MVP Round 10 Votes vs Richmond

[eaglespremiers]

5. Mackenzie
4. Cox
3. Selwood
2. Naitanui
1. Kerr

Probably only Hill and Kennedy to mention outside of these players.

 

[Shupe]

5. Shuey
4. Hill
3. Mackenzie
2. Masten
1. Kennedy

I cannot bring myself to give Scooter votes, no matter how often he touches it.

 

[Agent93]

5) S. Selwood
4) D. Kerr
3) J. Hill
2) E. Mackenzie
1) S. Hurn

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Yes, opinions; but not sure how Hill can miss out making anybodies list.

5. Josh Hill
4. Mitch Brown
3. Chris Masten
2. Eric Mackenzie
1. Luke Shuey

 

[kane249]

5 Emac, shut out Riewoldt
4 Hill, tried all night
3 Kerr, tried his guts out
2 Kennedy, was limited in what he could do
1 S.Selwood, would be higher if he could kick and hit a target

 

[eaglespremiers]

Yes, opinions; but not sure how Hill can miss out making anybodies list.

Did his best work late, even if it was all good.
Game was over by the time he got into his stride.

 

[TassieEagle]

5. Emac
4. Hill
3. Naita
2. Cox
1. Shuey

HM: Game of Thrones ready to watch.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Did his best work late, even if it was all good.
Game was over by the time he got into his stride.

Disagree, but fair enough.

 

[Shupe]

Did his best work late, even if it was all good.
Game was over by the time he got into his stride.

Yet Cox has 9 disposals and three marks. And no goals. And gets 4 votes from you.

 

[ziad]

5. Hill for efort and work
4 Kerr our classiest but ageing
3. Emac
2. Brown while on, for effort
1. Glass who was solid

Masten? if you gave him one he would fumble it.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Yet Cox has 9 disposals and three marks. And no goals. And gets 4 votes from you.

Truth be told I think nobody bar Mackenzie probably deserved votes.
But I thought Cox and Naitanui were massive in the ruck and can only be rated down by the midfielders ineptness.
Granted they did little around the ground but they gave our midfielders first service (said mids then conspired to hand ball over to Richmond).

 

[eagles rule]

5>eMac
4>Brown
3>Naita
2>Masten
1>Kennedy

 

[PAdman]

5. Adam selwood
4. Mark lecras
3. Matt Priddis
2. Brad Sheppard
1. Jack Darling

 

[Shupe]

5. Adam selwood
4. Mark lecras
3. Matt Priddis
2. Brad Sheppard
1. Jack Darling

Why the **** not. Haha.

 

[Apollo2011]

5. Josh Hill
4. Luke Shuey
3. Eric Mckenzie
2. Mark Hutchings
1. Josh Kennedy

 

[Underdog]

But I thought Cox and Naitanui were massive in the ruck and can only be rated down by the midfielders ineptness.
Granted they did little around the ground but they gave our midfielders first service (said mids then conspired to hand ball over to Richmond).

You're right, they were outstanding in the ruck. They were not only tapping it to our players but in front of them in space. Our midfielders were truly appalling.

We lost because we couldn't win the clearances or even stop Richmond. For all the cheap disposals the midfielders accumulated, they were worthless - certainly not worthy of votes.

 

[placebo]

5. Emac
4. Hill
3. Shuey
2. Brown
1. Masten

 

[lmach]

5. Mackenzie
4. Brown
3. Masten
2. Hill
1. Kerr

 

[WCEbrody]

5.Mackenzie
4.Masten
3.Shuey
2.Brown
1.Hill

 

[beatlesmith]

HM: Game of Thrones ready to watch.

Watch the episode and then tell me that it's an honourable mention.

 

[wotdoiput]

5 McKenzie
4 Brown
3 Hill
2 Glass
1 Umm err umm Hutchings

 

[Gizza]

You're right, they were outstanding in the ruck. They were not only tapping it to our players but in front of them in space. Our midfielders were truly appalling.

We lost because we couldn't win the clearances or even stop Richmond. For all the cheap disposals the midfielders accumulated, they were worthless - certainly not worthy of votes.

Seriously. Has there ever before been such a domination in the ruck before? Yet we couldn't win a clearance to save our life. And on the odd occasion we did it was a rushed kick to no one. Any half decent midfield would have absolutely dominated with the ruck work tonight. Our midfield would have to be bottom 4 in the league just about.

 

[TassieEagle]

Watch the episode and then tell me that it's an honourable mention.

Spoilered for those yet to see it.

Spoiler

GoT only turned out to be the second biggest massacre I saw tonight

 

[erbenz]

God this is hard. Masten, Shuey and S. Selwood were among our hardest workers but weren't winning the ball where it counts and Kerr was classy without getting a lot of it.

As follows...

5. Mackenzie
4. Masten
3. Hill
2. Brown
1. Shuey

HM to: S. Selwood, Kennedy, Kerr and Butler, Cox/Naita's tapwork, Gaff's ball use

DM to: A. Selwood, Priddis, LeCras.

 

[Underdog]

Cox and Naitanui aren't in your top 9!?