Round 6 Trades

[Outburst]

first option sounds best..

 

[lills]

Is it worth trading macintosh to simmonds (BE 8)

I've got McIntosh and was assuming I'd keep him to the end but it's getting really tempting to break a golden rule on this one. I've heard a rumour that he's playing with a niggle, and Simmonds looks like he's still decent value. I think a lot depends on how you'd use the extra 45k, for example it would allow me an upgrade to Riewoldt.

I still don't think I'll burn a trade on him, but not having had the chance to watch any Kangaroos games I don't really know how he's looking on the field and, more importantly, whether he'll be able to step up to an 80+ average.

 

[Stormer]

I would think Ellis >> Bradshaw is a bit of a sideways trade....we haven't seen the best from Ellis and he's definately improving. Limited TOG on the weekend hurt his score.

I agree that it's a sidewards trade but I think Ellis isn't ever gonan get heaps more time on ground. It's amazing that he's averaging so high with that much time on ground

 

[pillager]

Why is Ellis getting limited TOG? Is it due to Hawthorns depth?

If so, I am considering Ellis -----> Mcleod.

Ellis may have peaked after gaining 60k in value and Mcleod's value of 350k might be the cheapest I could get him.

Given the limited number of premium backs this year, Mcleod is ranked 7 overall amongst the backs and is a real playmaker for Adelaide... jump on him?

 

[Stormer]

I just don't think that Clarkson has faith in Ellis. If that changes Ellis could be in for a few very large scores

 

[force65]

Sorry...but what is the site to get the breakevens?

 

[horj89]

^^ http://www.fanfooty.com.au/
Then click on the New Price link of any match

Thinking of trading Kennelly for Goddard or Fisher. Which is the better option? In the long run I think Goddard will prove to be the better option. Thoughts?

Goddard $339,900
Last Rnd - 86
Average - 78
Total - 233

Fisher $339,500
Last Rnd - 100
Average - 82
Total - 413

 

[High Ryder]

Jon Brown should be a must in terms of trading in this week. Absolutely rediculous if you don't have him and dont trade him in.

 

[Unique]

Chad Cornes, Joel Bowden, Heath Shaw, Beau Waters, Brett Jones, Austin Wonaeamirri, Darren Pfeiffer, Nathan J. Brown, Harry Taylor

Jimmy Bartel, Kane Cornes, Matt Priddis, Nick Stevens, Phys Palmer, Chris Masten, Kieran Jack, Jarryn Geary

Dean Cox, Troy Simmonds, Trent West, Sean Hampson

Matthew Pavlich, Nick Riewoldt, Jonathan Brown, Des Headland, Brett Burton, Stuart Dew, Cyril Rioli, Josh Hill, Kurt Tippet

1. What is the best way for me to upgrade my rookies, and have the best team possible by the finals?

2. What trades should I do this round?

3. What rookies are ready to be traded?I HAVE SO MANY QUESTIONS!

 

[BigSudz]

What is the better midfield combination

Kornes & Griffen

or

Mitchell and Dal Santo?

 

[Stormer]

1st one.

 

[KouDogg]

Hey guys here is my team as it stands atm...i havn't done anything to it and i am worried about a couple of my players (B.Johnson, T.Cloke, Hill, Kennelly and Goodes).

If you were in my situation what would you do as far as trades go?

I have 15 trades left and have got 21,600 grand in the bank.

Thanks if you respond.

 

[daliman]

hey guys, trying to get my backline in order so interested to see what you think of these trades, currently have:

Shaw, Thornton, Symes, Birchall, McPharmlin, Nicoski, NJ Brown with Hartlett and SDThompson emergencies.

Looking to trade Nicoski and Hartlett ---> Goddard and T Pears but am short about 1K

The other rookies/cash cows i could trade out to make the Goddard trade are Tippett, Dew (will he play again?), Gamble, Kruezer, Palmer & C Morton but i am hesitatant to trade any of these as they are all still going up.

Thoughts????

 

[force65]

do u think it is the right time to do Mcintosh ----> Cox

 

[huggy_b]

do u think it is the right time to do Mcintosh ----> Cox

personally I think no, its too early. and I am sharing your frustration with McIntosh - hasn't produced as I would have expected.

 

[force65]

what is mcintoshs b/e

 

[Daz]

G'day guys just looking for opinions on what i can do with my team in terms of trading.

Trades Used: 2
Bank: 311,000

Backs: Cornes, Shaw, Birchall, Symes, Mattner, Ellis, Pfeiifer EMG: Proud, Scott DT

Mids: Cross, Murphy, Johnstone, Stevens, Houli, Palmer EMG: Masten Bird.

Rucks: Cox, Simmonds EMG: West, Meesen

Forwards: Pavlich, Riewoldt, Brown, Deledio, Porplyzia, Hill, Rioli EMG: Gamble, Tippet

I think ellis and hill have peaked (ellis one more week). I want to trade houli in two weeks (after that he plays sydney. Who should i target for this week to bring in. I have $311,000 and have only used two trades.

Cheers.

 

[Robo 123]

im really pissed
started last round in the top 500 but with some pathetic efforts im down to outside the top 1000
need some serious advice with my team
Backs
Shaw
P Bourgoyne
Birchall
Symes
Ellis
Gram
Pfeiffer
(Proud, Brown)

Cross
Judd
Salopek
Stevens
Dyson
Palmer
(Morton, Wonaemirri)

Cox
Simmonds
(Leuenberger, Meesen)

BJ
Jono Brown
Pavlich
Chapman
Porpz
Didak
Rioli
(Gamble, Tippett)

Have 17 trades left and 119K in the bank
Help Please

 

[Stormer]

Use all of it to upgrade Gram to whoever you like

The rest of your team looks fine

 

[Athomas]

This week trading:
Tuck to Ibboston/Hinkley/8th centre rookie, meh whoever I trade too won't get traded again this year anyway.

Tredrea to Riewoldt/Franklin.
Life's tough choices. Thinking Franklin but riskier. Same price.

 

[Robo 123]

Use all of it to upgrade Gram to whoever you like

The rest of your team looks fine

but i cant have the chad so im pissed

 

[Dee UK]

Not sure if I'll trade this week but if I do it will probably be:

Gram to a decent backman (any suggestions???)
Stevens to Judd

 

[courageous_tom]

im thinking of doing this trade this week

Out: J. Hill
R. Griffin

In: Riewoldt
B. Ebert

and then playing Rhys Palmer in Griffin's spot

any thoughts?

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Looking to offload a KPF for Paul Chapman.

I've got 22k in the bank, plus Franklin (378,000) (obviously not trading him), Lloyd (330,700), J. Brown(315,000), N. Thompson (209,200).

Chapman costs 410,700

Obviously I'd need to trade a cash cow as well. I was thinking C. Morton -> T Cotchin, but I'm not sure if Morton's peaked, or if Cotchin is ready.

Thoughts.

 

[kenny712]

Is it worth trading N.Stevens to Mitchell?