has lost form and Williams is droppable, but Malthouse shows lots of faith in winning teams. We really have to wait and see who gets up-we might stay with the extra height if we face a Fletcher-less Bombers, but more pace vs Port.

I'd love little Leon to bob up, and maybe Rupes too, but why change the winning combination? Holland will cetainly press for a spot, though.

 

[guess_who]

I don't think that there will be any changes unless they are forced with the exeption of Holland in for Bk or Walker

 

[Lockyer24]

agree with hotpies in's and out's.

 

[Joel]

Walker won't go out. He is there as back up for Fraser (in case injury occurs).

 

[guess_who]

Yes but how many back up's do you want, Rocca spends more time in the ruck than Walker does

 

[Joel]

He will stay. If Rocca goes into the ruck, it takes away our CHF.

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

If it's Port we are up against:

IN: Holland, McKee
OUT: Williams, Walker

If it is Essendon,

IN: Holland
OUT: Williams

 

[McGough27]

I think it will be -

In - Holland
Out - Kinnear

 

[Knowledge]

OUT; Kinnear, Williams
IN: Holland and Neon Leon (hopefully) prob not maybe cam cloke

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by McGough27
I think it will be -

In - Holland
Out - Kinnear

I think your spot on.....

 

[brentoncowell]

Time to stop following the crowd Guess_who. Why does Holland deserve an automatic recall? he has had some good games this year but he has been suspended twice, both for stupid acts. I like him he will be crucial in a tagging role. I see no real place for Cole and Williams. Kinnear and Tex should hold their spot to add height, especially against essendon. I really think McKee should come back, but he doesnt deserve it.

 

[Jabso]

Cole was great against Brisbane. Smashed McGrath and his run out of defence was a feature, he gathered 9 rebounds from 50.
Williams should be dropped but may be kept to do some sort of role. Lokan does a role effectively every week I think. Walker must be in our side as he can go back, forward or in the ruck. If Essendon make it with Fletcher possibly suspended Walker will stretch out the Essendon defence. Players such as Wellman, McPhee and Jacobs will be made accountable.

 

[JLC]

Holland has to play imo. When Holland plays he can free up Licuria to become a more attacking midfielder. Holland can also go up forward as a crumber which is an area that we are deficient in.

I would drop Williams. Walker shouldnt be dropped as he has become a somewhat flexible player and has a big body that can inflict some serious damage to opponents.

jlc

 

[brentoncowell]

Brodie Holland, i beleive that he is behind Licuria's poor form, or form slump. Holland playing a bigger role has dampened Licuria's position as a key midfeilder/tagger. Its great to see Brodie playing well but even against Brisbane i saw Licca do some running through the middle and ball movement which he has lacked in the second half. He was also more antogonising and the pic in the sun with Pike is a perfect example.

 

[Nic]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
Why does Holland deserve an automatic recall?

Because, atm he's in our best 22. Before Kinnear, Williams and Walker. Probably several others, too.

 

[hotpie]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
Brodie Holland, i beleive that he is behind Licuria's poor form, or form slump.

Crap

Its a cop out to blame somebody's poor form on somebody elses good form. In any case Licuria hasn't been that bad anyway.

 

[Murray]

In: Holland
Out: The Dud

 

[Whisky_McKay]

Holland maybe for Williams or Kinnear

 

[FIGJAM]

To anyone even remotely considering Leon Davis...GET SOME PERSPECTIVE!

I'd rather Freeborn back in, and that's saying something!!

Williams for Holland is the obvious one. Walker for McKee if we're playing against Primus.

 

[The Scarecrow]

In: Holland
Out: Kinnear.

I don't think Walker will be dropped, and I really don't think that Cam Cloke will be called up, maybe emergency again.