- Joined
- Jun 17, 2008
- Posts
- 10,766
- Reaction score
- 10,078
- Location
- East Falafel Town
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Norwood
Can the Swans include the Phil Hughes transfer as part of the Tippett deal?
only if you also throw in Watson, Cummins and Starc

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Can the Swans include the Phil Hughes transfer as part of the Tippett deal?

You can have Watson! Sure, good cricketer, but damn he has to have the worst facial expressions in Australian cricket. The bloke looks like he's permanently sucking on lemonsonly if you also throw in Watson, Cummins and Starc![]()
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Unfair. He carried our one-day team for a couple of years. Good player. Bad gut. Should have been retained.Except he wasn't, and Fats McLardington was costing us further in the field.
He's basically our Leigh Brown. Or Des Headland in reverse. Looks pretty flash when he rolls his giant arse out onto the ground with a good team doing all the hard work, but strains under the extra weight when he has to do it himself.
The system has been stuffed for many years. Even as a 14 year old playing state cricket, I could tell that there were a lot of problems and they were doing a lot wrong.No, Haberfield's from Qld.
If we include Kane Richardson, our 12th man, it makes 3.
Something's got to change & it has to start at the grade level.
You raise some very good points there, especially about the training focus. A particular NSW quick, who was a member of one of the early intakes of the AIS (& therefore playing for an Adelaide grade team) has told me exactly the same thing. It killed him. One of the best left arm quicks of his generation was overbowled & as a result suffered stress fractures to his spine that hindered him for the rest of his disappointingly short career.The system has been stuffed for many years. Even as a 14 year old playing state cricket, I could tell that there were a lot of problems and they were doing a lot wrong.
For a start if you were a bowler you did nothing but bowl the entire training. Not once did we practice our batting. Luckily I was an opening batsman at club level and got plenty of practice there. But they wonder why SA hasnt had a half-decent allrounder in 15 years. Secondly they picked players on reputation and technique...not on actual ability to score runs. One of the guys that missed out on the squad scored hundred after hundred at club level, and made some big runs in the trial games but becuase he was a bit of a clobberer and didnt quite get his foot far enough across on off drives he missed out. Look at Darren Lehmann. Was one of the best drives going around but his front foot was barely ever near the ball.
That wasn't Craig Bradbrook, was it?One of the guys that missed out on the squad scored hundred after hundred at club level, and made some big runs in the trial games but becuase he was a bit of a clobberer and didnt quite get his foot far enough across on off drives he missed out. Look at Darren Lehmann. Was one of the best drives going around but his front foot was barely ever near the ball.


Well they actually won a shield match :O
1st win in 20 games, so around 2 years agoWow... can't remember the last time the Redbacks took outright points!

Anyway, well done to the lads for a great result.