Round 14 Discussion

[Blueboys11]

Will be zeros all round I would say. Which totally screws me this week in my league games from what was a commanding position after last night

Oh well

 

[reload141]

I doubt it, I guess if you had many cats and crows players of which I have one each, have put reserves on the field to prevent donuts on field. Awful tragedy that very few can fathom, but in fairness to this game, projected points isn't the answer I believe.

They are projected for a reason by their formula, it would be the fair way... or yearly average. Not just saying "Oh well those of you that have these players you get a 0" that would be unfair.

 

[Satan]

If they give me the average of Dangerfield and Ellis Yomen I will take that

Make danger cpt?
Can i say that?

 

[bato]

I doubt it, I guess if you had many cats and crows players of which I have one each, have put reserves on the field to prevent donuts on field. Awful tragedy that very few can fathom, but in fairness to this game, projected points isn't the answer I believe.

Yep same. Just chucked on Hamling for Smith, or maybe I should have left it considering Colq was my emergency? I guess they'll work it out soon enough.

 

[Krujan]

Projected points awarded you would thinnk.

Personally, I don't think this will happen. (I'm expecting doughnuts) But if it does, Danger would be a safe Sunday C with a projected score of 133 for those whose VC has scored less.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Projected points awarded you would thinnk.

Or give us two extra trades for all those who brought in bottomed out players with low averages. Smith etc

 

[Krujan]

I doubt it, I guess if you had many cats and crows players of which I have one each, have put reserves on the field to prevent donuts on field. Awful tragedy that very few can fathom, but in fairness to this game, projected points isn't the answer I believe.

I tend to agree with this, even though I have 4 players affected. 3 of them being premo's.

 

[NSWCROW]

All this seems irrelevant now ( to me at least )


Hug your loved ones peeps.


Got the C on Paddy fwiw

 

[Satan]

All this seems irrelevant now ( to me at least )


Hug your loved ones peeps.


Got the C on Paddy fwiw

Thinking of you and few other adelaide posters

 

[Krujan]

All this seems irrelevant now ( to me at least )


Hug your loved ones peeps.


Got the C on Paddy fwiw

Nice gesture, Crow. Every SC who takes their VC score this week should put the C on a Crows player that they have on the ground as a mark of respect for Philip Walsh and the Adelaide FC.

 

[Ingy]

Vale Phil Walsh

 

[Big Fozza]

Projected points awarded you would thinnk.

Would have to be this or yearly avg

 

[NSWCROW]

Thinking of you and few other adelaide posters

Nice gesture, Crow. Every SC who takes their VC score this week should put the C on a Crows player that they have on the ground as a mark of respect for Philip Walsh and the Adelaide FC.

Gotta say , reading the comments from all the other teams supporters has been truly humbling.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Very sad news for the Walsh family the crows and Footy in general.

Very much doubt we'll get SC av or prog scores for the non playing cats and crows players.

 

[FFB1]

Expecting donuts for the Ade and Gee players. Totally different circs but no different to if a player is injured or a late withdrawal.

 

[Werewolf]

How about awarding 75 points to every player who would have played that game?

Doesn't affect me that much (Dangerfield & Motlop), but donuts would be unfair.

 

[xisor]

Would have to be this or yearly avg

Projected points I reckon. There are 3 new players named on extended bench. If they actually get picked, they have no average.

RIP Phil Walsh.

 

[Woodie99]

Expecting donuts for the Ade and Gee players. Totally different circs but no different to if a player is injured or a late withdrawal.

Not sure, after all the AFL abandoned the game. They might just give the projected score. SC will have to decide how to handle this before tonight's game I would think.

 

[OhhDeledio]

Might be a bit inappropriate to ask, but if two players say in my backline don't play and I put the E on both of the players on the bench, will both of them score in place of the 2 that don't?

 

[Ingy]

It doesn't really matter what they do, it's going to advantage/disadvantage people randomly no matter what they do - luck will be the key factor as it always is. I just think they need to make it clear what they are going to do before tonight's game so that people can manage their sides and trade accordingly

 

[juddola]

I would think the fairest way is to maybe do something similar to the byes where only 20 players count give or take. No avg points will be given its a competition for money and potentially end up in court rooms if something like that happens.

 

[Jensen]

Maybe they could leave the scores as 0 but apply the bye scoring system.

 

[Woodie99]

Might be a bit inappropriate to ask, but if two players say in my backline don't play and I put the E on both of the players on the bench, will both of them score in place of the 2 that don't?

Yes

 

[Vapor]

FWIW I hope the Crows/Cats players are all given donuts as if it's a bye round because they aren't playing, it just doesn't seem right to me to give them their projected score or average.

Such a tragic day.

 

[Woodie99]

I would think the fairest way is to maybe do something similar to the byes where only 20 players count give or take. No avg points will be given its a competition for money and potentially end up in court rooms if something like that happens.

Doubt very much the terms & conditions of entering SC would be open to that. Final decision of the umpire & all that.