Richmond Phantom Trading Thread

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
Tredrea & pick 5 for Chris Judd & Pick 11.

or

Tredrea & Pick 13 for Ben Cousins

Tredrea isn't up for grabs.

If rfc deal falls through how about picks 5,15 & B.Holland for Cousins

 

[NUCKLE]

Tiger Army

Can you please post a list of all trades that have occured to this time. I am aware that this may take some time but it would make life easier 'cause team managers would know where players are.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
Tiger Army

Can you please post a list of all trades that have occured to this time. I am aware that this may take some time but it would make life easier 'cause team managers would know where players are.

gimmy 20 minutes..

please dont trade for the moment.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by dascman03
Sorry mate, I dont rate him that highly enough that I would give up Dal Santo or a player of similar quality, have a look at my untouchables list. Its a few pages back. My final offer on the matter is...

Matera ---->St Kilda. Milne, Schwarze, pick #23 ------> West Coast.

You got a deal.

Matera to St. Kilda


Milne, Schwarze & Pick 23 to West Coast.

 

[mighty tiges]

Port Adelaide trades - mighty tiges

Salopek to Ess for Bolton
Pickett and Cochrane to Richmond for Bowden and Holland
N.Stevens to Melbourne for pick #5
M.Primus and pick 29 to Collingwood for Prestigiacomo and pick 13
Guerra, White and Poulton to Roos for Motlop and pick 39

 

[dascman03]

hey brad-clare, what do you want for Jon Hay? This is my offer

Pick #8, Wulf-----> Hawthorn
Hay ----> St Kilda

If accepted, I may not accept straight away because of my pending trade with Adelaide involving the same pick. I would prefer the trade with Adelaide, but would be delighted if this is accepted. But its only a fallback for now.

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
Tredrea isn't up for grabs.

If rfc deal falls through how about picks 5,15 & B.Holland for Cousins

pick 5, pick 13 & Lade for Cousins and the West Coast Eagles may do you a deal.

West Coast holds off on deals awaiting a summary of done deals. But floats this deal to Port Adelaide awaiting a reply.

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
pick 5, pick 13 & Lade for Cousins and the West Coast Eagles may do you a deal.

West Coast holds off on deals awaiting a summary of done deals. But floats this deal to Port Adelaide awaiting a reply.

Port have already have traded away a ruckman (Primus) so Brogan is untouchable and Lade and most likely Ackland aren't up for trade at this stage.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Adelaide- sante2003
Brisbane- tiger of old
Carlton- waspy
Collingwood- GhostofJimJess
Essendon- Showbag
Fremantle- Presi_is_god
Hawthorn- Brad-clare
North- Russian
Melbourne- magpie_junior9
Port- mighty tiges
Richmond- rfctigerarmy
St Kilda- dascman03
West Coast- nuckles
Western Bulldogs- Tank

Richmond D.Solomon + J.Johnson ---> Richmond, B.Ottens + #21 ---> Essendon

PA- Steven Salopek <---> Essendon Bolton

Pickett + Cochrane ---> Richmond, Bowden + Holland ---> Port

T.Notting ---> Richmond, Fiora + #36 ---> Brisbane

Brown for Power & Bradshaw + pick 19

Stevens for pick 5 (Melb)

Presti_is_god - Trent croad + Pick #26 for Jade Rawlings and Nathan Lonie - brad-clare

Daniel Giansiracusa for Salopek

Polak for #4, Gilbee and Eagleton

M.Primus + Pick 29 -> Collingwood; Prestigiacomo + Pick 15 -> Port

Hall + 4th Round (52 I think) <---> Sinclair

shattock for mcgrath (Rich).

pick 23, Baird & Harding for ox & Sampi

Guerra, White & Poulton for Motlop & Pick 39

#23 for Zantuck

Matera to St. Kilda for Milne, Schwarze & Pick 23 to West Coast.

Thats what I got but Im pretty sure there are more..

 

[NUCKLE]

West Coast want pick 5, pick 13 and a Key Position Forward to even consider trading Ben Cousins.

If Port Adelaide can not come up with a key forward maybe a three way deal is required.

