Reiwoldt the right captain?

[tigerT]

Are the saints well served having the young and inexperienced and some might say immature reiwoldt as captain? or would they have been better appointing someone else?

 

[noodle]

hammil is the man.

 

[Marns]

Yeah, the saints made a big mistake by removing Hamill as captain, I remember he had a great year that year. Riewoldt is good, but is only young and I think should've been let focus on his game for a year or more, then once he's one a brownlow or two give him the captaincy.

 

[ManWithNoName]

No, make Hamill captain, he relishes the role. His performances improved when he was captain, Riewoldt is just too young to captain an AFL side.

Why is there two threads with excatly the same poll?

 

[Sealen]

I agree. Hammil was a good captain for the Saints.

 

[Awesome_Wells]

Reiwoldt or Hamil?