REAL best player

[Richo83]

As it follows.

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Yes, I agree!!!

 

[demondavey]

Ok, its very hard to determine who is the best player. I dont think there is a best player, but honestly i reckon the most influential is probably pavlich, hodge or swan. This season anyway

 

[Donakebab]

Polls board.

 

[Brad Roo]

Sandilands.

You get someone to spoon feed your midfielders, a clearance machine and someone that can go forward and kick a goal.

If he played for Geelong they would never lose a game.

 

[theboxmike]

Jobe Watson Seriously i think he should be in the top 10

Luke Hodge ATM IMO

 

[CatFan79]

Pointless thread where people will only vote for whoever plays for their team..

 

[Donakebab]

Does best player mean the best individual, the most influential, the most important to their team? Too vague.

 

[Power King]

Ablett the best midfielder.

Franklin the best forward.

Pavlich overall, maybe.

 

[Power King]

Over the past few seasons, I'd say it's something like this in my opinion:

2004: Tredrea
2005: Cousins
2006: Judd
2007: Ablett > Cornes/Harvey
2008: Franklin > Ablett > Cooney
2009: Ablett > Riewoldt (edit: this is very close though)

Pavlich has been amongst the elite the whole time though

Brownlow means shit in my opinion; it is the collective opinion of umpires on midfielders. Pre-Brownlow hype is more accurate.

 

[neng]

Hodge. Will play any role handed to him, carried Hawthorn at the start of the season, now he is reaping the rewards

 

[AG]

How many of these threads are there?

I choose Riewoldt again. He's a freak. Ablett and the other key forwards next in line.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Spangher

 

[Hodgepodge]

Hodge this season.

Was carrying the entire team for the first half of the season, is 2010's MVP

 

[brjafi]

M. Boyd

 

[DeZi]

Good midfielders are there in every team...but a KPP that can dominate like Riewoldt? Not many...

 

[fitzroy_lions123]

Simon Black

 

[Power King]

Good midfielders are there in every team...but a KPP that can dominate like Riewoldt? Not many...

Based on 2010 though, Riewoldt gets excluded by default because of how much footy he has missed out on.

Simon Black

Career-wise, yes.

 

[Cynic]

After Sylvia wins the Brownlow you'll all change your tune.

 

[DeZi]

Based on 2010 though, Riewoldt gets excluded by default because of how much footy he has missed out on.

REAL Best Player or best player of 2010? If its this year then Hodge all the way

 

[wce4premiership]

Hodge this year and right now. He's just a footballer, pure genius sometimes.

 

[Patch Adams]

Brent Harvey

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Franklin is easily the best player when he's "on". He just rips teams apart that bloke and if I could pick 1 player from any other club it would be him.

The best forwards are him and Riewoldt with Pav and Brown just behind. Pavlich is the best all-round footballer of the group though.

Best mids are Hodge, Swan and Ablett.

Goodes, Goddard and Pavlich are the best utilities.

You have Sandilands with the rucks and probably Scarlett in the backs.

 

[weagles_fan]

This season - Hodge
Over the last 3 years - Ablett
Over the last 10 years - Judd

Therefore it comes down to opinion. IMO Ablett is the best.

 

[Donakebab]

This season - Hodge
Over the last 3 years - Ablett
Over the last 10 years - Judd

Therefore it comes down to opinion. IMO Ablett is the best.

Last 10 years Black shits it in.