Round 1 discussion

[Dark Sharks]

EAD Shaw owners, yeeeeeew.

 

[SSSSSS]

Standbyshaw

 

[AngryRanga]

Gawn gassed out completely.

 

[TheOz]

MELBOURNE
PLAYER
SUPERCOACH
35 Ben Kennedy 108
1 Jesse Hogan 103
25 Tom McDonald 103
7 Jack Viney 99
23 Bernie Vince 95
11 Max Gawn 93
4 Jack Watts 90
45 Matt Jones 84
2 Nathan Jones 84
16 Dean Kent 72
13 Clayton Oliver 70
36 Jeff Garlett 70
39 Neville Jetta 67
37 Aaron Vandenberg 66
3 Christian Salem 65
12 Dom Tyson 58
21 Cameron Pedersen 57
20 Colin Garland 54
43 James Harmes 46
32 Tomas Bugg 39
28 Oscar McDonald 30
17 Sam Frost 16
TOTAL
1569

GWS
PLAYER
SUPERCOACH
8 Callan Ward 134
37 Rory Lobb 97
5 Dylan Shiel 96
34 Caleb Marchbank 91
1 Phil Davis 90
17 Steve Johnson 90
9 Tom Scully 88
23 Heath Shaw 84
16 Nathan Wilson 83
22 Josh Kelly 77
32 Ryan Griffen 76
6 Lachie Whitfield 71
10 Devon Smith 69
41 Shane Mumford 65
7 Rhys Palmer 61
40 Adam Kennedy 53
35 Aidan Corr 52
21 Matt Buntine 51
4 Toby Greene 48
11 Jack Steele 47
20 Adam Tomlinson 42
36 James Stewart 10
TOTAL
157

 

[gutsroy]

How's McDonald (Tom) going? Sounds like BenKen is going well, good to see him getting a shot, never really got a consistent run at it with us (also due to injury / illness), often the sub.

 

[reload141]

EAD Shaw owners, yeeeeeew.

Top 3 defender lock all year round, not worried. Thanks.

 

[SSSSSS]

EAD Shaw owners.

Couldn't have played any worse and still will score 90 odd.

 

[Souup]

Top 3 defender lock all year round, not worried. Thanks.

No one's doubting that. The issue for Shaw owners is he just scored 30 points less than his price. Those without him will eventually bring him in at a cheaper price.

 

[Double the Fist]

Nobody ever understands what I mean

Watson second = play on words from A&C's Who's on first routine. It also appear Jobe is no longer the winner of 2012 Brownlow.

As far as scoring a lot, I'm pretty confident of going top 200k this year. My SC Rd 23 review email last year just said "You're shit". Thanks SC.

Jesus, if you want competition, look elsewhere!

 

[Captain Harley]

How's McDonald (Tom) going? Sounds like BenKen is going well, good to see him getting a shot, never really got a consistent run at it with us (also due to injury / illness), often the sub.

And after he plays Essendon next week, BenKen ownership will reach Kerridge levels!

McDonald did his scoring q2 and q4, awfully quiet in the third

 

[Charlemagne]

**** sake, Kolo. I guess I've got 20 minutes to choose a player I've never considered so far to take a punt on.

 

[Chasing_Cars]

So two games down and the total hit out numbers are very low. A bit of a worry for all rucks.

 

[Raveneyes]

No one's doubting that. The issue for Shaw owners is he just scored 30 points less than his price. Those without him will eventually bring him in at a cheaper price.

We're all doing that with other players anyway.

 

[Souup]

Couldn't have played any worse and still will score 90 odd.

He also had 30 touches to drown out those clangers. He had a bad game in the sense that he had 8 clangers, but he also had 30 touches which he only did twice last year. But I'm sure Shaw owners will continue to justify his game.

 

[TheOz]

String of ladies lining up for Oliver after this one, what a handsome young stud!

 

[reload141]

No one's doubting that. The issue for Shaw owners is he just scored 30 points less than his price. Those without him will eventually bring him in at a cheaper price.

Correct and i'll pick up another defender later on who will fall, i don't get the big deal.

 

[SSSSSS]

No one's doubting that. The issue for Shaw owners is he just scored 30 points less than his price. Those without him will eventually bring him in at a cheaper price.

That's true but you have to factor in how much a trade is worth in the grand scheme of things.

I'd take losing 50k-80k for keeping an extra trade.

 

[TheOz]

So two games down and the total hit out numbers are very low. A bit of a worry for all rucks.

Goldy will fix that.

 

[madman]

Still round 1, won't be too worried about Shaw.

 

[vast]

Ward will be a good POD this year.

Shaw abit like Dusty disspointing but everyone has them. Both still got plenty of the ball and if they play everygame a good chance to finish first in their position.

Oliver, awesome first half faded but at least now his JS looks pretty solid and seems capable of actually scoring 100s.

 

[gutsroy]

Callan Ward proving once and for all the power of the man bun (no vision, no idea how he's actually wearing it), Tom Mc solid, looks like the Ginger Ninja was again solid, good on him, like the way he plays.

 

[evo]

BenKen with the E on him Least he's in my side!

yeah i did that too. Cant loophole him. doh

 

[Souup]

That's true but you have to factor in how much a trade is worth in the grand scheme of things.

I'd take losing 50k-80k for keeping an extra trade.

You're not saving a trade. How this argument continues to get rolled out after being rebutted over and over is incredible.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Final Monday teams:
Geelong Cats v Hawthorn
Interchange; Caddy, Gregson, Kersten, Kolodjashnij.
Emergencies: Cowan, Menzel, Vardy.

Is Linc Mcarthy playing ?

 

[Raveneyes]

He also had 30 touches to drown out those clangers. He only had 30 touches twice last year. But I'm sure Shaw owners will continue to justify his game.

You're just justifying not having him, despite agreeing that he's a top 3 defender.

Well done on saving 50-80k if/when you do get him.