Perhaps can I suggest something like the following

Pick 13 to Richmond
Pick 5, Pick 15 & Richardson to West Coast
Pick 11 and Cousins to Port Adelaide.

 

[NUCKLE]

rfctigerarmy

for the AFL's fax machine or your records.

St.Kilda traded Milne, Schwarze & Pick 23 to West Coast Phil Matera.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Richmond's Trades

[ tiger of old ] T.Notting ---> Richmond, Fiora + #36 ---> Brisbane
[ Showbag ] D.Solomon + J.Johnson ---> Richmond, B.Ottens + #21 ---> Essendon
[ mighty tiges ] Pickett + Cochrane ---> Richmond, Bowden + Holland ---> Port
[ tiger of old ] A.Shattock ---> Richmond, M.McGrath ---> Brisbane
[ Nuckles ] #23 ---> Richmond, Zantuck ---> West Coast

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
rfctigerarmy

for the AFL's fax machine or your records.

St.Kilda traded Milne, Schwarze & Pick 23 to West Coast Phil Matera.

its there..

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
its there..

St. Kilda traded pick 23 back to the West Coast Eagles. I thought Richmond must have done a deal with St. Kilda.

WCE acquired this pick from north and traded it ro Richmond but got it back with a deal that saw Matera go to St.Kilda.

how can this work?

 

[NUCKLE]

Originally posted by NUCKLE


Pick 13 to Richmond
Pick 5, Pick 15 & Richardson to West Coast
Pick 11 and Cousins to Port Adelaide.

West Coast is becoming inpatient and want to move this trade soon because a new Captain will have to be appointed if the trade goes ahead.

West Coast again approaches Port Adelaide to start the deal moving.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
St. Kilda traded pick 23 back to the West Coast Eagles. I thought Richmond must have done a deal with St. Kilda.

WCE acquired this pick from north and traded it ro Richmond but got it back with a deal that saw Matera go to St.Kilda.

how can this work?

Wouldnt have a clue.. I havent done a deal with the Saints so its them who are in the wrong.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
West Coast is becoming inpatient and want to move this trade soon because a new Captain will have to be appointed if the trade goes ahead.

West Coast again approaches Port Adelaide to start the deal moving.

Richmond want more then #13 for Richardson... KPP and 2nd round.

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by NUCKLE
West Coast is becoming inpatient and want to move this trade soon because a new Captain will have to be appointed if the trade goes ahead.

West Coast again approaches Port Adelaide to start the deal moving.

I will accept if rfc agrees.

 

[dascman03]

There was a mix up with draft picks, the Matera deal was my first, so this is definitely mine, the KAngaroos second round pick is pick 25, mines 23!!!!
West Coast own pick 23

 

[NUCKLE]

Calling St. Kilda:

St. Kilda manager start listening

What draft pick did you give the WCE for the deal that saw Matera become a saint.

It was your second round pick in the 20's but what bloody number was it 'cause their appears to be an issue with the trade.

 

[NUCKLE]

So the Weagles have #23 & Richmond have #25.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by dascman03
There was a mix up with draft picks, the Matera deal was my first, so this is definitely mine, the KAngaroos second round pick is pick 25, mines 23!!!!
West Coast own pick 23

So I (Richmond) owns #25?

gotcha

BUT... I still thought I had #4 as that is my first round pick yet it was traded?!?

 

[dascman03]

Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
Wouldnt have a clue.. I havent done a deal with the Saints so its them who are in the wrong.

There was a mixup at the start. I have always had pick 23, Richmond have 21, Geelong 22, St Kilda 23, Hawthorn 24, Kangaroos 25. So its pick 25, NOT 23, thats been ontraded over and over.

 

[NUCKLE]

Stuffed if I know how that works. It looks like North Melbourne are as bad at trading in the phantom trade as they are in the actual trade period.

Anywonder they could not secure Rawlings. They were offering other clubs picks.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Originally posted by mighty tiges
I will accept if rfc agrees.

Richmond feel that without Matthew Richardson they will be short and without a KPP. Richmond have stated that they want a 2nd round pick + A KPP.